Styles, genres and technique

Brown food and daylight food: how food photography changed its mind

A man in dark clothing sits with his arms stretched along a wooden bench.
Portrait on a park bench.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

Food photography has reversed itself at least three times: from still life to banquet, from banquet to laboratory, from laboratory to crumbs. Each reversal left fingerprints, which makes an old food picture unusually easy to date.

You can date a food photograph the way you date a kitchen: by what it is trying to prove, and to whom.

Food photography has changed its mind about almost everything: where the light should come from, how much should be sharp, whether the plate should look untouched or half eaten, and whether brown is appetising. The history of food photography styles is a sequence of confident reversals, and because each one was adopted so completely, a food picture carries its date on its face.

That is the use we want to make of the history here. Plenty of accounts tell the story as a parade of great images. Ours treats it as a dating guide: a set of visual clues that will place an uncaptioned food photograph within a decade or so, which is a practical skill for anyone cataloguing an archive, licensing pictures or labelling them for machine learning.

When did people start photographing food?

Almost as soon as they could photograph anything. William Henry Fox Talbot made A Fruit Piece in 1845: two wicker baskets, peaches and a pineapple. It is a painter's still life executed by other means, and for the next half century food photographs kept the conventions of painting, with game hung by the feet and fruit heaped for effect. The curator Susan Bright, whose book Feast for the Eyes (Aperture, 2017) is the standard history, notes that in such pictures "props became less symbolic, more literal": a saucepan beside dead birds signals dinner, not mortality.

Colour arrived in print before it arrived in the camera. Jules Gouffé's Le Livre de Cuisine carried a chromolithograph of a dressed chicken in 1869. In 1903 a baker's manual, The Book of Bread, reproduced about 40 loaves at life size, an early case of the photograph as specification. By 1910 Wladimir Schohin was making still lifes with the autochrome process, which Bright points out demanded real skill: early processes were "so fragile and time-consuming".

What made mid-century food look so lavish?

Advertising, colour printing and relief. The decisive figure is Nickolas Muray, a Hungarian émigré who photographed food spreads for McCall's magazine in the 1940s using the three-colour carbro process. Bright credits his work with helping to make carbro a staple of American lifestyle and fashion magazines from the late 1940s into the 1950s. The pictures show tables that could not possibly be eaten by the number of chairs provided: hams, jellies, fruit, flowers, all bright and all in focus.

Bright's judgement is exact: "This is not food to eat, but food to be looked at and dreamed about." After depression and rationing, abundance was the message, and abundance needs width. The camera stands back, the table fills the frame and the colour is turned up.

Britain's version was thinner and stranger. John Hinde's photographs for The Small Canteen, published by the Empire Tea Bureau in 1947, show blancmange ringed with tinned fruit in colours one reviewer called both "muted and garish". The ambition is American. The ingredients are not.

Why is 1960s and 1970s food so brown?

This is the period the title calls brown food, and the brownness has several authors.

The first is the menu. Casseroles, roasts, pies and sauces are brown, and they were what cookbooks of the period wanted to teach. The second is the set: dark wood tables, earthenware, copper, hessian and orange napkins, the furnishing palette of the decade. The third is technique. Studio food was typically photographed with a large view camera stopped well down so that everything from the front fork to the back wine bottle was sharp, under strong directional lamps. Long set-ups under hot lights are hard on real food, which is where the stylist's kit came in. Documented substitutions include white glue in place of milk, mashed potato hidden in the bottom of a salad bowl, glycerin or corn syrup sprayed on glass for condensation and a detergent mixture dropped in with a pipette to make a drink look freshly poured. Acrylic ice cubes became widely available in the 1970s and 1980s.

The fourth author is time. Printed pages yellow and some colour films and prints shift as their dyes fade, a process we describe in why colour slides fade. A casserole that was brown in 1974 is browner now.

The camera position is a clue in its own right. In older work, food was commonly shot from above, from what has been described as "the point of view of the eater", with items "arranged flat on the plate and clearly separated from each other". The plate is presented as a diagram: this is what you are getting.

What changed in the 1980s and 1990s?

Two things, in sequence. First the picture got closer and glossier. Lower camera angles, more props and what one summary calls "romantic lighting" produced the dish as an object of desire, and at the extreme gave rise to the phrase "food porn". Plates grew, portions shrank, sauces were drawn in lines. This is the restaurant decade, and the photographs flatter the chef.

Then came the reaction. In 1990 the photographer Bob Carlos Clarke, known for black-and-white pictures of women and cars, photographed Marco Pierre White's kitchen at Harvey's in London for the book White Heat. Bright describes it as part memoir, part cookbook, part documentary, with full-bleed pages that looked more like a magazine than a recipe book. It showed steam, sweat and exhaustion in place of plated food, and in her words "predicted the rise of the chef memoir and the era of the celebrity chef".

From there the plated dish itself loosened. Through the 1990s magazines and cookbooks moved toward what this article calls daylight food: window light, white crockery, linen, a very shallow plane of focus and evidence that somebody had started eating. The prevailing Western manner is now summarised as presenting food as simple and natural, with few props, "selective focus, tilted plates, and extreme close-ups". The stylist's glue pot gave way, at least in editorial work, to cooking the dish and photographing it quickly.

How do you date a food photograph by its style?

The table gathers the clues. It describes tendencies in published Western food photography, not rules; a conservative advertiser might be twenty years behind a fashionable magazine, and the period looks are now imitated on purpose.

Period Light Camera angle Focus Props and styling The food
1840s to 1900s Daylight, long exposure Eye level, as a painting Sharp throughout Baskets, game, drapery Raw produce, arranged
1940s to 1950s Bright, even, saturated colour Pulled back to take in the table Sharp throughout Flowers, silver, crowded tables Abundant, glazed, untouched
1960s to 1970s Warm, hard, directional Overhead or three-quarter Sharp throughout Dark wood, earthenware, patterned fabric Brown, sauced, garnished with parsley
1980s Controlled, glossy, dark backgrounds Lower, closer Mostly sharp Large plates, restaurant settings Small, architectural, drawn sauces
1990s to 2000s Daylight or imitation daylight Low or directly overhead Very shallow White crockery, linen, few props Simple, partly eaten, crumbs left in
2010s onward Soft daylight; phone flash as a style Directly overhead Variable Hands, boards, visible mess Informal, shared, colour-led

Three further checks help. Format: a large-format transparency suggests commercial work of the film era, and the size of the original narrows the date. Packaging: a tin, label or bottle in the frame can often be dated more precisely than the picture. And the test shots: instant prints filed with a job show how the set was built and corrected, as our piece on Polaroid proofing before digital explains.

If you are working from scans, the free colour palette generator makes the decade visible in a row of swatches: the browns and oranges of one era against the whites and greens of another.

Does it matter whether the food is real?

It matters to the law in advertising and to nobody in a cookbook. Fast-food chains including McDonald's, Wendy's and Taco Bell have faced class-action claims in the United States in recent years alleging that advertised food looked larger or fuller than what was served, and a similar claim was brought against Burger King in 2023. That is a dispute about the gap between picture and product.

For archives the question is different. A food photograph is a record of what a period thought food should look like, which is at least as interesting as what it tasted like. Bright puts it well: "Like art, cookbooks also tell us about the values of their time."

What food and drink photography does the Robert Harper archive hold?

The archive's inventory lists 23 folders under food, totalling 5,828 frames and 1,521 unique shots, and 12 under drinks, with 3,543 frames and 1,310 shots. The food folders are organised by subject, from bread and home baking through chocolate confectionery, fish and seafood, fruit, oils and sauces, and prepared foods to ready meals and tinned food. Drinks run from beer and champagne to cocktails (two folders, 1,053 frames between them), glasses, spirits, wine, and tea and coffee. Heinz and Diageo are among the commercial clients recorded for Robert Harper's studio.

One entry shows the working method of the film era more clearly than any description. A folder catalogued as a Cinzano shoot records 10 x 8 inch transparencies with 19 Polaroids, 5 x 4 inch film and 6 x 7 cm film from the same job: three formats and a stack of instant proofs for a single drinks assignment. The complete list is in the archive inventory, and the collections are introduced on the food and drinks pages.

More than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned, so we do not characterise the style of individual pictures. Subject-organised food photography from a single commercial studio, with one rights holder, is the kind of material that product and multimodal datasets look for; licensing is available by negotiation, subject to rights review.

Dataset builders and picture buyers can read more on our AI training data licensing page.

Frequently asked questions

How can you tell how old a food photograph is?

Look at five things: the light (hard and warm, or soft and cool), the camera angle (overhead, eye level or low), how much is in focus, how many props surround the food, and whether the dish looks finished or eaten. Everything sharp, many props and glossy food suggests the 1950s to 1980s. Shallow focus, daylight and crumbs suggest the mid-1990s onward.

Why does food in 1970s cookbooks look brown?

Several causes combine. The cooking itself favoured casseroles, roasts and gravies. Sets used dark wood, earthenware and orange or brown fabrics. Lighting was warm and directional. And colour printing and ageing paper have often shifted further toward yellow and red since. The brownness is partly the food, partly the styling and partly the decades.

What was the first food photograph?

William Henry Fox Talbot's A Fruit Piece, made in 1845, is usually given as the earliest. It shows two wicker baskets with peaches and a pineapple arranged on a patterned cloth, in the manner of a painted still life. Colour came much later: an autochrome still life by Wladimir Schohin dates from 1910.

Did food photographers really use fake food?

Yes, routinely, because real food wilts, melts and dries under lights. Documented substitutions include white glue for milk, mashed potato to bulk out a bowl, glycerin or corn syrup for condensation and dew, and detergent to make bubbles in drinks. Acrylic ice cubes became widely available in the 1970s and 1980s.

The shift is usually placed in the 1990s, when magazines and cookbooks moved from elaborate lit sets toward daylight, white plates, shallow focus and visibly eaten food. It became the general style in the 2000s, helped by digital cameras that let photographers check results at once and work faster with real dishes.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive