Digitising film archives

How to scan 35mm slides: four methods compared

A bespectacled worker wearing protective gloves holds a curved pipe inside a workshop.
Pipe maker, Paisley, 1975.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

A 35mm slide is 24 by 36 millimetres of dye. Four kinds of equipment will turn it into a file, and they differ less in headline resolution than in speed, dust and how much of your time they take.

There are four practical ways to scan 35mm slides: a flatbed scanner with a transparency unit, a dedicated film scanner, a digital camera with a macro lens over a light source, and a scanning service that uses one of those on your behalf. All four can produce a usable file. They differ in how much real detail they resolve, how they cope with dust, how many slides they clear in an hour and how much of the work lands on you. The right choice follows from two numbers: how many slides you have, and how large the pictures will ever need to be.

What does a good scan of a 35mm slide look like in numbers?

A 35mm frame measures 24 x 36 mm. Sampling resolution, in pixels per inch, sets the size of the file.

Sampling Pixel dimensions Megapixels 16-bit RGB TIFF, uncompressed Print at 300 ppi
2,000 ppi 1,890 x 2,835 5.4 about 32 MB about 6 x 9 inches
3,000 ppi 2,835 x 4,252 12 about 72 MB about 9 x 14 inches
4,000 ppi 3,780 x 5,669 21 about 129 MB about 12 x 19 inches

The US federal guidelines for cultural heritage digitisation (FADGI, third edition, May 2023) rate about 3,000 ppi as three stars and about 4,000 ppi as four stars for film from 35mm to 4 x 5 inches, with 16 bits per channel at both levels. The Canadian Heritage Information Network's guide treats 1,000 ppi as a minimum and 4,000 as the recommendation. The film scan resolution calculator reproduces the table for any format or print size.

Two cautions apply to every method. Sampling resolution is not resolving power: the Canadian guide advises checking a scanner's effective resolution with a test target, because claimed values often fall short, and warns against "interpolated" figures. And slides are dense. FADGI notes that transparency film can approach a maximum density of 4.0, so shadow detail is the usual casualty of weak equipment.

Four methods at a glance

Flatbed with transparency unit Dedicated film scanner Digital camera and macro lens Scanning service
Real detail Modest High High, depends on lens and alignment Depends on the provider's equipment
Speed Batches of several slides, slow per pass Slowest per slide Fastest Your time: packing and checking
Infrared dust removal On many models On most models Not normally available Usually offered
Dense shadows Weakest Good Good, with raw capture Varies
Skill needed Low Moderate Highest to set up, low to run Low
Suits Screen use, small sets Hundreds of slides, best quality per frame Thousands of slides Owners short of time

Method 1: a flatbed scanner with a transparency unit

A flatbed can scan film only if its lid contains a light source, so that light passes through the slide to the sensor. Slides sit in a plastic holder, typically several at a time, and the software finds each frame.

The appeal is convenience: one machine also handles prints and documents, and batches run unattended. The weakness is optical. The lens and the glass are designed to cover a whole page, and the detail actually delivered from a 24 x 36 mm frame is generally far below the nominal setting. For viewing on screens, family sharing and identification scans of a collection, that is acceptable. For reproduction or preservation it usually is not.

Practical points from the Canadian guide: the emulsion side, which is the duller one, generally faces up on a flatbed, but check each batch because mount orientation varies; handle slides only by the mount; and clean the glass with a lint-free cloth only when needed.

Method 2: a dedicated film scanner

A film scanner is built around the small frame. Its lens focuses on the film plane, its light source is matched to the sensor, and most models add an infrared channel that maps dust and scratches so that software can repair them during the scan. For individual 35mm slides this remains the benchmark for quality per frame.

The costs are time and supply. High-resolution passes with infrared cleaning can take minutes per slide, and many of the best-regarded desktop models are no longer manufactured, so buyers rely on the second-hand market and on third-party software to drive them. Infrared cleaning also has limits. It works on dye images, which covers E-6 slides and colour negatives, but Kodachrome's cyan dye absorbs infrared, so the dust channel can mistake picture for dirt and soften detail. Dust and scratch removal explains the workarounds.

Method 3: a digital camera and macro lens

Photographing the slide is now an established archival method, and for volume it is the fastest. A camera on a copy stand looks down through a macro lens at a slide in a holder over an even, high-quality light. If the slide fills the frame of a 6,000 x 4,000 pixel sensor, the 36 mm side is sampled by 6,000 pixels, which works out at about 4,200 ppi in one exposure of a fraction of a second.

The figure needs qualifying. FADGI points out that a camera sensor with a colour filter array interpolates colour, so its true resolution is lower than the pixel count suggests, and that the whole system has to be tested, not assumed. Results depend on a flat-field macro lens, exact alignment, a dark room and steady support. There is no infrared channel, so dust has to be dealt with before capture. The set-up is described in full in camera scanning film: a practical set-up guide.

Method 4: a professional scanning service

A service is not a separate technology; it is someone else's scanner or camera, plus their labour. What you are buying is throughput and experience, and what you give up is control, unless you specify it.

Ask, in writing: what equipment is used; the true sampling resolution; bit depth and file format of the delivered masters; whether infrared or software dust removal is applied and whether an untouched file is also supplied; how colour is managed; how slides are handled, tracked and returned; and how files are named. For large collections, write a proper specification, as described in how to write a digitisation brief vendors can quote against.

Which settings matter whichever method you use?

  • Clean first. A bulb blower before every slide saves more time than any software. See how to clean slides and negatives before scanning.
  • 16 bits per channel, saved as TIFF. Slides have deep shadows, and extra tonal steps allow later adjustment without banding. Make JPEG copies afterwards for sharing; the TIFF to JPG converter does that in the browser.
  • Show the edge. The Canadian guide recommends keeping at least some frame or border in the master. With a mounted slide, that means including the inner edge of the mount.
  • Do not let the software "improve" the master. Auto-colour, sharpening and grain reduction are choices to make later, on a copy.
  • Check the histogram. The image histogram tool reports clipped shadows and highlights, the commonest fault in slide scans.
  • Profile if colour matters. Colour management for film scanning explains what an IT8 target does.
  • Plan the time. Enter your real seconds per slide into the digitisation time and cost calculator before committing to a method.

The 35mm slides in the Robert Harper archive

The Robert Harper Photograph Library's analogue holdings are mainly 6 x 7 colour transparency film, with 35mm slides among the other formats, alongside black-and-white negatives, contact sheets and 4,005 Polaroid prints. More than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned. The formats are described in the analogue collections, and the folders are listed in the archive inventory. Laboratories and imaging specialists equipped for mixed 35mm and medium-format transparency work are invited to make contact through the digitisation partners page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best way to scan 35mm slides?

It depends on quantity and purpose. For a few hundred slides and good quality, a dedicated film scanner with infrared dust removal is hard to beat. For thousands, a digital camera on a copy stand is much faster. A flatbed with a transparency unit is adequate for screen use. A scanning service suits people who value their time more than control.

What resolution should I scan 35mm slides at?

For preservation, published standards point to 3,000 to 4,000 ppi. At 4,000 ppi a slide becomes about 3,780 x 5,669 pixels, or 21 megapixels, enough for a print around 12 x 19 inches at 300 ppi. For screens and small prints, 2,000 ppi, about 5 megapixels, is often sufficient. Always keep 16 bits per channel in the master.

Can I scan slides with a normal flatbed scanner?

Only if it has a transparency unit, a light in the lid that shines through the film. An ordinary document flatbed lights the slide from below and records almost nothing. Flatbeds with transparency units scan slides in batches in a holder, but their real resolving power is usually well below the figure on the box, so results are softer than those of a dedicated film scanner.

Should slides be taken out of their mounts for scanning?

Usually not. Mounts protect the film, carry captions and dates, and fit the holders of most scanners. The mount hides a thin margin of the image and can hold the film slightly curved, so for the highest quality some operators unmount selected frames. For an archive, keep every original mount with its film, since the writing on it is catalogue information.

How long does it take to scan slides?

Capture time ranges from a second or two per slide with a camera to several minutes per slide on a film scanner at high resolution with infrared cleaning. Handling, dusting, naming and checking usually take longer than capture itself. Multiply your true time per slide by the number of slides before choosing a method; a planning calculator makes the answer hard to ignore.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

Help digitise the archive

52,684 analogue originals, mostly medium-format transparencies, are waiting to be scanned and catalogued. We are speaking to scanning, cataloguing and tagging partners.

See the digitisation briefWrite to the archive