Styles, genres and technique

Editorial and advertising photography: how one studio shot both

A man in a dark overcoat and hat stands on a staircase beneath framed pictures.
Portrait on a staircase.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

The camera, the film and often the photographer were the same. What changed between a magazine job and a campaign was the number of people who had to say yes before the shutter was pressed.

An editorial picture has to please an editor once; an advertising picture has to survive a meeting, and it shows.

The difference between editorial and advertising photography is not the camera, the lighting or the talent. It is who has to approve the picture before it exists. A magazine photograph answers to an editor and an art director who want to be surprised. An advertising photograph answers to an agency and a client who have already agreed, in a meeting, what the surprise will be. Most explanations of the two terms are really about licensing: what a picture may be used for afterwards. This one is about style and working method: what the two kinds of job felt like from behind the camera, why the same studio could do both, and how to tell them apart when all you have is the photograph. (For the licensing side, see our separate guide to editorial versus commercial image use.)

What is editorial photography?

Editorial photography is made for a publication's own pages: the fashion story, the portrait that runs with a profile, the still life illustrating a feature on autumn lipsticks. The commissioner is the magazine. The brief is often a sentence and a list of clothes. The people in the room are the photographer and assistants, a fashion or features editor, perhaps the art director, and whoever is being photographed.

Three things follow. The fee is modest, because the magazine pays partly in credit and freedom. The idea usually belongs to the photographer or is shaped with the editor on the day. And the picture is finished when the editor likes it. Michael Rand, art director of The Sunday Times Magazine for thirty years from its launch in 1962, described his credo as "grit plus glamour", and a credo is about as detailed as editorial direction traditionally got.

Freedom has limits. The Irving Penn Foundation records that in the early 1950s magazine editors found Penn's photographs too severe and cut his assignments. Editorial latitude is a loan, and editors can call it in.

What is advertising photography?

Advertising photography is made to sell a product or a brand in space that somebody has paid for. The commissioner is the brand, normally through an advertising agency. By the time a photographer is hired, the agency's creative team has usually sold the client a layout: a drawing of the finished advertisement showing where the product, the headline and the logo will sit. The photographer's task is to make that drawing real, and better than the drawing.

The room is more crowded: the agency art director, sometimes a copywriter and an account handler, sometimes the client, a stylist or home economist, a set builder. The budget is larger, because it has to cover all of them and because the fee reflects what the picture will be used for. The schedule is longer for each image and the tolerance for accident is lower.

Dave Dye's collected recollections of Lester Bookbinder, one of the leading advertising still-life photographers in London, give the flavour. One art director remembered Bookbinder spending about six hours setting up a single beer-bottle still life. A set art director recalled hand-stencilled wallpaper and a carbon arc light used to reveal flaws. Bookbinder was clear about what kind of work this was: "I am by definition a commercial photographer, not an artist by any stretch of the imagination," he told Design Journal in 1971.

Editorial vs advertising photography: what is the difference in practice?

Editorial Advertising
Commissioned by A publication A brand, usually through an agency
Purpose Illustrate the publication's own content Sell or promote
Brief Loose: a theme, a sitter, a rail of clothes Tight: an approved layout to match
Who approves Editor and art director Agency art director, then the client
Typical budget Modest fee, expenses Larger fee tied to how the picture is used
Creative latitude High, within the magazine's taste Narrow, unless the client grants more
Product in the picture Present among other things The reason for the picture
Credit Photographer usually named on the page Photographer usually unnamed
Rules that bite The publication's own standards Advertising codes, such as the CAP Code in the UK
What survives Tear sheets, outtakes, contact sheets Final transparencies, test Polaroids, layouts

The last row matters to archives and we come back to it below.

Who signs off the Polaroid?

Before digital capture, every studio had the same moment of truth. The set was built and lit, the camera was loaded with an instant-film back, and a test exposure was peeled apart and passed round. On a magazine job the photographer and the editor looked at it, argued about a collar, and carried on. On an advertising job the Polaroid went to the art director, who held it against the layout, and then, if the client was present, to the client. Only when everyone had agreed did the photographer change backs and expose transparency film.

That small ritual is the whole difference in miniature. An editorial picture has to please an editor once; an advertising picture has to survive a meeting, and it shows. It shows in a certain completeness: nothing in an advertising photograph is there by chance, because chance was eliminated at the Polaroid stage. Our article on Polaroid proofing before digital explains the equipment and the film.

Why did the same studios do both?

Because each paid for the other. Magazine work brought a photographer's name before art directors every month, with a credit beside the picture. Advertising work paid the rent, the assistants and the film bill. A studio that only shot editorial tended to be poor; one that only shot advertising tended to be anonymous. The Helmut Newton Foundation describes Newton as a photographer who "straddled the gap between art and commerce", and the phrase would fit most of the notable studios of the period.

The two kinds of work also trained each other. Advertising taught a precision that made editorial still lifes sharper. Editorial taught a looseness that the best agency art directors wanted to buy. Now and then a client simply handed over the keys: Roland Jourdan, who commissioned Guy Bourdin's shoe advertising from 1967, said in 1995 that "we had to protect him because he was a true artist". The story of Bourdin and Charles Jourdan is what advertising looks like with editorial freedom.

How can you tell an editorial picture from an advertisement?

When the page it was printed on survives, read the page. When only the photograph survives, look for these signs. None is conclusive on its own.

  • Space for words. Advertising pictures are often composed with an empty area where the headline and logo were to go. Editorial pictures are composed to the edge.
  • One hero. In an advertisement a single product is lit to be the most important thing in the frame. In an editorial still life several products share the light.
  • The label faces you. Packs and bottles in advertising are turned square to camera with the name legible.
  • Format. Campaign work was often shot on larger film than magazine work, because posters and double-page spreads needed the detail.
  • The paperwork. Layouts, agency job numbers and client names on the sleeve are the best evidence of all.

People who look after archives, and people who assemble image datasets, need this distinction for a practical reason. Advertising pictures are more likely to feature a recognisable brand as the subject, and UK advertising rules urge marketers to get permission before implying that a person approves a product (CAP Code rule 6.1). What a picture was made for affects the questions to ask before it is used again. Copyright is a separate matter: the Intellectual Property Office's guidance is that copyright in a commissioned professional photograph usually remains with the photographer, and our piece on the four sets of rights in a fashion picture takes that apart layer by layer.

What does the Robert Harper archive show of both kinds?

It shows a studio that did both for decades, which is the reason for this article. Robert Harper was a regular contributor to Elle and The Telegraph Magazine for more than fifteen years, and his work appeared in Vogue, Tatler, Cosmopolitan, Esquire, The Face, Wallpaper and Harpers & Queen. Over the same years his commercial clients included De Beers, Harrods, Selfridges, Boots, Heinz, Diageo, the BBC, CBS Records and Montblanc. We cannot tell you what a given week in the studio looked like, and will not pretend to. The inventory, though, records both sides of the practice:

  • Editorial: 88 catalogued magazine fashion set-ups across 389 frames; 79 fashion set-ups and group shots; and a folder of printed magazine and newspaper pages (79 shots, 364 frames) from titles including Elle, Esquire, Cosmopolitan, Vogue, Wallpaper, The Face and Harpers & Queen.
  • Advertising: a folder catalogued simply as advertising (74 shots, 355 frames), and a Cinzano shoot recorded on three film sizes: 10 x 8 inch transparencies with 19 Polaroids, 5 x 4 inch film, and 6 x 7 cm film.
  • Both at once: 4,005 unique Polaroid prints, the residue of years of sign-offs.

The Cinzano folder is the format point above made concrete: the same subject on sheet film for the big uses and on roll film alongside. The advertising collection and the fashion collection are the places to start, and the complete archive inventory is searchable. More than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned, so which frames were commissioned by whom is, in many cases, still to be established from the sleeves. If you are checking what a scanned file says about itself, the free EXIF viewer reads embedded captions and credits in the browser.

Picture editors, agencies and researchers who want to see either kind of work can begin at the page for picture agencies.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between editorial and advertising photography?

Editorial photography is commissioned by a publication to illustrate its own content, such as a fashion story or a feature, and is approved by the magazine's editor and art director. Advertising photography is commissioned by a brand, usually through an agency, to sell something, and must be approved by the agency and the client. The second has more money, more people and less room for surprise.

Do photographers earn more from advertising than editorial?

As a rule, yes. Magazine fees have historically been modest because the publication offers exposure, credit and creative freedom. Advertising pays for the photographer's time and for the right to use the picture in paid media, so fees are higher and scale with the campaign. Many studios have used advertising income to subsidise editorial work that builds their reputation.

Who has the final say on an advertising photograph?

The client, through the agency. The agency's art director brings an agreed layout to the shoot and directs the photographer towards it; an account handler or the client may attend. Before digital capture, the approval point was the Polaroid test print: once the people in the room agreed that it matched the layout, the photographer exposed the film.

Can the same photograph be both editorial and advertising?

A picture made for a magazine can later be licensed for advertising only if the necessary permissions exist, because advertising use raises questions about models, brands and endorsement that editorial use does not. That is a licensing matter, separate from style. Our article on editorial versus commercial image use explains the distinction and the UK advertising rules on implied endorsement.

Is editorial photography more creative than advertising?

It usually offers more freedom, which is not the same thing. Editorial lets a photographer propose the idea; advertising hands over a problem with fixed terms. Some of the most inventive pictures of the last century were advertisements, including Guy Bourdin's shoe campaigns for Charles Jourdan, made for a client who gave him unusual latitude.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive