Styles, genres and technique

Guy Bourdin, the shoe and the crime scene

Two women and a man in a dinner jacket pose beneath festive decorations.
Three guests at an evening gathering.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

From 1967 a French shoe company let a photographer make its advertisements about almost anything except how the shoes looked on a foot. Accessory photography has been living with the consequences ever since.

Bourdin's discovery was that a shoe is more memorable as evidence than as merchandise.

In March 1975 the French weekly Jours de France carried a photograph of a pavement. On it was the chalk outline of a woman's body, the kind police draw, and beside it a spill of pink shoes. No woman, no price, no description of the leather. The image is by Guy Bourdin and is generally grouped with the advertising he made for the shoe company Charles Jourdan, and it reportedly drew outrage and disgust. It also did what advertisements exist to do: people looked at it for a long time.

The usual way to write about Bourdin is as a surrealist who happened to work in fashion. Our angle is narrower and, we think, more useful: he solved a specific commercial problem that every accessory photographer faces, which is that a shoe on its own is a small, inert object, and the solution he found has shaped how handbags, watches, perfume and shoes have been photographed ever since.

Who was Guy Bourdin?

Bourdin was born in Paris on 2 December 1928. He received his first photographic training as an aerial photographer during air force service in Dakar in 1948 and 1949. Back in Paris he sought out Man Ray, who wrote the introduction for an exhibition of his photographs at Galerie 29 in 1952. His first fashion pictures were published in French Vogue in February 1955, and he went on working for the magazine into the late 1980s, a run of some thirty years.

He was not a public figure and seems to have wanted it that way. He exhibited in small Paris galleries in the 1950s, once under a pseudonym, but his mature work appeared almost entirely on magazine pages and the books about him are posthumous. In 1985 he turned down the Grand Prix National de la Photographie. A 1987 campaign for Chanel won him the International Center of Photography's Infinity Award in 1988. He died in Paris in 1991, aged 62. The Victoria and Albert Museum gave him his first retrospective in 2003, and Tate acquired 27 works in 2014.

How did the Charles Jourdan campaigns begin?

With a magazine cover. Roland Jourdan, son of Charles Jourdan, who had founded the shoe business in 1921, is reported to have noticed Bourdin's cover for French Vogue of March 1966: a red miniskirt, red tights and red Pierre Cardin shoes. He hired the photographer, and from 1967 Bourdin made the company's advertising, effectively acting as its creative director.

The dates of the end are less settled than the beginning. Bourdin's Wikipedia biography gives 1967 to 1981. An account drawing on the Rizzoli volume Guy Bourdin for Charles Jourdan (216 pages, 150 colour photographs) describes a twelve-year collaboration ending in 1979. We give both and prefer neither.

What is agreed is the unusual nature of the arrangement. Roland Jourdan is said not to have rejected any of Bourdin's proposals, even when he hesitated. In 1995 he explained why: "We had to protect him because he was a true artist." He added, a little ruefully: "Today, I would not be able to work like I did with him." The campaigns ran in prominent positions in magazines including French Vogue and Harper's Bazaar, season after season, so that readers came to expect the next instalment.

What did the Charles Jourdan adverts look like?

Like stills from films nobody had made. A few documented examples:

  • The corridor (late 1960s). A gigantic yellow shoe stands in a hotel corridor among the men's black loafers left outside bedroom doors.
  • The miniature. A model toys with a tiny red shoe that matches her nails and lipstick.
  • The chalk outline (1975). Pink shoes scattered on a pavement beside the outline of a body.
  • Walking Legs (1979). On a road trip from London to Brighton, Bourdin photographed mannequin legs wearing Jourdan shoes in deserted locations: no torso, no model, only the legs and what they stood in. The Michael Hoppen Gallery in London exhibited the series in 2015.

The constants are saturated colour, a hard gloss, a single eccentric idea, and an absent or fragmentary person. The shoe is always in the picture and never the point of it.

Why did turning the product into the plot work?

Consider the problem. A shoe is about twenty-five centimetres long. Photographed straightforwardly it is a packshot: accurate, useful and forgettable. Photographed on a model it competes with a face, a dress and a setting, and usually loses. For most of the century advertisers split the difference with a pretty foot on a step.

Bourdin's answer was to make the shoe a clue. If a picture asks "what happened here?", the viewer searches the frame for evidence, and the only evidence is the product. Attention that would have gone to a model's face goes to a few pink shoes because they are all that is left of her. Bourdin's discovery was that a shoe is more memorable as evidence than as merchandise.

Two other things made it work. One was seriality: a new episode each season trained readers to look for the Jourdan page. The other was restraint of information. The pictures explain nothing, and an unexplained image stays in the mind longer than an explained one. That is not a law of psychology we can cite a paper for; it is the working assumption of every art director who has borrowed the method since.

It should be said that the pictures have always had critics. The fragmented bodies, the hints of violence and the doll-like women trouble many viewers now as they did in 1975, and Bourdin is frequently paired in that argument with Helmut Newton, his contemporary at French Vogue, whom the Helmut Newton Foundation describes as a photographer who "always managed to surprise and polarize his audience". The two are compared in most histories of the period; our piece on Bailey and Newton sets out Newton's method.

What did Bourdin change for accessory still life?

Before him the accessory picture came in two kinds, described in our guide to what still life photography is: the packshot, which identifies, and the arranged still life, which flatters. After him there was a third kind, the narrative still life, in which an object is given a situation.

Before Bourdin After Bourdin
Role of the product Subject Clue
Model A whole person wearing the item A fragment, a mannequin, or nobody
Setting Studio or tasteful location A scene with implied events
What the reader does Recognises Deduces
Client's risk Low High, and repaid in attention

The influence is easiest to see in the things that became normal: legs without bodies, handbags abandoned on car seats, perfume bottles in rooms someone has just left. It is also visible in what art directors began to ask of still-life photographers generally. The exacting London tradition represented by Lester Bookbinder, who by one colleague's account spent about six hours arranging a single beer bottle, was a tradition of perfect description. Bourdin showed that a product could be perfectly lit and also be implicated in something.

For collectors and galleries the campaigns raise a further point of interest. They were advertisements, made for hire and printed in mass-circulation magazines, yet examples of his work are now in Tate's collection and are shown by commercial galleries. They are among the clearest cases of commercial photography crossing into the museum unaltered. This article is general information, not financial or legal advice, and we make no comment on prices.

Where can you see Bourdin's work?

Tate holds the 27 works acquired in 2014, and the V&A staged the 2003 retrospective. The Rizzoli book reproduces the Jourdan campaigns at length. Our photographers index includes an entry on Bourdin, and the photography directory lists galleries and museums, in London and elsewhere, that show fashion photography.

What does the Robert Harper archive hold on shoes?

Nothing by Bourdin, and no recorded connection with him: Robert Harper's documented training was in London, under David Bailey, Helmut Newton and Lester Bookbinder at the Condé Nast studios. What the library does hold is a large body of the genre Bourdin transformed. The inventory lists 43 shoe folders with 1,891 unique shots across 6,830 frames, along with 23 folders of bags, 26 of perfumes and 20 of jewellery, made for magazines and commercial clients over about thirty-five years and mostly on 6 x 7 colour transparency film. Designer footwear is one of the catalogue's 24 principal categories.

Which of those frames are packshots, which are arranged still lifes and which, if any, tell stories is something the catalogue cannot yet say, because more than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned. That is the honest state of things, and for a researcher it is the attraction. The fashion collection and the advertising collection are the starting points, and the whole archive inventory can be searched by folder. If you are comparing colour between scans of glossy accessories, the free colour palette generator will pull the dominant hues from an image in the browser.

Curators, galleries and picture researchers who would like to look at the footwear material can ask for professional access.

Frequently asked questions

When did Guy Bourdin work for Charles Jourdan?

Bourdin began photographing Charles Jourdan's advertising in 1967. Sources differ on the end date: his Wikipedia biography gives 1967 to 1981, while an account based on the Rizzoli book Guy Bourdin for Charles Jourdan describes a twelve-year collaboration from 1967 to 1979. The best-known campaigns, including Walking Legs, date from the 1970s.

Why are Guy Bourdin's shoe adverts famous?

Because they reversed the usual order of advertising. Instead of describing the product, each picture staged a small, strange story in which the shoes were a detail: a chalk outline on a pavement, a pair of legs with no body, a giant shoe in a hotel corridor. The viewer had to work out what had happened, and remembered the brand for making them do it.

What is Guy Bourdin's Walking Legs?

Walking Legs is the name given to Bourdin's 1979 Charles Jourdan campaign, photographed on a road trip from London to Brighton. In place of models he used mannequin legs wearing Jourdan shoes, set down in deserted locations so that the shoes appear to be walking by themselves. The series was exhibited at the Michael Hoppen Gallery in London in 2015.

Who hired Guy Bourdin at Charles Jourdan?

Roland Jourdan, son of the founder Charles Jourdan, who established the shoe company in 1921. He is reported to have noticed Bourdin's March 1966 French Vogue cover, which showed a red miniskirt, red tights and red Pierre Cardin shoes. Roland Jourdan is said never to have rejected one of Bourdin's proposals, even when he hesitated.

Did Guy Bourdin exhibit or publish books in his lifetime?

He showed drawings, paintings and photographs in Paris galleries in the 1950s, with a catalogue introduction by Man Ray for a 1952 exhibition. But he published his fashion and advertising work almost entirely in magazines, and the books devoted to him are posthumous. In 1985 he turned down the French Grand Prix National de la Photographie. His first retrospective came in 2003.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive