Styles, genres and technique

What is still life photography? From the Dutch table to the packshot

A woman wearing a green scarf listens to a man at an outdoor gathering.
Conversation at a gathering.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

It is the oldest subject in photography and the one that has paid the rent on most studios. It is also the genre least likely to get a retrospective. The reasons are connected.

Still life is the genre in which nobody blinks, nothing is late and every flaw in the picture is the photographer's own.

Still life photography is the photographing of objects that cannot move and have been put where they are on purpose. That is the whole definition, and it covers a daguerreotype of plaster casts from about 1840, a platinum print of cigarette ends in the Museum of Modern Art, and the picture of a shampoo bottle on the page where you last bought shampoo. Most accounts of the genre tell the museum half of that story. Ours starts from the other end: still life is the branch of photography that has most reliably paid for studios, and its history makes more sense when the advertising picture is treated as the main line and the art picture as the distinguished cousin. The hinge between the two, in Britain, was a New Yorker called Lester Bookbinder.

What is still life photography, exactly?

The J. Paul Getty Museum, which devoted an exhibition to the subject from 14 September 2010 to 23 January 2011, traces the term to the Dutch "stilleven", coined in the 17th century when paintings of objects were popular across Europe. Painters of the period set out bread, oysters, glass and silver on a table and painted them with an attention previously reserved for saints. Some of those pictures were displays of wealth. Others were warnings: the vanitas, a National Science and Media Museum essay reminds us, takes its name from the Latin for vanity or emptiness, and its skulls and guttering candles made the point that the owner of the silver would not own it for long.

Photography inherited all of it: the table, the side light, the taste for texture, the moral. What it added was a new relationship with time. A painter needs days to suggest that a moment has stopped. A camera stops it as a matter of course.

Three things distinguish still life from every other kind of photograph. The photographer chooses the subject and arranges it. The subject does not change unless the photographer changes it. And the session can last as long as the budget allows. Still life is the genre in which nobody blinks, nothing is late and every flaw in the picture is the photographer's own.

Why were the earliest photographs still lifes?

Necessity. The first processes were slow, and living sitters could not hold still long enough. The Getty notes that still life was central to the experiments of both Louis Daguerre and William Henry Fox Talbot for exactly this reason, and its exhibition included a daguerreotype by Baron Armand-Pierre Séguier, Still Life with Plaster Casts, dated 1839 to 1842. Roy Exley, writing for the National Science and Media Museum, calls the genre "a test bed for early photography", and points to Talbot's A Fruit Piece, a salt print published in The Pencil of Nature in 1845.

The line continues through Charles Aubry's arrangement of tobacco leaves and grass of about 1864, Baron Adolf de Meyer's Glass and Shadows of 1905, André Kertész's Bowl with Sugar Cubes of 1928, Man Ray's Dead Leaf of 1942 and Horst P. Horst's Gloves, New York of 1947. Notice how often the subject is something for sale or something from the kitchen. The art-historical story and the commercial one were never far apart.

When did still life become advertising?

As soon as magazines could print photographs well and manufacturers had brands to distinguish. By the middle of the 20th century the same photographers were doing both. Irving Penn is the standard example: The Irving Penn Foundation records that when magazine editors in the early 1950s found his photographs too severe and cut his assignments, he turned to advertising. His Cigarettes series of 1972, pictures of discarded butts printed in platinum, was shown at the Museum of Modern Art in 1975. The Getty lists a Penn still life among its acquisitions.

The economics explain the shift. A fashion sitting needs a model, a hairdresser, an editor and luck. A still life needs a table. A client who wants a bottle of whisky to look like the only bottle of whisky in the world is paying for time and control, which are precisely the two things the genre offers. Studios that could deliver them were never short of work.

Who was Lester Bookbinder, and why does he matter here?

Bookbinder was born in New York City in 1929, trained with the photographer Reuben Samberg, opened his own studio in New York in 1955 and moved to London around 1959. He became a regular contributor to Vogue, Queen and Nova, lectured at the Royal College of Art, and built a reputation in advertising that the art director Dave Dye has documented at length from the recollections of people who worked with him. He died on 9 January 2017.

The client list in Dye's account reads like a history of British advertising: Collett Dickenson Pearce campaigns for Ford, Harvey's Bristol Cream, Whitbread and Clark's Shoes; White Horse whisky; images for the Victoria and Albert Museum commissioned by Paul Arden at Saatchi & Saatchi; a late campaign for the Volkswagen Corrado, for which he shot through bendable reflective perspex to control distortion in camera.

The anecdotes are about exactitude. A set art director, Martin Hill, recalled that Bookbinder noticed wallpaper joins and blemishes in skirting boards and used a carbon arc light to show up imperfections. The art director Ron Collins described him spending about six hours on a still life of a beer bottle and, when Collins nudged the glass, leaving the room and returning with an instruction, which was that Collins might talk and point but must not touch.

What makes him the hinge of this story is his refusal of the art label. Interviewed by Robert Waterhouse for Design Journal in 1971, he said: "I am by definition a commercial photographer, not an artist by any stretch of the imagination." He credited himself only with "the ability to see near beauty in trivia". And, in the same interview: "Look. I take photography seriously, but not myself." It is hard to think of a better statement of the still-life photographer's position. The work is done to the standard of a museum piece, for a client, on a deadline, and then it is printed next to the crossword.

Bookbinder also explains why the genre lacks retrospectives. Advertising pictures belong, in practice, to campaigns that end; the transparencies go to the agency or the client; the photographer's name is seldom printed. His moving-image work has fared a little better: he directed commercials and the video for Dire Straits' "Romeo and Juliet".

What is a packshot?

A packshot is a still life with a job description. The word comes from advertising and means a clear picture of the product, usually in or with its packaging, made so that a buyer can recognise it on a shelf or a screen. It is the plainest and most numerous kind of still life, and the one with the strictest rules:

  • The product must be accurate in colour, proportion and label.
  • The lighting should describe the material: gloss as gloss, glass as glass, card as card.
  • The background is neutral, often white, so the picture can be cut out and reused.
  • Nothing in the frame should compete with the name.

Between the packshot and the art still life lies a wide middle ground of editorial still life: the page of lipsticks arranged by shade, the shoes laid out for the autumn issue, the food feature. This is where a photographer has both a product to show and room to play, and where the genre's wit usually turns up. Guy Bourdin's shoe campaigns are the extreme case, and we look at them in the shoe and the crime scene.

Kind Purpose Who decides Typical afterlife
Art still life The picture itself The photographer Exhibition, collection
Editorial still life Illustrate a feature Photographer with an editor One issue, then the archive
Advertising still life Persuade Agency and client The length of the campaign
Packshot Identify The brand's guidelines Catalogues, packaging, web listings

Why does still life matter to AI and data teams?

Because still life is the cleanest visual data there is. One object or a small group, deliberately lit, sharply focused, against a controlled background, with the photographer's whole effort spent on making material legible: metal, glass, liquid, leather, chocolate. For anyone building or evaluating models that must understand products and surfaces, that is close to ideal, provided the provenance and the rights are in order. Our article on product photography datasets for multimodal models goes into what developers look for, and the AI training data licensing pages explain how enquiries to this archive work. Licences are negotiated directly with the single rights holder and are subject to rights review.

What does the Robert Harper archive hold?

A great deal of still life, which is no surprise: Robert Harper spent two years at the Condé Nast studios assisting Lester Bookbinder, as well as David Bailey and Helmut Newton, before running his own London studio. The record says nothing more about what he did for Bookbinder, and we will not guess. What can be said is what the inventory lists: 23 food folders with 1,521 unique shots, 26 perfume folders, 20 jewellery folders, 43 shoe folders, 12 drinks folders, and a Cinzano shoot recorded on 10 x 8 inch transparencies with 19 Polaroids alongside. The principal format is 6 x 7 colour transparency film, and more than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned.

The advertising collection and the food collection are the places to start, our pieces on photographing fragrance bottles and jewellery lighting on film go further into technique, and the photographers index has an entry on Bookbinder. If you are planning to scan transparencies of this kind, the free scan resolution calculator will tell you what a 6 x 7 frame yields.

Agencies, publishers and researchers who would like to see still life material from the library can start at the page for picture agencies.

Frequently asked questions

What is still life photography?

Still life photography is the photographing of inanimate objects that the photographer has chosen and arranged: food, flowers, glass, tools, products. Unlike most genres, everything in the frame is under the photographer's control, including position, light and time. It covers fine art work, editorial illustration and commercial product photography, and the same techniques serve all three.

What is the difference between still life and product photography?

Product photography is still life with a commercial brief. A still life can be about light, time or decay and need not sell anything. A product photograph must show a specific item accurately and attractively for a client. The purest form, the packshot, shows the product and its packaging plainly, often on a white or neutral background, so buyers can recognise it.

Why were the first photographs often still lifes?

Because the early processes were slow. Exposures in the late 1830s and 1840s could last minutes, which made living sitters impractical. Plaster casts, fruit, books and glassware would hold still indefinitely and could be placed in good light. The J. Paul Getty Museum notes that still life was central to the experiments of both Daguerre and Talbot for this reason.

Who was Lester Bookbinder?

Lester Bookbinder was a New York-born photographer and commercials director, born in 1929, who worked in Britain from about 1959 and died on 9 January 2017. He contributed to Vogue, Queen and Nova and became known for exacting advertising still lifes for agencies such as Collett Dickenson Pearce. He also directed the video for Dire Straits' 'Romeo and Juliet'.

What equipment is used for still life photography?

Historically, large and medium-format cameras on a stand, because movements and a big film area give control over focus and detail, with tungsten lights or studio flash shaped by reflectors, diffusers and black card. Before digital capture, studios checked each set-up on Polaroid instant film. Today the camera is usually digital, but the stand, the cards and the patience are unchanged.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive