Picture research and licensing

Editorial versus commercial image use explained

A woman poses beside a yellow sports car against a plain studio background.
Studio composition with a yellow sports car.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

Editorial use tells a story about the subject of a picture. Commercial use borrows the subject to sell something else. Most licensing problems start in the gap between the two.

Editorial use is use of a picture to inform, report on or discuss the thing it shows. Commercial use is use of a picture to promote a product, service, organisation or cause. The same photograph of a musician on stage can be editorial in a biography and commercial on a poster for a headphone brand, and the permissions needed for the second are wider than for the first.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Checked on 18 November 2026. It explains how the picture industry uses the two terms and where UK law touches them. It does not tell you whether a particular use is lawful.

Where does the editorial and commercial distinction come from?

Not from the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, which does not sort uses into those two boxes. The distinction is a working convention of picture libraries, written into licences. It exists because a photograph involves at least two sets of interests:

  1. Copyright in the photograph, held by the photographer or whoever now owns the rights.
  2. Rights and interests in what is shown: people, trade marks, products, artworks, buildings, private property.

A picture library can license the first. It can only license the second if it holds a release or other permission from the person or company concerned. "Editorial use only" is the industry's shorthand for "we are licensing the copyright; we are not telling you the subject has agreed to promote anything".

What counts as editorial use?

Typical editorial contexts are newspapers and magazines, non-fiction books, documentaries, museum displays, textbooks and academic work. The common thread is that the picture is there because the content is about its subject, or about the period, event or idea it records.

Two cautions apply. Editorial does not mean exempt from copyright: a newspaper needs a licence as much as an advertiser does. The UK's fair dealing exception for reporting current events expressly excludes photographs (section 30(2) of the 1988 Act), and the exception for criticism or review is conditional on the dealing being fair and acknowledged. Nor does editorial mean anything goes. Archive.London's image subjects, brands and personalities disclaimer makes the point that calling a use editorial, documentary or educational does not make it lawful by itself; context, accuracy and the rights involved all matter.

What counts as commercial use?

Advertising in any medium, sponsored content, packaging, point of sale, brochures, corporate websites and social accounts that promote the organisation, merchandise and products for resale. The test most libraries apply is purpose: is the picture helping to sell or promote something other than the editorial work it appears in?

Commercial use raises the stakes for third-party rights because it risks suggesting that the person or brand in the picture endorses the advertiser.

What does UK law say about using someone's image?

There is no single rule, which surprises people used to the publicity rights of some US states. In Fenty v Arcadia Group Brands Ltd [2015] EWCA Civ 3, the Court of Appeal confirmed that English law gives a celebrity no general right to control the use of their name or image. Rihanna nonetheless won, in passing off: the court upheld the finding that a Topshop T-shirt bearing her photograph was likely to make buyers think she had approved it. Lord Justice Underhill called the case "close to the borderline", and the outcome turned on its particular facts.

Several other areas of law can also be engaged, depending on the use: misuse of private information, data protection, defamation, trade mark law, and copyright in any artwork visible in the frame. Section 85 of the 1988 Act also gives a person who commissioned a photograph for private and domestic purposes a right not to have copies issued to the public.

Alongside the law sit the advertising codes. Rule 6.1 of the CAP Code urges marketers to obtain written permission before referring to or portraying a member of the public, referring to a person with a public profile, or implying any personal approval of the advertised product. The Advertising Standards Authority's guidance says the principle applies whether the person is a private individual or well known.

None of this is a formula. It is the reason commercial uses get a rights review and editorial uses usually get a lighter one.

The grey areas researchers actually meet

Use Usual treatment Why it is debated
Inside pages of a non-fiction book Editorial Settled in practice
Book cover or film poster Varies by licensor The cover promotes the product as well as describing it
Documentary programme Editorial Trailers and promotional stills may be treated separately
Brand's own heritage book or anniversary exhibition Often commercial or "corporate" The publisher is the brand, and the purpose is partly promotional
Brand's social media post about its history Usually commercial Promotes the account owner
Museum exhibition Editorial or cultural Merchandise in the shop is commercial
Fine art print for sale Its own category The photograph is the product
Charity fundraising appeal Often commercial Non-profit status does not change the purpose

The lesson of the table is to describe the use, not the label. "Editorial" in an enquiry tells a licensor much less than "half page inside a 3,000-copy illustrated history, plus one Instagram post from the publisher's account".

How do rights-managed and royalty-free fit in?

They are a different axis. Rights-managed and royalty-free describe how a licence is priced and scoped: by specific use, or by a one-off fee for broad repeated use. Editorial and commercial describe the kind of use permitted. A royalty-free stock picture can be marked editorial only; a rights-managed archive picture can, with the right permissions, be licensed for an advertisement. Our guide to licensing a photograph for a book compares the two pricing models in a table.

Archive.London's position in plain terms

The Archive.London image licensing terms take the conventional approach and state it without hedging:

  • A licence covers only the photographic copyright permission described in the written Licence Confirmation.
  • No model, property, trade mark, artwork, privacy or publicity release is provided unless the confirmation expressly says so.
  • Editorial licences do not authorise commercial endorsement.
  • Commercial and promotional uses require express written approval and appropriate clearances, and the licensee decides which third-party permissions its use needs and obtains them.
  • Without prior written approval, images may not be used to endorse products, causes or political campaigns, on merchandise for resale, or as a logo or brand identifier.
  • AI training and related machine uses are outside every standard licence and need a separate agreement.

This matters for an archive of this kind. The Robert Harper Photograph Library includes portraits and music photographs of named people, and still lifes in which fragrance bottles, watches and other branded products are the subject. The catalogue records what is depicted. It does not imply that any person or brand commissioned, approved or endorses the archive, and the presence of a product in a picture is not evidence of a commission.

A quick self-check before you enquire

  • Is the picture illustrating content about its subject, or promoting something else?
  • Who is the publisher of the use: a media organisation, or a brand?
  • Is anyone identifiable? Is any brand, artwork or private property prominent?
  • Could a reasonable viewer think the person or brand shown is backing a product?
  • Will the picture be altered, cropped tightly or combined with other images?

If any answer gives you pause, say so in the brief. Licensors would much rather discuss a difficult use at the start than discover it in print. Producers working with music material will find the same questions applied to film and television in our piece on clearing music photographs for documentaries.

Asking about a specific use

The Robert Harper Photograph Library is held by a single rights holder, 825 Ventures Ltd, and licences are negotiated directly, subject to rights review. If you have an editorial or commercial use in mind and want to know whether it can be considered, describe it through professional access and include the layout or context if you have one.

Frequently asked questions

What does editorial use only mean?

It means the licensor is offering the picture to illustrate news, commentary, education or other content about its subject, and is not offering it for advertising, promotion, merchandise or endorsement. The label usually signals that no model, property or trade mark releases are held. It is a contractual limit set by the licensor, so the precise meaning is whatever that licensor's terms say.

Can I use an editorial image in an advertisement if I pay more?

Not by payment alone. The licensor would need to agree a commercial licence, and you would also need to consider permissions from anyone or anything depicted, such as a person, a brand owner or an artist. A higher fee to the photographer's rights holder does not buy rights that belong to somebody else.

Is social media use editorial or commercial?

It depends on who is posting and why. A publisher sharing a story on its own channel is usually closer to editorial. A brand posting a picture on its account to promote itself is usually treated as commercial, even if nothing is for sale in the post. Describe the account and purpose when you ask for a licence.

Do I need a model release in the UK?

UK law does not set out a general requirement for a model release, and there is no single image right. But identifiable people can have claims in passing off, privacy, data protection or defamation depending on the use, and the advertising codes urge written permission. For commercial uses, advertisers and their lawyers normally expect documented consent.

Are Archive.London images released for commercial use?

The archive does not state that releases exist. Its published position is that no model, property, trade mark or other third-party release is provided unless a written Licence Confirmation expressly confirms one. Commercial and promotional uses are considered case by case, subject to rights review, and the licensee is responsible for any further permissions its use requires.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive