Take away the room, the furniture and the weather, and a portrait has only one subject left. The plain backdrop is the simplest device in photography and the least forgiving, for the sitter and the photographer alike.
A white background is not an absence of setting; it is the most exposed setting there is, because nothing in it can take the blame.
The white background is the studio portrait reduced to its minimum: a person, a light and nothing else. It looks like the easy option. It is the opposite. With no room to read and no props to hold, every fact about the sitter that the camera can record, the set of the shoulders, the state of the shoes, is promoted to evidence.
Histories of the device usually present it as a modernist purification that Irving Penn and Richard Avedon arrived at by taste. We think it has a second, less elegant parentage: the identity photograph. The plain ground is what officials specify when they want a face and nothing but a face, and the great portraitists of the twentieth century borrowed the format of the passport booth and the police file to make art. That borrowing explains both its power and the unease it still causes.
Where did the plain background come from?
Commercial portrait studios of the nineteenth century favoured painted scenery: balustrades, clouds, a suggestion of parkland. The plain ground belonged to a different sort of picture, the one made for a record. A neutral backdrop makes faces comparable, which is why it became the standard for identity documents and remains so. The current UK rules for a printed passport photograph require it to be "taken against a plain cream or light grey background", with no "shadows on your face or behind you" and "a plain expression".
Read that as a brief for a portrait and it is close to a description of what Penn and Avedon did, with one difference. The official wants the plain ground in order to learn nothing about the sitter except identity. The artist uses the same ground to learn everything else.
How did Irving Penn use the bare studio?
Penn joined Vogue in the 1940s; his first photographic cover for the magazine appeared in October 1943. Back at the magazine after the war, he undertook what his foundation's chronology calls "extensive portrait series of cultural figures" in 1946 and 1947. He was, as one summary has it, "among the earliest photographers to pose subjects against grey or white backdrop", and for one celebrated group he built two angled flats that met in "a stark, acute corner", into which sitters were invited to fit themselves as best they could.
Two things about Penn's practice matter here. The first is that he preferred a toned ground to a pure white one, and daylight to flash. In 1948, after a fashion assignment in Lima, he stayed on to photograph local people "in a daylight studio in Cuzco". The second is that he applied the same treatment to everybody. For Small Trades in 1950 and 1951 he photographed workers in Paris, London and New York, with their tools, in the studio: 252 full-length portraits in which a fishmonger receives the backdrop previously given to a duchess.
Then he took the studio to the sitters. In 1967 he constructed a portable tent studio and travelled with it to Dahomey (now Benin) that January, Nepal in October, Cameroon in 1969, New Guinea in 1970 and Morocco in 1971. The pictures were published in 1974 as Worlds in a Small Room, a title that states the method exactly. The Metropolitan Museum's centenary exhibition in 2017 gathered more than 200 of his photographs.
What did Avedon do differently?
Avedon made the ground white and the light hard. In the late 1950s he moved from daylight and outdoor work to studio photography with strobe, and for portraits he used a large-format 8 x 10 inch view camera. One account of his method says that "by eliminating the use of soft lights and props" he could concentrate on what his sitters gave away. His own summary, quoted by his foundation, is better: "My photographs don't go below the surface. I have great faith in surfaces. A good one is full of clues."
The fullest test of the idea was In the American West. In 1979 Mitchell A. Wilder, director of the Amon Carter Museum in Fort Worth, Texas, commissioned Avedon to photograph the people of the region. Over five years he photographed 762 sitters, among them miners, drifters, waitresses and slaughterhouse workers, and exposed about 17,000 sheets of 8 x 10 Tri-X. He worked on location but refused the location: each sitter stood against a sheet of white paper, so that a coal miner in Colorado and a rattlesnake skinner in Texas occupy the same blank space. Printing the exhibition took nine months, and the prints were larger than life.
The reception showed what a white background can do to an argument. Critics accused the project of falsifying the West and exploiting its subjects, and asked why a fashion photographer from New York had concentrated on the poor and the odd. Admirers answered that the pictures gave working people the scale and the scrutiny normally reserved for the powerful. Both readings follow from the same white paper. With no landscape to explain these people, the viewer is left alone with them, and with their own reactions.
Where does David Bailey fit?
Bailey brought the white ground to London and to pop. After working in John French's studio, he was contracted as a fashion photographer to British Vogue in 1960. His Box of Pin-Ups, published in the mid-1960s, was a set of poster-sized portraits of the people who made the decade's noise: the Beatles, Mick Jagger, Jean Shrimpton, Terence Stamp, P. J. Proby, Cecil Beaton, Rudolf Nureyev and, notoriously, the Kray twins. Lord Snowdon objected to the inclusion of the Krays, and that objection is given as the main reason no American edition appeared.
The Krays are the instructive case. Set a pop singer, a ballet dancer and two gangsters against the same plain ground, in the same hard light, and the format declares them equals. That was the scandal. A background is a context, and a shared background is a shared context, whatever the sitters did for a living.
| Irving Penn | Richard Avedon | David Bailey | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical ground | Grey or toned; also white | White | White |
| Typical light | Daylight | Strobe from the late 1950s | Studio lighting |
| Signature projects | Small Trades (1950 to 1951); Worlds in a Small Room (1974) | In the American West (1979 to 1984) | Box of Pin-Ups (mid-1960s) |
| Who was photographed | Cultural figures and tradespeople alike | The famous in the studio; working people in the West | The London celebrities of the 1960s |
| Effect | Dignity, stillness, a little space around the figure | Confrontation, flatness, detail | Energy, glamour, immediacy |
The entries for ground, light and effect summarise published accounts and the pictures themselves; they are generalisations, and each photographer broke his own rule when it suited him.
Why is a white background so hard to get right?
Because white is not a colour you can simply place behind someone. It has to be made with light.
The usual surface is seamless paper, a wide roll hung high and swept forward under the sitter's feet so that wall and floor become one continuous plane with no horizon. To record as clean white the paper has to receive more light than the sitter, commonly a stop or more. Give it too little and it goes grey and patchy. Give it too much and it becomes a second light source, bouncing forward to eat the edges of hair and shoulders. On transparency film, with its narrow tolerance for overexposure, the margin was small, which is one reason studios proofed the set-up on instant film first; see our piece on Polaroid proofing before digital.
Then there is the sitter. A person given a chair, a desk or a window knows what to do with their hands. A person given a white void does not. The awkwardness that results is not a flaw in the method. It is the method. Penn's corner and Avedon's bare paper were devices for making people react, and the reaction is the portrait.
For anyone preparing such pictures for a catalogue or a web page, the practical question is whether the white is really white. The free image histogram will show whether the background reaches the top of the scale or stops short of it.
Why does the style still dominate?
Three reasons, none of them aesthetic. A figure on white drops into any layout, because the edge of the picture vanishes into the page. It dates slowly, since there is no wallpaper or furniture to betray the year. And it suits the catalogue, where products and faces have to be compared like with like. The format that began in the registry office has ended up as the default language of the online shop.
That is also its limit. A white background removes information, and information is what archives are for. A portrait made in someone's office tells a researcher about the office. A portrait on white tells them about the face, the clothes and the photographer's nerve.
What portraits does the Robert Harper archive hold?
Robert Harper spent two years at the Condé Nast studios assisting David Bailey, Helmut Newton and Lester Bookbinder, a period described in our article on the Condé Nast studios, before working as a freelance assistant and then opening his own London studio. His biography sets out the sequence.
The archive's portrait collections record sitters including Robert De Niro, Sir Bobby Charlton, Sir Hardy Amies, Ken Russell, Paul Whitehouse, Anthony Powell and Anton Lesser. One folder of portraits runs to 829 frames; another, in black and white, to 358. The inventory names the sitters and counts the frames. It does not describe backgrounds or lighting, and we will not guess at them before the film is scanned. To place the names in this article among their contemporaries, see our index of photographers.
Editors and researchers looking for portraits of a particular sitter can ask about professional access.
Frequently asked questions
Who first used a white background for portraits?
No single photographer invented it. Plain backdrops appear in nineteenth-century studios and in identity photographs. Irving Penn is generally credited as among the first to make the bare grey or white backdrop a deliberate artistic style, from the late 1940s, and Richard Avedon and David Bailey made the pure white version famous in the 1960s.
Why did Richard Avedon use a white background?
Avedon removed props, settings and soft lighting so that attention fell entirely on the sitter's face, posture and clothing. He said he had great faith in surfaces, and that a good one is full of clues. A white ground isolates those clues. It also made portraits from different places and years look like parts of one continuous body of work.
What is seamless paper in photography?
Seamless paper is a wide roll of heavy coloured paper hung behind a subject and swept forward along the floor, so that no join or horizon line appears where wall meets floor. A common roll width is about 2.7 metres. It gives a continuous, featureless ground and is replaced by pulling down a fresh length when marked.
How do you light a white background so it stays white?
Light the background separately from the sitter and make it brighter, typically by a stop or more, so it records as clean white. Keep the sitter far enough forward that reflected light does not wrap round the edges of the figure and soften the outline. Too little light gives grey; too much gives flare.
What is the difference between a white background and a grey one?
White detaches the figure completely and reads as graphic and modern; it suits reproduction on a white magazine or web page because the picture's edge disappears. Grey keeps the sitter in a believable space, with a floor and a little shadow, and is kinder to skin tones. Penn favoured grey; Avedon and Bailey are associated with white.
Sources
- The Irving Penn Foundation, Chronology
- The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Irving Penn: Centennial (24 April to 30 July 2017)
- The Richard Avedon Foundation, History
- Wikipedia, Irving Penn (plain backdrops, Small Trades, Vogue cover of October 1943)
- Wikipedia, In the American West (commission, 762 sitters, about 17,000 sheets of film, criticism)
- Wikipedia, Richard Avedon (8 x 10 view camera, studio strobe, removal of props)
- Wikipedia, David Bailey (Vogue contract 1960, Box of Pin-Ups sitters, Lord Snowdon's objection)
- GOV.UK, Get a passport photo: rules for printed photos
Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

