Styles, genres and technique

Penn and Avedon: the still and the restless

Two men stand together in a pub, one holding a glass of beer.
Portrait in a pub.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

Both studied under the same teacher, worked for the same magazines and stood people in front of plain backgrounds. One used the blankness to calm the sitter. The other used it to leave them nowhere to go.

Penn built a quiet room and waited for the sitter to settle; Avedon built a blank one and photographed what happened when they could not.

Irving Penn and Richard Avedon had the same teacher, Alexey Brodovitch, worked for the same handful of magazines, and are both remembered for photographing people against nothing much. It is tempting to treat them as two versions of one mid-century American minimalism. They were closer to opposites. Our argument is that the plain background, which looks like the thing they share, is where they differ most: Penn used an empty studio to lower the temperature of a sitting, and Avedon used one to raise it. Seen that way, the comparison stops being art history and becomes practical advice about backgrounds, daylight and what to do with a nervous sitter.

Who were Irving Penn and Richard Avedon?

Penn was born in Plainfield, New Jersey, on 16 June 1917. He studied at the Philadelphia Museum School of Industrial Arts from 1934 to 1938, where Brodovitch ran his Design Laboratory, and he trained as a designer and painter before he was a photographer. The Irving Penn Foundation records that he went to Mexico in 1941 to paint and then destroyed the paintings. In 1943 Alexander Liberman, the new art director of Vogue, hired him as an associate and encouraged him to take photographs; his first Vogue cover appeared that October. He died in New York on 7 October 2009, aged 92.

Avedon was born in New York City on 15 May 1923. He joined a camera club at twelve, and in 1942 enlisted in the Merchant Marine, where his job was to take identity photographs. "I must have taken pictures of one hundred thousand faces before it occurred to me I was becoming a photographer," he said, in a line preserved by The Richard Avedon Foundation. He studied with Brodovitch at the New School, and his pictures first ran in Harper's Bazaar in October 1944. He stayed until 1965, moved to Vogue, and in 1992 became the first staff photographer at The New Yorker. He died in San Antonio, Texas, on 1 October 2004, on assignment.

One man came to the camera from the drawing board and the other from the ID booth. Penn composed. Avedon confronted.

What was Penn's approach to the studio?

Removal. The Foundation's biography says he preferred a controlled studio in which he could strip away anything nonessential and concentrate on the subject, and the Metropolitan Museum, which mounted Irving Penn: Centennial from 24 April to 30 July 2017 with more than 200 photographs, describes a "pared-down aesthetic of studio photography" marked by meticulous attention to composition, nuance and detail across nearly seventy years.

Three episodes show the method.

The corner. In the late 1940s Penn pushed two studio flats together to make a tight angle and placed his sitters inside it. Marcel Duchamp, Georgia O'Keeffe and Igor Stravinsky were among those who went in. The corner gave people something to do with their bodies: brace, slouch, fill it or disappear into it. It turned a background into a test of temperament.

The curtain. Sent to Paris in 1950 to photograph the couture collections for Vogue, Penn worked in a daylight studio with an old theatre curtain as the backdrop. The same year he married Lisa Fonssagrives, the model in many of those pictures. The mottled cloth and soft window light became a signature, and he carried the idea into Small Trades (1950 to 1951), 252 full-length portraits of working people in their work clothes, photographed with the same gravity as the couture.

The tent. Between 1964 and 1971 Penn travelled for Vogue to Japan, Crete, Spain, Dahomey, Nepal, Cameroon, New Guinea and Morocco, and the Foundation describes a tent studio that could be taken down and moved. The pictures were gathered in Worlds in a Small Room in 1974. Wherever he was, he rebuilt the same neutral room, because he believed, in the Foundation's paraphrase, that a neutral environment encouraged a respectful exchange with his subjects.

What was Avedon's approach?

Movement first, then scrutiny. The early Avedon is known for fashion photographs in which models run, laugh and jump, and his biography notes that he specialised in capturing movement. Dovima with Elephants, made at the Cirque d'Hiver in Paris in 1955, is the best-known example of a dress given something to do. The 1957 film Funny Face based its photographer, played by Fred Astaire, on him.

In the late 1950s he turned away from daylight and open-air work towards the studio and strobe lighting, and removed soft lights and props. From there on the portraits become severe: a large-format 8 x 10 inch camera, a plain pale background, the sitter facing the lens. Observations (1959) had commentary by Truman Capote; Nothing Personal (1964) had a text by James Baldwin.

The fullest statement is In the American West. The Amon Carter Museum commissioned the project in 1979; over five years Avedon photographed 762 people across the western United States on about 17,000 sheets of Kodak Tri-X. Flash freezes; daylight forgives; Avedon wanted every crease recorded. His own account of what the pictures were is disarming: "My photographs don't go below the surface. I have great faith in surfaces." A good surface, he added, "is full of clues".

Penn vs Avedon: how do they compare?

Irving Penn Richard Avedon
Dates 16 June 1917 to 7 October 2009 15 May 1923 to 1 October 2004
Route into photography Design and painting; associate to Alexander Liberman at Vogue, 1943 Merchant Marine identity photographs, 1942 to 1944; Brodovitch's class
Magazine base Vogue, from 1943 Harper's Bazaar 1944 to 1965; Vogue from 1965; The New Yorker from 1992
Background Corner of two flats; old theatre curtain; portable tent studio Plain pale paper
Light Daylight studio favoured Daylight outdoors early; strobe in the studio from the late 1950s
Sitter's experience Slowed, quietened, given time Faced, examined, sometimes provoked into motion
Parallel work Still life; Cigarettes series, 1972, shown at MoMA in 1975; platinum printing from the 1960s In the American West, 1979 to 1984; advertising for Versace and Calvin Klein from 1980
Own summary A neutral environment encourages respectful exchange (Foundation paraphrase) "I have great faith in surfaces"

Both men also sold. Penn turned to advertising in the early 1950s when, the Foundation says, magazine editors found his photographs too severe and cut his assignments. Avedon began recurring campaigns for Gianni Versace in 1980. Neither thought commerce beneath him, which is one more thing later photographers learned from them.

What do they teach about backgrounds?

That a plain background is not a neutral one. Penn's curtain has texture and age; it sits behind a sitter like weather. His corner has geometry, and the geometry acts on the person. Avedon's white paper removes the floor, the horizon and the time of day, so the figure appears cut out and pinned. If you want a sitter to look composed, give them a room, even an invented one. If you want them to look exposed, take the room away.

There is a technical consequence too. A white background reflects light back into the subject and on to the lens, lowering contrast at the edges unless it is controlled; a mid-grey curtain does not. Anyone scanning or grading such pictures can see the difference in the tones, and our free image histogram tool will show it: Avedon's backgrounds sit hard against the right-hand wall, Penn's in the middle.

What do they teach about daylight and nervous sitters?

Daylight is slow and continuous. The sitter can see what the photographer sees, nothing fires, and long sessions are bearable. It suits people who are not used to being looked at, which is why Penn could photograph a tradesman in his work clothes and children in Cuzco with the same patience he gave a couture dress. Penn built a quiet room and waited for the sitter to settle.

Strobe is fast and discontinuous. Every exposure announces itself with a pop, and the sitter performs, or fails to, in bursts. Avedon's method turned that into the subject: the moment after the public face slips. Avedon built a blank room and photographed what happened when they could not settle. Neither is kinder in any simple sense. Penn's calm can flatter; Avedon's glare can be unfair. A portrait photographer chooses between them every time a sitter walks in, usually without saying so.

Where can their work be seen?

The Irving Penn Foundation and The Richard Avedon Foundation both publish chronologies and maintain the archives. The Metropolitan Museum holds a large body of Penn's work following the Foundation's promised gift of more than 150 photographs shown in 2017, and the J. Paul Getty Museum has collected his still lifes, a subject taken up in our piece on what still life photography is. Our photographers index has short sourced entries on both men, and the photography directory lists museums with strong photography holdings.

How does this relate to the Robert Harper archive?

By lineage of practice, not by personal connection: nothing in the record links Robert Harper to Penn or Avedon. But the choices described here are the daily choices of any studio photographer, and the library is, in large part, a studio's output: fashion, still life and portraits made mostly on 6 x 7 colour transparency film over about thirty-five years. The portraits collection includes sitters catalogued as Robert De Niro, Sir Bobby Charlton and Sir Hardy Amies, and the fashion collection covers decades of magazine and commercial work. For the British side of the same story, see our comparison of Bailey and Newton, both of whom Harper assisted, and our note on how to read a contact sheet, which is where a sitter's nerves are easiest to see.

Curators and researchers who would like to look at the portraits can request professional access.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Irving Penn and Richard Avedon?

Both made portraits and fashion pictures against plain backgrounds, but to different ends. Penn worked for stillness: a controlled studio, often daylight, in which anything inessential was removed and the sitter was given time. Avedon worked for energy and confrontation: first models in motion, then, from the late 1950s, strobe-lit studio portraits that record tension, fatigue and performance in close detail.

What were Irving Penn's corner portraits?

In the late 1940s Penn photographed sitters wedged into a narrow corner formed by two studio flats. The confinement gave each person something to push against, lean on or shrink into, and the pose became a record of temperament. Sitters included Marcel Duchamp, Georgia O'Keeffe and Igor Stravinsky. The corner is the simplest example of Penn making a background do psychological work.

What camera did Richard Avedon use for In the American West?

Avedon used a large-format 8 x 10 inch view camera, exposing about 17,000 sheets of Kodak Tri-X film over the five years of the project. He photographed 762 people for the Amon Carter Museum commission, which began in 1979. The large negative is the reason the prints hold so much detail of skin, cloth and dirt at exhibition size.

Did Penn and Avedon work for the same magazines?

Their careers crossed at Vogue. Penn was hired at Vogue in 1943 by its art director Alexander Liberman and remained associated with the magazine for the rest of his career. Avedon worked for Harper's Bazaar from 1944 until 1965, when he moved to Vogue, where he later photographed most of the covers from 1973 until late 1988. In 1992 he became the first staff photographer at The New Yorker.

Why did Irving Penn use natural light?

Penn preferred a controlled studio in which he could remove anything nonessential, and soft daylight suited that purpose: it is even, quiet and does not startle a sitter the way a flash does. The Irving Penn Foundation records that he photographed the 1950 Paris collections in a daylight studio and that he felt a neutral environment encouraged a respectful exchange with the people he photographed.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive