Six processes account for most photographs a collector will ever be offered. Each has a look, a weakness and a different idea of what its owner owes it.
Every print process is a promise about time: silver promises decades, platinum promises centuries, and early colour promised nothing and largely kept its word.
A C-type and a giclee can show the same picture at the same size and be entirely different objects. One is dye formed inside gelatin by chemistry. The other is ink sprayed on to a coated sheet. A silver gelatin print is neither: it is metal, fine particles of silver suspended in gelatin on paper. Put all three under a 50x microscope and the argument is over in seconds.
Most guides stop at telling the processes apart. Our angle is that identification is only half of what a collector needs. Every print process has a temperament, a way it prefers to fail, and a different list of demands on whoever hangs it. This is a field guide to both: how to recognise the six processes you are most likely to meet, and what each one asks of you afterwards.
This article is general information, not financial or legal advice.
C-type vs giclee vs silver gelatin: what is the difference?
The short version, before the detail:
| Silver gelatin | C-type (chromogenic) | Giclee (pigment inkjet) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Image made of | Silver particles | Cyan, magenta and yellow dyes | Pigment ink droplets |
| How it is made | Exposed and developed in chemistry | Exposed and developed in chemistry | Printed by an inkjet printer |
| Usually | Black and white | Colour | Either |
| At 50x magnification | Continuous tone | Soft dye clouds | Scattered dots |
| Characteristic fault | Silver mirroring, yellow-brown fading | Colour shift, yellowed highlights | Surface scuffing, uneven gloss |
| Period | 1890s onwards | 1942 onwards | 1990s onwards |
"C-type" is a nickname that outlived the Kodak paper it came from. "Giclee" was coined for fine art inkjet printing in its early years and has no technical meaning beyond that; galleries now tend to write "pigment print" or "archival pigment print". "Silver gelatin" and "gelatin silver" are the same thing, depending on which side of the Atlantic wrote the label.
What is a silver gelatin print and how do you recognise one?
It is the black-and-white print of the twentieth century. The Image Permanence Institute dates silver gelatin developing-out paper from about 1890, with the image carried in a gelatin layer over a white baryta coating on paper, or from the later decades of the century on resin-coated (RC) paper with a plastic feel.
Untoned, the image is a neutral black. Sulphur toning warms it to brown and selenium shifts it towards purple-red. Under a loupe the tone is continuous, with no dots. The fault to look for is silver mirroring, a bluish metallic sheen in the darkest areas when the print is tilted to the light, along with fading or a drift towards yellow-brown.
What it asks of you: not much, if it was well processed. The Canadian Conservation Institute says fibre-based silver gelatin prints can tolerate display for several weeks or even a few months at relatively high gallery light levels, and puts the acceptable range at 30 to 50 per cent relative humidity and 15 to 25°C. Its enemies are damp, pollutants and poor mounting board.
What is a C-type print and why do some turn orange?
Graphics Atlas, the Image Permanence Institute's reference site, calls the chromogenic process the dominant colour photographic process of the twentieth century. The paper carries three gelatin silver layers, each sensitive to one primary colour. During development, colourless couplers in each layer form cyan, magenta or yellow dye, and the silver is bleached away. What remains is dye.
Dye is the weakness. The Northeast Document Conservation Center notes that chromogenic materials fade both in light and in the dark: dark fading mostly takes the cyan and yellow, light fading the magenta and cyan. Prints made before 1954 commonly show yellow staining in the highlights and borders. Prints made after 1990 tend to be much more stable. A family album of the 1970s that has gone the colour of weak tea is the process behaving exactly as designed.
A "digital C-type", "Lambda" or "LightJet" print is the same paper and chemistry exposed by laser from a file, and the IPI's identification notes treat it as materially identical to an optically enlarged one. Many are backprinted with the manufacturer's name.
What it asks of you: darkness when nobody is looking, cool storage, and realism. Our articles on why colour slides fade and film and print storage conditions cover the chemistry and the numbers.
Dye transfer and Cibachrome: why do collectors seek them out?
Both were answers to the chromogenic problem, and both are now closed chapters.
Dye transfer (the general term is dye imbibition) was Kodak's premium colour print process, listed by the NEDCC as running from 1946 to 1993. Three matrices, one per colour, were soaked in dye and pressed in register on to a gelatin-coated baryta paper. The result has bright whites, very rich colour and what the NEDCC calls excellent dark stability. Clues: registration marks in the border, or a faint colour fringe where the three layers did not quite align. It was laborious and expensive, which is why it is found in fine art and advertising, not in family albums.
Silver dye bleach, sold as Cibachrome and later Ilfochrome, worked the other way round. The dyes were in the paper from the start and were destroyed where they were not wanted. It was printed directly from a positive transparency, so no negative was involved. The NEDCC describes the look: usually a very high gloss, black borders where the edge is visible, on a white plastic base, with sharp, stable, saturated images. Manufacture ended in the early 2010s.
That direct line from transparency to print is worth a moment. A studio that shot colour transparency film, as most editorial and advertising studios did, was producing exactly the originals a Cibachrome was made from. Our guide to medium-format transparency film explains why.
What they ask of you: provenance. Because neither material can be bought new, the question of when a print was made answers itself, but who made it and for whom needs paper. See how to tell if a photograph is authentic.
What is a platinum print?
A print with no gelatin layer at all. The image is platinum metal (often with palladium) sitting in the fibres of the paper itself. The Image Permanence Institute places its main commercial era from about 1880 to 1930, and it has been revived since by photographers and specialist printers who make it by hand.
Recognition is by surface and tone: completely matte, with the paper texture visible through the image, and a long, soft scale of greys from cool black to warm brown. There is no sheen in the shadows because there is no binder to shine. The metal is extremely stable, so the life of a platinum print is in practice the life of its paper.
What it asks of you: good paper conservation, and care about what it touches. Framing materials matter more than light for this process.
What is a pigment print, and is giclee the same thing?
Yes, with a caveat. Inkjet inks are either dye-based or pigment-based. Pigment inks are the ones galleries mean by "archival pigment print". The IPI's identification notes describe two kinds of coating: swellable polymer layers, which suit dye inks, and porous mineral layers, which dry at once. Under magnification an inkjet print shows a random scatter of dots, sharper or softer depending on the paper. Pigment on glossy paper can show differential gloss or bronzing: the inked areas reflect differently from bare paper when tilted.
An inkjet print can be reprinted identically from the file tomorrow. That is its practical strength and its market problem, and it is why edition size, signature and documentation carry so much of the weight for contemporary work.
What it asks of you: gentle handling, because matte pigment surfaces scuff, and written evidence of the edition.
What does each process ask of its owner?
| Process | In use | Tell-tale under a loupe or in raking light | Main risk | Owner's first duty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silver gelatin | c. 1890 to now | Continuous tone; silver mirroring in shadows | Damp, poor mounts | Stable humidity, sound framing |
| Chromogenic (C-type) | 1942 to now | Dye clouds; yellowed highlights; backprint | Fading in light and dark | Limit light, store cool |
| Dye transfer | 1946 to 1993 | Slight misregistration; registration marks | Light on display | Limit light, keep paperwork |
| Silver dye bleach | Ended early 2010s | High gloss, black borders | Surface scratches | Never touch the surface |
| Platinum | c. 1880 to 1930, revived | Matte, image in the paper fibres | The paper itself | Conservation mounting |
| Pigment inkjet | 1990s to now | Scattered dots; differential gloss | Abrasion | Handle by the edges, document the edition |
On light, the museum benchmark is sobering. The Conservation Center for Art and Historic Artifacts puts photographs in its most sensitive category: a maximum of 50 lux, for three months in every five years. No hallway meets that, which is why our piece on framing, glazing and light is about sensible compromise. If you are deciding how large a print a given original will support, the print size calculator does the arithmetic.
Where the archive sits in all this
The Robert Harper Photograph Library is not, in the main, a collection of exhibition prints. Its analogue holdings are recorded as 52,684 photographs, principally 6 x 7 colour transparencies, with black-and-white negatives, contact sheets and 4,005 Polaroid prints, which have their own article on whether Polaroids are collectable. In the terms of this guide, that is the material prints are made from: the transparency behind a silver dye bleach print, the negative behind a silver gelatin one. Most of it has yet to be scanned.
Which process a photographer chose for the wall is part of how their work is read, and the new index of photographers is a good place to compare approaches. Galleries, publishers and printers interested in what could be made from these originals are welcome to ask about professional access.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a C-type and a giclee print?
A C-type (chromogenic) print is made on light-sensitive paper and developed in chemistry, so the image is dye formed inside gelatin layers. A giclee is an inkjet print: ink sprayed on to coated paper. Under strong magnification the C-type shows soft dye clouds and the inkjet shows scattered dots. Both can be made from a digital file.
Is a silver gelatin print better than a C-type?
It is different, not better. Silver gelatin is the standard black-and-white process and, well processed on fibre-based paper, is long lived. A C-type is a colour process whose dyes fade in light and, in older papers, in the dark as well. Collectors compare like with like: a black-and-white picture is judged as silver, a colour picture as dye or pigment.
How can I tell what kind of print I have?
Start with colour or monochrome, then surface (matte, glossy, plastic-feeling), then the back (manufacturer printing suggests a resin-coated photographic paper), then a 10x loupe. Continuous tone points to a photographic process, scattered dots to inkjet, a regular rosette to press printing. For anything valuable, a photograph conservator can confirm the process without damaging the print.
What does archival pigment print mean?
It is the usual gallery term for an inkjet print made with pigment-based inks, as opposed to dye-based inks, on a good paper. The word archival is a claim about expected permanence under stated conditions and has no single legal definition. Ask which printer, ink set and paper were used, and whether the edition is documented.
Are Cibachrome prints still made?
Not in any routine way. Cibachrome, later sold as Ilfochrome, was a silver dye bleach material printed directly from colour transparencies. Manufacture of the material ended in the early 2010s, so existing prints are a closed population. They are recognised by their high gloss, saturated colour and, where the border is visible, black edges.
Sources
- Graphics Atlas (Image Permanence Institute): Chromogenic overview
- [Northeast Document Conservation Center: Preservation Leaflet 5.2.2, colour photographic processes (2020)](https://www.nedcc.org/assets/media/documents/Preservation Leaflets/5_2_2_PhotosColor_2020.pdf)
- Image Permanence Institute: Identification of 20th century photographic processes (webinar slides)
- Image Permanence Institute: Identification of 21st century print processes (webinar slides)
- Canadian Conservation Institute: CCI Notes 16/4, Care of Black-and-White Photographic Prints
- Conservation Center for Art and Historic Artifacts: Light Exposure for Artifacts on Exhibition (2020)
Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

