Styles, genres and technique

Pictorialism and straight photography: the quarrel that still matters

A young man in a patterned shirt sits among blankets and a crowd near stage equipment.
An outdoor gathering.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

Soft focus against sharp focus looks like a dispute about lenses. It was a dispute about honesty, it was never settled, and image generators have just reopened it.

Every generation of photographers decides again how much a picture may be improved before it stops being a photograph of anything at all.

Pictorialism and straight photography were the two sides of the first great quarrel in the medium: whether a photograph earns its place as art by being worked up by hand, or by being left alone. The pictorialists softened, brushed and toned their prints until they resembled etchings. The straight photographers stopped the lens down, printed on glossy paper and called anything else a lie.

The usual account treats this as a closed chapter that the sharp side won around 1932. Our view is that it was never about focus and was never won. It was an argument about honesty, about what a viewer is entitled to assume when told that a picture is a photograph, and it has come back in the past few years in a form neither side imagined. An image generator is a pictorialist with no negative.

What was pictorialism?

Pictorialism was an international movement, at its height between about 1885 and 1915, whose photographers set out to make pictures, not records. The idea had been in the air for decades. In 1853 the miniature painter William John Newton proposed that a photograph could be made more artistic by keeping it slightly out of focus, and in 1869 Henry Peach Robinson published Pictorial Effect in Photography, which promoted combination printing, the assembly of one image from several negatives.

What turned an idea into a movement was the snapshot. In 1888 George Eastman introduced the Kodak camera with the slogan "You press the button, we do the rest", and, as the Metropolitan Museum's Lisa Hostetler puts it, "an army of weekend 'snapshooters' invaded the photographic realm". Serious amateurs needed a way to show that what they did was different. They found it in difficulty.

Gum bichromate printing meant hand-coating artist's paper with home-mixed emulsion and pigment. Platinum printing gave long, delicate tonal scales. Bromoil, carbon and oil printing all let the photographer add, remove and smear. Special lenses softened the image at the taking stage. Each technique put a visible human decision between the subject and the print, and that was the point: nobody could mistake the result for something a machine had done on its own.

Who led the movement, and what did it achieve?

In England the leading body was the Linked Ring. In the United States it was Alfred Stieglitz, who in 1902 left the New York Camera Club with Gertrude Käsebier, Alvin Langdon Coburn, Frank Eugene and others to form the Photo-Secession. Its exhibitions were held at the Little Galleries of the Photo-Secession on Fifth Avenue, known as 291, and its quarterly Camera Work was illustrated with photogravures on Japanese paper.

The campaign worked. In 1910 the Albright Gallery in Buffalo bought 15 photographs from Stieglitz's gallery, often cited as the moment an American museum formally accepted photography as art worth collecting. Whatever one thinks of misty woodland nymphs, pictorialism won the argument that the later purists took for granted: that a photograph could hang on a museum wall at all.

What is straight photography, and where did the term come from?

Straight photography is the practice of showing a subject in sharp focus and full detail, on the principle that photography should do what only photography can. The critic Sadakichi Hartmann was using the word "straight" in this sense by 1904, in the pages of Stieglitz's own circle, which tells you how early the doubts set in.

Stieglitz himself changed sides. By the end of the First World War he and Edward Steichen were moving away from painterly effects toward what Hostetler calls "an unvarnished display of the medium's natural strength". He closed the Photo-Secession and Camera Work in 1917. The man who had built the house of pictorialism locked the door on his way out.

The doctrine got its sharpest statement on the West Coast. Group f/64 opened its first exhibition at the M. H. de Young Memorial Museum in San Francisco on 15 November 1932 and ran for six weeks. Its seven founders were Ansel Adams, Imogen Cunningham, John Paul Edwards, Sonya Noskowiak, Henry Swift, Willard Van Dyke and Edward Weston. Their manifesto declared: "Pure photography is defined as possessing no qualities of technique, composition or idea, derivative of any other art form." The group had dissolved by the end of 1935, but the sentence lasted.

How do the two approaches compare?

Pictorialism Straight photography
Peak years About 1885 to 1915 1920s to the 1970s
What the picture is for Expression, mood, the maker's sensibility Description, form, the thing itself
Focus Soft or selectively diffused Sharp throughout, small apertures
Printing Gum bichromate, platinum, bromoil, carbon; textured papers Gelatin silver on smooth or glossy paper
Attitude to handwork Welcome and visible Suspect if it hides the photographic origin
Institutions Linked Ring, Photo-Secession, Camera Work Group f/64, museum photography departments
Charge against the other side Mechanical, anyone can do it Fake, imitating painting

The table flatters both sides by making them tidy. In practice the straight photographers intervened constantly. They chose filters to darken skies, selected papers for contrast, and dodged and burned prints with great skill. The term came to name a look, with rich tonality, hard edges and strong geometry, more than a rule about touching the print. That look dominated serious photography into the 1970s.

Was it really about honesty?

The best evidence that it was is the tone of the fight. William Mortensen, a Californian pictorialist who worked his prints with pens, paints, pumice and razor blades and favoured the bromoil process, carried on a long written debate with Ansel Adams in Camera Craft magazine. Adams, not normally an intemperate man, is recorded as calling him the "Devil" and "the anti-Christ". People do not reach for theology over a preference in lenses.

What the purists objected to was a kind of fraud. A photograph makes an implicit promise that something stood in front of the camera and looked roughly like this. A print scraped and painted until it resembles a charcoal drawing breaks the promise while trading on it. The pictorialist reply was just as serious: every photograph is a made thing, the purist's filtered sky and burned-in foreground are choices too, and pretending otherwise is the greater dishonesty.

Mortensen lost the publicity battle. His position led to his being, in one summary, ostracised from most authoritative canons of photographic history, and he was largely forgotten at his death in 1965. Recent decades have been kinder, partly because digital editing made his position look less eccentric. Once every photographer owned a retouching program, the question of how far to go stopped being historical.

Why has the quarrel returned with image generators?

Because generators remove the one thing both sides shared. Mortensen and Adams disagreed about what could be done to a negative. Neither doubted that there should be one.

A generated image has the surface of a photograph, including lens blur, grain and plausible light, with no exposure behind it. That is pictorial effect in its purest form: all picture and no record. The response from competitions, picture desks and collecting institutions has been to write rules that say what counts, which is the Group f/64 manifesto again in administrative prose. Where the purists of 1932 defined photography by what it must not borrow from painting, today's definitions turn on whether light from a real scene reached a sensor or a film.

There is a practical consequence for anyone who holds photographs. Provenance, meaning the documented chain from camera to file, has become part of a picture's value. Film originals have an advantage here that their makers never planned: a negative or transparency is physical evidence that an exposure took place. We have set out how that evidence can be carried into the digital copy in our guide to C2PA content credentials for photo archives, and the free content credentials checker will tell you whether a file carries any.

Where can you see both traditions?

Pictorialist prints need to be seen in the flesh, because their surfaces do not survive reproduction; a gum print on a screen is a rumour of itself. Museum photography departments hold the major names on both sides. Our index of photographers lists the figures mentioned here, and the photography directory maps the museums, galleries and festivals where such work is shown.

How does this connect to the Robert Harper Photograph Library?

A working archive is straight photography by necessity. A commercial transparency had to describe a product or a place precisely enough to satisfy a client, and the film recorded what was in front of it. The Robert Harper Photograph Library's inventory counts 95,487 unique photographs, 52,684 of them analogue, and more than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned.

Within it, the landscapes are the closest thing to the tradition discussed here: one folder holds 560 frames of black-and-white negatives and contact sheets of landscapes and rustic buildings dated 1975, described in our piece on Scottish landscape photography in the 1970s. They are unmanipulated in the simplest sense: nobody has yet done anything to them at all.

If you are a curator, researcher or publisher interested in film originals with a documented source, get in touch.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between pictorialism and straight photography?

Pictorialism treats the negative as raw material for a handmade picture, using soft focus and manipulated printing to suggest painting or etching. Straight photography treats the camera's sharp, detailed description as the point, and regards effects borrowed from other arts as a kind of dishonesty. One values the maker's touch, the other the lens's evidence.

When did pictorialism end?

There is no clean date. The movement was at its height between about 1885 and 1915, Stieglitz closed the Photo-Secession and Camera Work in 1917, and pictorialism declined after 1920. Camera clubs and individual photographers such as William Mortensen kept practising and defending it into the 1940s and beyond.

What did the Group f/64 manifesto say?

The 1932 manifesto stated that pure photography is defined as possessing no qualities of technique, composition or idea derivative of any other art form. The group took its name from a small lens aperture that gives great depth of sharp focus. Its seven founders included Ansel Adams, Edward Weston, Imogen Cunningham and Willard Van Dyke.

Is editing a photograph against the rules of straight photography?

Not in practice. Straight photographers used ordinary darkroom controls, including choice of paper, contrast, dodging and burning, to make expressive prints. What they rejected was handwork that disguised the photographic origin of the image, such as brushed emulsions, scratched negatives and heavy diffusion. The line was drawn at pretending, not at printing.

Why is this old argument relevant to AI images?

Because it is the same question: how much may an image be made, as opposed to recorded, and still be called a photograph? Generators produce pictures with no exposure behind them. Competitions, picture desks and archives now have to state what they accept, which is exactly what the purists of 1932 tried to do in a manifesto.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive