Styles, genres and technique

Grunge against gloss: 1990s fashion photography explained

A smiling man in a jacket and jeans leaps in front of a window.
A man jumping in a furnished room.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

In 1990 two pictures appeared six months apart: five supermodels on the cover of British Vogue and a laughing sixteen-year-old on the cover of The Face. They are usually cast as enemies. They were closer to siblings.

Grunge and gloss were not opposites; they were two ways of apologising for the 1980s, one by stripping the set and the other by perfecting it.

The 1990s fashion photography style that everyone now imitates is really two styles that appeared within months of each other. In January 1990 British Vogue ran a black-and-white cover of five models who would shortly be known by their first names. In July The Face ran a cover of a sixteen-year-old from Croydon wrinkling her nose on a beach. One picture launched the supermodel. The other launched what was later called grunge.

The standard account sets them against each other: money against youth, artifice against truth. Looked at as photographs, they have more in common than that story allows. Both were rejections of the lacquered, shoulder-padded 1980s. Both claimed to show the real woman. They simply disagreed about what real looked like, and that disagreement, conducted on film in the last decade before digital took over, is why both remain such useful references.

What did the supermodel picture look like?

Its founding image is Peter Lindbergh's cover for the January 1990 issue of British Vogue: Linda Evangelista, Naomi Campbell, Tatjana Patitz, Cindy Crawford and Christy Turlington, photographed together for the first time. George Michael saw it and put the five in the video for Freedom! '90, at which point a group of working models became a cultural fact.

What is striking, given the picture's reputation as the height of glamour, is how plain it is. It is black and white. The styling is simple. Lindbergh, who was born in 1944 and died in 2019, said in a 2008 interview that "with black and white, you can really see who they are", and in 2016 he questioned the "commercial agenda to retouch all signs of life and of experience". The supermodel image at its origin was a naturalistic one.

The gloss came from what the idea turned into: colour, studio lighting, couture, flawless skin, and above all the confidence of women who were as famous as the clothes. The look said that beauty was a profession and these were its senior practitioners. It was expensive to produce and it looked it.

What did the grunge picture look like?

Its founding image is the July 1990 cover of The Face, headed "The 3rd Summer of Love". Corinne Day photographed the 16-year-old Kate Moss on a day trip to Camber Sands, with styling by Melanie Ward. The magazine called Moss "the face of The Face".

The Face had been founded by Nick Logan a decade earlier, its first issue dated 1 May 1980, and from 1982 Neville Brody's art direction had given it one of the most imitated designs in British publishing. Around 1990, under the art director Phil Bicker, it gave pages to a group of young photographers including Day, Juergen Teller, David Sims, Ellen von Unwerth, Stéphane Sednaoui and Nigel Shafran. Their pictures, as published, shared a manner: real places in place of sets, friends in place of established models, clothes that looked owned, and a refusal of the retoucher.

Day, who was born in 1962 and died in 2010, is described as a documentary photographer as much as a fashion one, and her book Diary (2000) was compared to Nan Goldin's. The Victoria and Albert Museum included her in Imperfect Beauty, curated by Charlotte Cotton, in 2000, and the National Portrait Gallery in The Face of Fashion in 2007. The titles of both exhibitions say what the style was about.

How do the two styles compare?

The table describes the two looks as they appear on the printed page. It is our reading of published pictures, not a record of any individual photographer's equipment or method, and plenty of work crossed the line in both directions.

Gloss Grunge
Emblematic image British Vogue cover, January 1990 The Face cover, July 1990
Where it ran Vogue and the established fashion monthlies; major advertising The Face, i-D and other style magazines; later the monthlies too
Setting Studio, or a location dressed like one Flats, beaches, streets, as found
Light Controlled and flattering Available light or direct flash
Models Named stars with a public persona New faces, friends, the unknown
Hair and make-up Finished Minimal or visibly undone
Finish Fine grain, clean colour, retouched Visible grain, colour casts, unretouched
What it promised Aspiration: you could look at this Recognition: you already look like this

On film the difference is easy to see with a loupe. A gloss picture is typically even from edge to edge, with skin tone held in a narrow, flattering range and no accident anywhere in the frame. A grunge picture lets accidents stand: a blown window, a green cast from strip lighting, a subject caught mid-blink. If you want to see how much of the second look is surface, add grain to a clean studio frame with the free film grain tool. The picture gets rougher. It does not get more honest.

Why did the two looks fall out?

Because one of them moved into the other's house. In June 1993 British Vogue, under its editor Alexandra Shulman, published "Under Exposed", a story by Day showing Moss, then nineteen, in her own west London flat. What had passed without comment in a style magazine caused a scandal in Vogue. Newspapers attacked the pictures as exploitative, and the argument about thinness, youth and responsibility that followed has never quite ended.

The same year the waifish look became the basis of Calvin Klein's advertising for Obsession, with Moss as its face. The style was no longer an alternative to the fashion business. It was the fashion business.

Critics gave it a name, heroin chic, defined by pale skin, dark circles under the eyes and an air of exhaustion. The name stuck after the death in 1997 of the young fashion photographer Davide Sorrenti. On 22 May that year President Bill Clinton said that the "glorification of heroin is not creative, it's destructive. It's not beautiful. It's ugly." Fashion is rarely the subject of presidential remarks, and the industry took the hint. In 1999 American Vogue put Gisele Bündchen on its cover under the line "The Return of the Sexy Model", and the decade's pendulum swung back.

It is worth being fair to both sides here. The photographers of the Face generation said they were showing young women as they were, against an industry that manufactured an impossible finish. Their critics said the pictures made illness look desirable. Both things can be true of the same photograph, which is why the pictures still provoke.

Why are both now reference material?

Three reasons.

The first is timing. This was the last full decade in which fashion pictures were made on film and finished largely in camera and in the darkroom. Each look is therefore tied to physical materials, to particular films, flashes and papers, in a way that later, digitally finished work is not. The originals are evidence of how the look was achieved.

The second is clarity. Gloss and grunge are opposed on almost every visual variable, as the table shows, which makes them easy to teach, to cite on a mood board and to describe in words. Anyone captioning images for machine learning will recognise the value of two styles that can be told apart by lighting, setting and finish alone; we discuss that kind of description in image captions for machine learning training data.

The third is that the argument is not over. Every few years fashion rediscovers one look as a corrective to the other. A picture desk that needs "nineties" has to know which nineties is meant.

For published examples and the people who made them, our index of photographers is the starting point.

What does the Robert Harper archive hold from fashion's magazine years?

Robert Harper was a regular contributor to Elle and The Telegraph Magazine for more than fifteen years, and his work also appeared in Vogue, Tatler, Cosmopolitan, Esquire, The Face, Wallpaper and Harpers & Queen, among others; his biography gives the outline. That list spans both sides of the newsstand described here.

The archive's inventory records, among its fashion collections, a folder of models and catwalk fashion (479 frames), a folder of magazine fashion set-ups (389 frames from 88 shots) and a folder of invitations to fashion shows by houses including Ralph Lauren, Chloé, Paul Smith and John Galliano. A separate folder of magazine pages, 364 frames, lists Elle, Esquire, Cosmopolitan, Vogue, Wallpaper, The Face and Harpers & Queen. We explain why such pages matter in what is a tearsheet.

The inventory does not date most of these folders, and the film has yet to be scanned and catalogued, so we do not assign any of it to a decade or a style. What it represents is the working output of a London studio that supplied the magazines of the period, held by a single rights holder.

Picture editors, stylists and researchers can ask about professional access.

Frequently asked questions

What defined 1990s fashion photography?

Two looks that shared the newsstand. One was the supermodel picture: polished, confident, expensively produced. The other, associated with The Face and i-D, used ordinary locations, little make-up and a snapshot manner, and came to be called grunge or, later and critically, heroin chic. Most of the decade's best-known work borrows from both.

Who photographed Kate Moss for The Face in 1990?

Corinne Day photographed Kate Moss for The Face's July 1990 issue, titled 'The 3rd Summer of Love'. The pictures were taken on a day trip to Camber Sands in East Sussex and styled by Melanie Ward. Moss was sixteen. The cover image, in a feather headdress, became one of Day's most recognised photographs.

What was heroin chic?

Heroin chic was a label applied in the 1990s to fashion images showing pale skin, dark-ringed eyes, very thin bodies and unkempt hair. It was used mainly by critics. After the photographer Davide Sorrenti died in 1997, President Bill Clinton said on 22 May that year that glorifying heroin was 'not creative, it's destructive'.

Who were the original supermodels on the 1990 Vogue cover?

Peter Lindbergh's cover for the January 1990 issue of British Vogue showed Linda Evangelista, Naomi Campbell, Tatjana Patitz, Cindy Crawford and Christy Turlington, photographed together for the first time. George Michael then cast the group in the video for Freedom! '90, which fixed the idea of the supermodel as a public figure in her own right.

Why is 1990s fashion photography so widely referenced now?

Because it offers two clear, repeatable visual languages, both made on film just before digital capture and retouching became universal. Designers, stylists and art directors use the pictures as references, and anyone building or prompting image models reaches for the same vocabulary. Original, datable examples with known rights are correspondingly useful.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive