Styles, genres and technique

Colour before it was respectable: Leiter, Haas, Eggleston, Shore

A man in a checked jacket stands among a group near parked cars and traffic cones.
A roadside gathering.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

The usual story says colour photography became art in 1976. Commercial photographers had been delivering it to magazines and advertisers for forty years by then. The canon, retold with the paying work put back in.

Colour photography did not arrive in 1976; the museum did, some forty years after the art directors had already settled the question.

The pioneers of colour photography are usually named as four men, in an order that keeps changing: William Eggleston, Stephen Shore, Ernst Haas, Saul Leiter. Each has been called the first. None was. By the time the Museum of Modern Art hung Eggleston's pictures in May 1976, colour had been paying photographers' rent for four decades, in magazines, catalogues and advertisements that no curator thought to collect.

That is the angle of this piece. The argument about who came first is really an argument about who was looking, and the people looking earliest were art directors. Put the commercial work back and the canon reads differently: less a sudden breakthrough than a long, well-paid apprenticeship that the galleries joined late.

When did colour photography actually begin?

The dates that matter are industrial. The Lumière Autochrome, the first colour process to succeed commercially, went on sale in 1907. Kodachrome was announced on 15 April 1935 as 16mm cine film, and in 1936 arrived in the 35mm still format that would carry most of the pictures discussed here. Kodak sold Kodachrome sheet film to professionals from 1938 to 1951, and released its Dye Transfer printing process commercially in 1946.

So by the end of the Second World War a working photographer could shoot colour, and a printer could reproduce it. What happened next happened on the page. Susan Bright's history of food photography credits Nickolas Muray's colour spreads for McCall's in the 1940s with helping to make the three-colour carbro process a staple of American lifestyle and fashion magazines. Colour was where the money was, which is exactly why it was suspect.

Why did museums and critics resist colour for so long?

Because it looked like selling. Black and white carried the moral weight of reportage and the craft prestige of the darkroom; colour carried soup, lipstick and holidays. The resistance came from the most admired people in the medium. Ansel Adams claimed to get "a far greater sense of 'color'" from a well-planned black-and-white image. Eggleston has told the story that Henri Cartier-Bresson remarked to him at a party, "William, color is bullshit." That is Eggleston's account, and it has the ring of a line polished by retelling, but the attitude it reports was real enough.

There was also a practical objection. Colour materials were costly, slow, and for most photographers impossible to print themselves. A black-and-white photographer controlled a picture from exposure to print. A colour photographer handed a transparency to a laboratory or a magazine and hoped. For anyone raised on the idea that the fine print was the art, that was a serious loss of authorship.

The commercial studio simply did not have this problem. Its product was the transparency itself, delivered to a client and reproduced in ink. We have written elsewhere about why studios standardised on medium-format transparency film: the sheet on the lightbox was the finished article.

Who were the pioneers, and what paid for their colour?

The four names are worth taking in the order they worked, not the order they were canonised.

Saul Leiter moved from Pittsburgh to New York in 1946 and, by the Saul Leiter Foundation's account, began taking colour photographs in the late 1940s on slide film such as Kodachrome. Edward Steichen included him in a MoMA exhibition, Always the Young Strangers, in 1953. In 1957 he took his first fashion photographs for the art director Henry Wolf at Esquire; when Wolf moved to Harper's Bazaar, Leiter's colour pictures ran there from the February 1959 issue. In the early 1960s he rented a studio on Fifth Avenue and worked for Elle, Nova and British Vogue. The street pictures now considered his achievement stayed largely in boxes until Early Color, edited by Martin Harrison, was published in January 2006.

Ernst Haas, born in Vienna in 1921, was a magazine photographer first and last. In 1953 Life gave his colour essay on New York, "Images of a Magic City", 24 pages across two issues. In 1962 MoMA showed about 80 of his prints as Ernst Haas: Color Photography, the museum's first solo retrospective devoted to colour work. His book The Creation followed in 1971.

William Eggleston began experimenting with colour in 1965 and 1966, and by the late 1960s was working mainly on colour transparency film. While teaching at Harvard in 1973 and 1974 he found dye-transfer printing on the price list of a Chicago photographic laboratory, listed as the top of the range. The detail is the whole story in miniature: the process that made his museum prints so saturated was a commercial service, on a commercial price list.

Stephen Shore had a solo show of black-and-white photographs at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in 1971. He made American Surfaces in colour in 1972 and 1973, first exhibited at Light Gallery in New York in 1972, then moved to a view camera for the work published as Uncommon Places in 1982. He had a solo exhibition of colour photographs at MoMA in 1976, the same year as Eggleston.

Photographer Working in colour from Paid or published colour work Museum moment
Saul Leiter Late 1940s Esquire from 1957; Harper's Bazaar colour from February 1959; Elle, Nova, British Vogue Monograph Early Color, January 2006
Ernst Haas Early 1950s Life, "Images of a Magic City", 24 pages, 1953 MoMA solo colour exhibition, 1962
William Eggleston 1965 to 1966 Dye-transfer portfolio 14 Pictures, privately published 1974 MoMA, 25 May to 1 August 1976
Stephen Shore 1972 American Surfaces at Light Gallery, 1972 MoMA solo colour exhibition, 1976

Two things stand out. The earliest colour on this list was made by the two men who worked hardest for magazines. And the gap between doing the work and being hung for it narrows with every row, from more than half a century for Leiter to four years for Shore. The photographers did not get faster. The institutions did.

Was Eggleston's 1976 MoMA show really the first?

No, and MoMA never said so. The museum's own press release for Color Photographs by William Eggleston gives the dates as 25 May to 1 August 1976, counts about 75 prints selected by John Szarkowski, and makes one claim to priority: that the accompanying book, William Eggleston's Guide, was "the Museum's first publication on color photography."

The exhibition record is plainer still. MoMA had given Eliot Porter a solo show of colour photographs in 1943. It showed Haas in 1962 and a group exhibition, Three Photographers in Color, in 1963. In 1974 it ran Projects: Helen Levitt in Color, a continuous projection of 40 slides by a photographer who had won Guggenheim grants for colour work in 1959 and 1960, and who lost much of that early work in a burglary in 1970.

What 1976 did supply was an argument. Szarkowski wrote in the release that Eggleston worked as though "the world itself existed in color, as though the blue and the sky were one thing", and that the pictures were "not photographs of color". The show was badly received in parts of the press, which helped. A hostile review is a kind of certificate: nobody bothers to attack a medium that does not matter.

What did the commercial photographers know that the art world did not?

Three things, all of them technical before they were aesthetic.

First, that colour has to be designed. A black-and-white picture can be rescued in the darkroom; a transparency cannot. Studio photographers learned to build a picture's colour in front of the lens, with paper, gels and props, because the film recorded what it was given. That discipline, more than any theory, is what Szarkowski meant by colour that is part of the picture's content.

Second, that the original is a positive. Reversal film gives a unique, first-generation object with its colour fixed at the moment of processing. A whole professional culture of lightboxes, loupes and couriers grew up around that fact.

Third, that reproduction is the test. A magazine photographer's colour had to survive separation, ink and paper stock. Anyone who has compared a faded 1970s slide with its printed page knows how much judgement that took; our guide to why colour slides fade explains which films held up.

The Milwaukee Art Museum made the same case in 2013 with Color Rush: 75 Years of Color Photography in America, curated by Lisa Hostetler and Katherine Bussard. It charted the period from 1907 to 1981 and described its route as running "from magazine pages to gallery walls, from advertisements to photojournalism". The closing date is telling: 1981 was the year Sally Eauclaire's survey The New Color Photography was published, after which nobody had to argue the point.

Where can you see early colour work now?

Major museum collections hold all four photographers, and commercial galleries and festivals show them regularly. Our index of photographers is the place to start for names and where their archives sit, and the photography directory maps galleries, museums and fairs.

For the commercial side of the story, look in less obvious places: bound runs of magazines in libraries, advertising archives, and photographers' own files of transparencies. This is material that was made in colour because a client wanted colour, and kept because nobody threw it away.

What does this have to do with the Robert Harper Photograph Library?

Robert Harper's career sits on the side of the story the museums came to late. He spent two years at the Condé Nast studios assisting David Bailey, Helmut Newton and Lester Bookbinder, then ran his own London studio, contributing regularly to Elle and The Telegraph Magazine for more than fifteen years. The archive's inventory lists 52,684 unique analogue photographs, and its principal analogue format is 6 x 7 colour transparency film: colour made to brief, for the printed page.

More than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned, so we make no claims about individual pictures. What we can say is what the analogue holdings are: decades of professional colour in first-generation form, held by a single rights holder. If you are judging a scan of such material, the free colour palette generator will show you at a glance how a picture's colour was built.

Researchers, curators and picture editors who want to know what is in the boxes can ask for professional access.

Frequently asked questions

Who was the first colour photographer?

There is no single first. Colour processes were demonstrated in the nineteenth century, and the Lumière Autochrome of 1907 was the first to succeed commercially. Among photographers now treated as artists, Saul Leiter was shooting colour slides in New York in the late 1940s, Ernst Haas published a 24-page colour essay in Life in 1953, and Eliot Porter showed colour at MoMA in 1943.

Was William Eggleston's 1976 MoMA show the first colour photography exhibition?

No, although the claim is often repeated. MoMA had shown Eliot Porter's colour work in 1943, Ernst Haas in 1962 and a Helen Levitt slide projection in 1974. What MoMA's own 1976 press release claims is narrower: that William Eggleston's Guide was the museum's first publication on colour photography.

Why was colour photography not taken seriously as art?

Partly because of where it lived. Colour was expensive, hard to print well and tied to advertising, fashion and illustrated magazines, so curators and critics associated it with selling. Black and white had the prestige of reportage and the darkroom. Ansel Adams said he got a greater sense of colour from a well-made black-and-white image.

What is a dye-transfer print?

A dye-transfer print is made by transferring cyan, magenta and yellow dyes in register from three matrices onto one sheet of paper. Kodak released its version commercially in 1946. It gave rich, controllable, stable colour, and was used largely for advertising and reproduction work before William Eggleston adopted it for exhibition prints in the 1970s.

Did Saul Leiter work as a commercial photographer?

Yes. The Saul Leiter Foundation records that he took his first fashion photographs in 1957 for the art director Henry Wolf at Esquire, followed Wolf to Harper's Bazaar, and in the early 1960s rented a Fifth Avenue studio and worked for Elle, Nova and British Vogue. His personal colour street work was published in book form in January 2006.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive