Styles, genres and technique

New Topographics explained: car parks, tract houses, no heroes

Two young people stand by blue water near an inflatable boat and distant buildings.
At the water’s edge.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

In 1975 a small show in Rochester, New York, replaced the mountain with the industrial estate. Its cool manner was less new than it looked: surveyors, estate agents and trade photographers had been working that way for a century.

New Topographics did not invent the dispassionate photograph of a building; it took the trade's plainest habit and hung it where people expected the sublime.

New Topographics is the name of an exhibition that ran at George Eastman House in Rochester, New York, from October 1975 to February 1976, and of the style it launched: landscape photography with the scenery taken out. Where the tradition had offered peaks and storms, ten photographers offered warehouses, tract houses and tarmac, described with the calm of a property survey.

It is usually presented as a rupture, the moment art photography turned its back on Ansel Adams. We think the more interesting story is one of borrowing. The level horizon, the flat light, the refusal to editorialise: all of this was standard practice among surveyors, estate agents and industrial photographers long before a curator gave it a name. The show's achievement was to move a working method from the filing cabinet to the gallery wall.

What was the New Topographics exhibition?

Its full title was New Topographics: Photographs of a Man-Altered Landscape. It was organised by William Jenkins at the International Museum of Photography at George Eastman House and contained 168 photographs.

The participants were Robert Adams, Lewis Baltz, Joe Deal, Frank Gohlke, Nicholas Nixon, John Schott, Stephen Shore, Henry Wessel, Jr., and the German couple Bernd and Hilla Becher, the only non-Americans. Shore was the only one who showed colour. Everything else was black and white.

Its reputation grew afterwards, through teaching and through the careers of the people in it. A reduced version reached the Arnolfini in Bristol in 1981, organised by the photographers Paul Graham and Jem Southam, which is one route by which its manner entered British photography. When the Center for Creative Photography and George Eastman House restaged it from 2009, the tour took in the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, the San Francisco Museum of Modern Art, the Nederlands Fotomuseum in Rotterdam and the Bilbao Fine Arts Museum. Few exhibitions tour more widely at thirty-five than they did when new.

What did the photographs actually look like?

Unexcited. That was the scandal and remains the pleasure.

Lewis Baltz photographed the blank walls of new commercial buildings for The New Industrial Parks near Irvine, California, in 1974: loading doors, stucco, a single shrub. The Bechers showed industrial structures photographed frontally under overcast skies. Others gave the edges of Western American cities, where new houses met open ground with nothing in between.

The Los Angeles County Museum of Art summed up the change as the moment when, in landscape photography, "romanticization gave way to cooler appraisal", and identified the subject as the "everyday built environment". The San Francisco Museum of Modern Art's phrase was "everyday scenes not usually given a second glance". Both descriptions are accurate, and both undersell how carefully the pictures are made. The prints are precise, the framing exact. The coolness is a matter of attitude, not of indifference to craft.

Jenkins supplied the vocabulary. In the catalogue he called the images "neutral", said the exhibition's common thread was "a problem of style", and described the whole enterprise as "more anthropological than critical". That last phrase did a great deal of work. It allowed the pictures to show the consequences of development without preaching about them, and it let viewers supply their own unease.

How did it differ from the heroic landscape?

Heroic landscape tradition New Topographics
Typical subject Mountains, forests, coast, weather Suburbs, industrial parks, motels, roadsides
Human presence Excluded or incidental The whole point, usually without people
Light Dramatic: storms, dawn, raking sun Even daylight, often midday or overcast
Viewpoint Elevated, sweeping Level, frontal, at street height
Implied message Nature is sublime and should be revered Here is what we have built; look at it
Photographer's stance Celebrant Witness

The contrast can be overdrawn. Robert Adams, for one, has written at length about beauty in photography, and a great deal of feeling survives in pictures that claim to have none. But as a rule of thumb the table holds: if a landscape photograph makes you want to visit, it belongs to the first column, and if it makes you wonder who approved the planning application, it belongs to the second.

What did its cool gaze borrow from survey and commercial photography?

Jenkins was open about two of his sources.

The first is in the title. Writing in Places Journal in 2010, the curator Shana Lopes notes that Jenkins chose "topography" to link the work to nineteenth-century survey photographers such as Timothy O'Sullivan and William Henry Jackson. Those men were employed to describe land accurately for governments and railways. Their pictures are plain because plainness was the job.

The second is Ed Ruscha, whose small self-published books of the 1960s, among them Various Small Fires (1964) and Thirtyfour Parking Lots (1967), presented petrol stations and car parks with no visible style at all. Jenkins admired their deadpan treatment of mundane American subjects and took his exhibition's disengaged attitude from them, though Ruscha was not in the show. The Los Angeles restaging made the family tree explicit by adding work by O'Sullivan, Walker Evans and Ruscha, along with Robert Venturi and Denise Scott Brown's 1972 book Learning from Las Vegas.

To these we would add a third source that the literature tends to skip, because it has no famous names attached: ordinary trade photography. This is our reading, not Jenkins's. A photographer hired to record a new factory for its owner, a house for an agent or a product for a catalogue works under rules that New Topographics would recognise at once. Stand square to the subject. Keep the verticals vertical. Use even light so that nothing is hidden. Leave yourself out. The Bechers' frontal views of industrial structures follow the conventions of an engineering record; Baltz's industrial parks resemble the pictures a developer might commission, with the sales pitch removed.

The difference lies in the frame around the frame. The trade photograph is made for someone who wants the building. The New Topographics photograph is made for someone who wants to think about the building. Lopes observes that this "'stylessness' has become a style in its own right", and she is right: what began as the absence of manner is now one of the most imitated manners in photography.

Why does it still divide people?

Because it withholds the two things many viewers want from a landscape: pleasure and a verdict. A New Topographics picture will not tell you that the housing estate is a blight, or that it is somebody's first home, although it may well be both. For admirers that restraint is a form of respect, for the subject and for the viewer's intelligence. For detractors it is a shrug dressed as rigour.

Fifty years on, the complaint has shifted. The original ten were describing places nobody had thought worth describing. Their many imitators are describing a style. A deadpan photograph of a petrol station made in 1975 was a decision; the same photograph made today is closer to a genre exercise, which is the usual fate of any manner that enters the syllabus.

How do you recognise the style today?

A working checklist:

  • The subject is built or altered land: housing, retail parks, infrastructure, edges of towns.
  • The camera is level, the horizon straight and the composition frontal or gently oblique.
  • Light is flat and descriptive; there is no golden hour and no storm.
  • People are absent or small.
  • The picture belongs to a series, and the series matters more than any single frame.
  • Captions are factual: place, date, sometimes an address.

The last two points are where the style meets the archive. Serial, captioned, neutrally lit pictures of buildings and land are also what a well-kept commercial or survey file looks like. If you want to test how much of the look is tonal, convert a colour picture of a retail park with the free black-and-white converter and watch it acquire seriousness it has not earned.

Where can you see New Topographics work?

The photographers are held by major museums in the United States and Europe, several of which hosted the restaged exhibition between 2009 and 2012. Our index of photographers lists the participants, and the photography directory maps museums and galleries where landscape work of this kind is shown.

What does the Robert Harper archive hold from the same moment?

By coincidence of date, the Robert Harper Photograph Library holds a group of pictures from the year the exhibition opened. The inventory lists 560 frames of black-and-white negatives and contact sheets under 1975, with the subjects given as landscapes, rustic buildings and off-grid living. They form the black-and-white landscapes and off-grid life collection, and our article on Scottish landscape photography in the 1970s sets out what is and is not recorded about them.

We draw no stylistic comparison. The negatives have yet to be scanned and catalogued, and we will not describe pictures on the strength of a folder title. What can be said is that the wider landscapes collection also includes 1,135 colour frames of landscapes and skies, among them the Highlands, New York and London, and that the same photographer spent his working life making the plain, exact commercial record that New Topographics learned from.

Curators and researchers working on 1970s landscape are welcome to ask about professional access.

Frequently asked questions

What is New Topographics photography?

It is a style of landscape photography named after a 1975 exhibition at George Eastman House in Rochester, New York. Instead of wilderness, its photographers showed suburbs, industrial parks, motels and roadsides, in a detached, descriptive manner with little obvious drama. The term now covers any cool, frontal, unsentimental picture of the built landscape.

Who were the New Topographics photographers?

Ten in all, counting a married couple as two: Robert Adams, Lewis Baltz, Joe Deal, Frank Gohlke, Nicholas Nixon, John Schott, Stephen Shore, Henry Wessel, Jr., and Bernd and Hilla Becher. All were American except the Bechers, who were German. All showed black-and-white prints except Shore, who showed colour.

Why was the New Topographics exhibition important?

It marked a break with the heroic landscape tradition of unspoiled nature and made the ordinary built environment a serious subject. The San Francisco Museum of Modern Art has called it a turning point in the history of photography. Its manner, sometimes described as deadpan, became one of the dominant styles in art photography and teaching.

Where did the name New Topographics come from?

Topography means the detailed description of a place. The curator William Jenkins used it to connect the work to nineteenth-century survey photographers such as Timothy O'Sullivan and William Henry Jackson, whose job was to record land accurately. He also drew on the plain, uninflected photo books Ed Ruscha self-published in the 1960s.

Was New Topographics a criticism of suburban development?

Not explicitly. Jenkins described the exhibition as more anthropological than critical, and the photographs avoid commentary. Many viewers nonetheless read them as an environmental argument, because a calm picture of a new housing tract on open land invites the question. The ambiguity is part of why the work has lasted.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive