Three working-class Londoners are filed under one nickname from 1962. Their training, their pictures and above all their exits were different, and the differences are the interesting part.
A nickname is a caption written by somebody else, and the Black Trinity has been badly captioned for sixty years.
In 1962 three London photographers were given two collective nicknames inside a year. The Sunday Times called them the "Terrible Trio"; Norman Parkinson, a generation older, called them the "Black Trinity". Both labels, recorded by the Duffy Archive, have stuck, and both have done the three men a disservice by suggesting they were one phenomenon with three heads. Our angle here is that the clearest way to tell David Bailey, Terence Donovan and Brian Duffy apart is not by their 1960s pictures, which share a moment, but by what they were trained to do before the decade and what they chose to do after it. One stayed a photographer. One became a film-maker who also photographed. One lit a bonfire.
Why were Bailey, Donovan and Duffy called the Black Trinity?
Because they arrived together and looked like a takeover. All three were Londoners from outside the class that had supplied British fashion photography until then. All three worked for British Vogue around the turn of the 1960s. Duffy was hired by the magazine's art director John Parsons in 1957 (his own archive dates his Vogue years 1959 to 1962); Bailey was contracted in 1960. Donovan built his name in the same years in the magazines that were rethinking men's and women's style.
The nickname compresses real differences of age and background. Duffy, born on 15 June 1933 to Irish parents, was the eldest and the only art-school product: he entered Saint Martin's School of Art in 1950 to paint, switched to dress design, and worked as an assistant designer at Susan Small and then for Victor Stiebel. His archive says he turned down a job with Balenciaga in Paris in 1956 because he was about to become a father. Donovan, born in Stepney on 14 September 1936, the son of a lorry driver and a cook, studied at the London County Council School of Photoengraving and Lithography from the age of eleven to fifteen. Bailey, born on 2 January 1938, left school on his fifteenth birthday.
So the Trinity consisted of a trained dress designer, a trained print technician and a self-taught enthusiast. It would be strange if they had made the same pictures.
What did the three have in common?
A teacher, more or less. John French, who died in 1966, had developed a style of fashion photography built for newspaper reproduction: reflected natural light, low contrast, graphic clarity. He directed his sittings and left the pressing of the shutter to assistants, and those assistants included both Donovan and Bailey. Duffy applied to French in 1957 and, his archive says, was unsuccessful; he went instead to Carlton Studios, Cosmopolitan Artists and then to assist Adrian Flowers.
They also shared an outlet at exactly the right moment. The first colour supplement published with a British newspaper, The Sunday Times Colour Section, appeared on 4 February 1962 with a Bailey cover of Jean Shrimpton. Its art director, Michael Rand, summed up his credo as "grit plus glamour", which is as good a three-word description of the Trinity's early work as anyone has managed. Duffy's first commission, in 1959, had been for The Sunday Times, and it was Duffy, according to his archive, who introduced Shrimpton to Bailey.
And they shared a subject: young people in a city, photographed as if the photographer were one of them. That was new for Vogue, and it is the part the nickname remembers.
How did Bailey, Donovan and Duffy differ?
| David Bailey | Terence Donovan | Brian Duffy | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Born | 2 January 1938, Leytonstone | 14 September 1936, Stepney | 15 June 1933, London |
| Training | Left school at 15; assistant at John French studio, 1959 | Photoengraving and lithography school, ages 11 to 15; assisted John French | Saint Martin's School of Art from 1950; dress design; assistant to Adrian Flowers |
| Early base | British Vogue, contracted 1960 | Magazine fashion; Nova in the early 1970s | British Vogue to 1962; French Elle 1962 to 1966; own studio in Swiss Cottage, 1963 |
| Documented signature | Close portraits of the famous on plain backgrounds; Box of Pin-Ups | Fashion in gritty, bomb-damaged urban settings such as flats and gasometers | Design-led, conceptual commissions: Pirelli calendars 1965 and 1973; Aladdin Sane, 1973 |
| Moving image | Documentaries on Beaton (1971), Visconti (1972), Warhol (1973); commercials | About 3,000 commercials; the film Yellow Dog (1973); Robert Palmer videos | Co-founded the film company Deighton Duffy, which produced a feature film released in 1969 |
| After the 1960s | Continued as a photographer; CBE 2001 | Continued in stills and film; died 22 November 1996 | Quit in 1979; furniture restorer; died 31 May 2010 |
Bailey: the portraitist
Bailey's reputation rests on faces. Our comparison of Bailey and Helmut Newton goes into the method: a plain background, a close camera, and nothing in the frame to explain the sitter. He is the one of the three whose pictures of people who were not models became the work.
Donovan: the technician who went outdoors
Donovan's schooling was in how images are reproduced, and it shows in his control of tone and print. His fashion work is documented as using the hard edges of post-war London, including gasometers and flats, as backdrops for clothes that were more usually photographed in studios. He was a black belt in judo and co-wrote a book on the subject, Fighting Judo, in 1985. He moved his studio to 30 Bourdon Street in Mayfair in the early 1970s and went on to direct about 3,000 commercials. The video for Robert Palmer's "Addicted to Love", which The Guardian has called "fashion's favourite video", is his. Nova, the magazine that ran from March 1965 to October 1975, published experimental fashion pictures by Donovan in the early 1970s alongside Helmut Newton and Don McCullin.
Duffy: the designer
Duffy thought like the dress designer he had been. His commissions tend to have a concept that can be stated in a sentence: a calendar, an album sleeve, a cigarette campaign. He shot the second Pirelli calendar in 1965 and another in 1973. With the novelist Len Deighton he set up the film company Deighton Duffy, which produced a feature film of a First World War stage musical, released in 1969. He returned to stills in 1972 for the first of five sessions with David Bowie, and his archive credits him with designing, shooting and naming the Aladdin Sane cover of 1973. In the 1970s he made award-winning advertising for Benson & Hedges and Smirnoff.
Why did Duffy stop, and what does that tell us?
In 1979, after the Lodger session with Bowie, Duffy gave up photography and tried to burn his negatives in the yard of his studio. The Duffy Archive's account is that a council employee intervened because of the acrid smoke, by which time much had already gone. Bowie coaxed him back for Scary Monsters in 1980, and he worked in commercials and music videos in the 1980s, but by 1990 he had largely retired from image-making and become an accredited furniture restorer. In 2006, after a diagnosis of pulmonary fibrosis, he agreed with his son Chris to organise what survived; The Duffy Archive was founded in 2008. A BBC documentary followed, and his first exhibition opened at Chris Beetles Gallery in Mayfair in 2009. He died on 31 May 2010.
The episode is the sharpest difference between the three. Bailey treated photography as a life. Donovan treated it as a craft that extended naturally into film. Duffy treated it as a problem, and when he considered the problem solved he tried to dispose of the workings. A nickname is a caption written by somebody else, and the Black Trinity has been badly captioned for sixty years.
It is also a lesson for anyone who looks after negatives. What exists of Duffy's work exists because an official objected to the smoke and because a son spent years sorting what was left. Archives are not a natural by-product of careers; somebody has to decide to keep them. Our guide to what to do with a photographer's archive starts from that fact.
Where can you see the Black Trinity's work now?
Bailey's portraits were the subject of Bailey's Stardust at the National Portrait Gallery in 2014, later shown in Edinburgh and Milan. Donovan's fashion work was collected in the book Terence Donovan Fashion in 2012. Duffy's surviving negatives and contact sheets, from Vogue, French Elle, Glamour, The Sunday Times and The Telegraph, are administered by The Duffy Archive, and the Victoria and Albert Museum used his Aladdin Sane image for its Bowie exhibition. Our photographers index carries short sourced entries on all three, and the photography directory lists the museums and galleries that show work of the period.
What is the connection to the Robert Harper archive?
A direct one in two cases out of three, and it is a connection of training, nothing more. Robert Harper assisted Bailey during his two years at the Condé Nast studios, an apprenticeship described in our account of those studios, and afterwards worked as a freelance assistant to Terence Donovan, among others, before opening his own London studio. The archive records no work with Duffy. What followed was Harper's own: 95,487 unique photographs across fashion, still life, portraits and travel, more than half of them still on film. The fashion collection is the place to see how a photographer schooled by that generation handled the decades after it, and anyone assembling contact sheets for comparison can lay them out with our free contact sheet maker.
Researchers, curators and picture editors who would like to look further can request professional access.
Frequently asked questions
Who were the Black Trinity in photography?
The Black Trinity were David Bailey, Terence Donovan and Brian Duffy, three London photographers who came to prominence around 1960 and changed the look of British fashion photography. The Duffy Archive attributes the name to the older photographer Norman Parkinson in 1962, the same year The Sunday Times called them the 'Terrible Trio'. They were colleagues and friends, not a firm or a collective.
Who coined the term Black Trinity?
Norman Parkinson, the established society and fashion photographer, is credited with it. The Duffy Archive dates the remark to 1962, and David Bailey's and Brian Duffy's Wikipedia biographies both attribute the phrase to Parkinson, the former citing a 2009 article in The Times. The label was affectionate but not wholly admiring: the three represented a break with Parkinson's generation.
How did Terence Donovan's photographs differ from David Bailey's?
Donovan took fashion outdoors into a harder London: his shoots are documented as using gritty, bomb-damaged urban settings such as flats and gasometers. Bailey's defining work is the close studio portrait against a plain background. Donovan was a technician by training, with a photoengraver's schooling, and later became a prolific director of commercials. Bailey remained primarily a portraitist.
Why did Brian Duffy burn his negatives?
In 1979, after photographing David Bowie's Lodger sleeve, Duffy abruptly gave up photography and tried to burn his negatives in his studio yard. His archive's account says a local council employee stopped him because of the acrid smoke, though much had already been destroyed. Accounts describe a man who felt he had taken stills photography as far as he could.
Did Robert Harper assist the Black Trinity?
The archive records that Robert Harper assisted David Bailey during two years at the Condé Nast studios, and afterwards worked as a freelance assistant to Terence Donovan, Tony McGee, Alan Randall and Alex Chatelain. It records no assistant role with Brian Duffy. These are statements about Harper's training and imply no endorsement of the archive by any of the three or their estates.
Sources
- About Duffy, The Duffy Archive
- Brian Duffy (photographer) (Wikipedia)
- Terence Donovan (photographer) (Wikipedia)
- David Bailey (Wikipedia)
- John French (photographer) (Wikipedia)
- Nova (UK magazine) (Wikipedia)
- The Sunday Times Magazine (Wikipedia)
Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

