Digitising film archives

How to clean slides and negatives before scanning

Wooden-handled brushes appear suspended with soap bubbles against a green background.
Washing-up brushes and bubbles.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

The safest way to clean film is to move air across it and nothing else. Every step beyond that removes more dirt and carries more risk, so the order matters.

Clean film with air first, and for most slides and negatives stop there. A rubber bulb blower removes the loose dust that causes most of the white or black specks in a scan, and it does so without anything touching the image. Each further step, a brush, a cloth, a solvent, removes more and risks more, because the picture lives in a thin layer of gelatin that scratches easily when dry and softens when wet. The right approach is a ladder, climbed only as far as each piece of film requires.

Why does film need cleaning before scanning at all?

A scanner or camera records everything in the light path at very high magnification. At 4,000 pixels per inch a speck of dust a twentieth of a millimetre across covers a patch roughly eight pixels wide. On a transparency it shows as a dark mark; on a negative, after inversion, as a white one. Thousands of frames each carrying a few dozen specks add up to an enormous retouching bill.

Some of this can be handled later. Infrared channels in film scanners detect dust on colour film, and software can heal marks in a copy of the file; both are covered in dust and scratch removal. But infrared does not work on conventional black-and-white film, and no software is as good as a speck that was never there. The Canadian Heritage Information Network's scanning guide makes the same point from the other side: the scan should capture the image, not the artefacts on it.

What do you need to clean slides and negatives?

Very little, and none of it is expensive.

  • A bulb blower. The hand-squeezed rubber kind sold for camera sensors. The Library of Congress recommends an air bulb, not canned air, for removing loose dust and debris.
  • Clean nitrile gloves. Fingerprints carry oils and salts that etch into emulsion. The National Archives asks its readers to use nitrile or vinyl gloves and not cotton, which reduces dexterity and can transfer fibres.
  • A clean, uncluttered surface and good raking light. A lightbox with a lamp shone across the film at a low angle shows dust better than any magnifier.
  • A lint-free cloth and isopropyl alcohol or lens cleaner, for the scanner only. The Canadian guide specifies these for the glass platen.

Notice what is missing: brushes, wipes, water. They belong higher up the ladder.

How do you clean slides and negatives step by step?

  1. Prepare the room. Close windows, wipe down the bench, wash and dry your hands and put on gloves. Dust that is not in the air cannot land on the film.
  2. Look before touching. Under raking light, sort what you see: loose dust, embedded dirt, fingerprints, scratches, or the furry or web-like growth of mould. Only the first is a job for a blower.
  3. Hold the film correctly. Slides by the mount, film by the edges. Never flex a strip.
  4. Blow both sides. Hold the film upright or tilted downwards so that dislodged dust falls away, and squeeze the bulb in short puffs across the surface. Do not blow with your mouth. The Canadian guide is specific that droplets of saliva can settle on the film.
  5. Check again and scan. If a few specks remain, scan anyway. A small amount of spotting on a production copy is safer than a larger intervention on the original.
  6. Clean the equipment as often as the film. Dust on a flatbed's glass or a film holder repeats in every frame. Blow out holders between batches and clean glass only when it needs it.

For the great majority of film that has been kept in sleeves or mounts, this is the whole procedure.

What should never be used on film?

  • Water and anything containing it. The Canadian Conservation Institute's advice is unambiguous: do not clean negatives in aqueous solutions. Wet gelatin swells, softens, and can stick to whatever touches it.
  • Household cleaners, wet wipes and spectacle sprays. They contain water, detergents and fragrances.
  • Erasers and dry cloths rubbed on the emulsion. The National Archives warns against erasers, water and solvent-based cleaners because they can alter the image surface.
  • Breath. It is warm, wet and not clean.
  • Canned air at close range. The can may release liquid propellant with the gas, and the propellant can mark the emulsion.

Brushes divide opinion. The Canadian Conservation Institute accepts a soft brush for surface dirt on negatives. The Library of Congress cautions that even soft brushes can scratch. A reasonable reading is that a brush is acceptable only if it is very soft, kept clean in a closed case and used with no pressure, and that a blower should always be tried first.

What about fingerprints, sticky residue and mould?

Here the ladder gets steep, and the honest answer for archive material is to stop.

Greasy marks and residue. Scanner software makers and film suppliers describe using a water-free film-cleaning fluid or high-purity isopropyl alcohol on a lint-free pad. The Canadian Conservation Institute allows that dry alcohol may be used for spot cleaning of negatives. The National Archives, writing for the public, advises against solvent-based cleaners altogether. These positions are not really in conflict: one describes what a trained person may do, the other what an untrained person should avoid. Solvents can disturb dyes, retouching and the lacquer that some laboratories applied to film. On your own family slides, a careful test on an unimportant frame is your decision. On someone else's archive, it is a conservator's.

Old fingerprints. If a print has been on the emulsion for years it has probably etched in. Cleaning will not remove it and may enlarge it.

Mould. Fungus grows on gelatin in damp storage and digests it. The National Science and Media Museum notes that growth is likely at 70 per cent relative humidity or above, and that it does not recommend any fungicide or cleaner because they are generally harmful to emulsions and dyes. Isolate mouldy film from clean film, keep it dry, scan it as it is, and seek a conservator's advice. The record of the image is worth more than a tidy surface.

Glass-mounted slides. Dust and moisture trapped between the glasses cannot be reached from outside. Remounting exposes the film to handling, so decide case by case, and keep any mount that carries a caption or number.

When is it better to leave the dirt alone?

More often than people expect. Cultural heritage guidelines such as FADGI's hold that a master file should document the original as it was at the time of capture, blemishes included, and that retouching belongs in derivative files. That principle has a practical side. A scan of slightly dusty film is a complete record that can be cleaned up digitally, many times, by better tools in future. A scratched or solvent-damaged original cannot be put back.

So the rule for an archive is: blower always, brush seldom, liquid almost never, and anything embedded or growing is recorded, not removed. Cleaning time also has to be budgeted. Adding even half a minute of inspection and blowing to each frame changes the length of a large project noticeably, which the digitisation time and cost calculator will show for any number of items. After scanning, the compare two images tool is a quick way to see what a second pass with the blower actually removed.

Clean handling and the Robert Harper archive

The Robert Harper Photograph Library holds 52,684 unique analogue photographs according to its inventory, a count not checked frame by frame against the physical material: principally 6 x 7 colour transparency film, with 35mm slides, black-and-white negatives and contact sheets. More than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned, so handling and cleaning protocol will be part of any scanning specification. The surface condition of the film has not been surveyed item by item, and nothing is claimed about it here.

The material is described in the analogue collections, and the workflow around cleaning is set out in how to digitise a film archive. Scanning laboratories and conservators who would like to discuss handling standards are invited to make contact through the digitisation partners page.

Frequently asked questions

What is the safest way to clean slides before scanning?

Use a hand-squeezed rubber bulb blower to move loose dust off both sides of the film, holding the slide by its mount. That is the only method conservation bodies recommend without reservation. Avoid breath, canned air held close, cloths and water. If dust remains after blowing, it is often better to scan and deal with the remaining specks in a copy of the file.

Can I clean negatives with water or household cleaners?

No. The image sits in a layer of gelatin that swells and softens when wet, so water can lift, smear or stick the emulsion. The Canadian Conservation Institute states that negatives should not be cleaned in aqueous solutions, and The National Archives warns against water and solvent-based cleaners. Household glass cleaners, wipes and detergents should never touch film.

Is isopropyl alcohol safe for cleaning film?

It is widely used by hobbyists on the base side of film, in high purity and with very little water content, and scanner software makers suggest it for greasy deposits. Conservators are more cautious, since solvents can affect dyes and lacquers. Treat it as a last resort for your own film, test on an unimportant frame first, and do not use it on archive material without professional advice.

How do I remove mould from slides?

Do not try to wipe it off. Mould feeds on the gelatin, so the image layer underneath is already weakened, and rubbing removes picture with the growth. Britain's National Science and Media Museum does not recommend any fungicide or cleaner, because they generally harm emulsions and dyes. Isolate affected slides, keep them dry, scan them as they are, and consult a photograph conservator.

Should I use compressed air on negatives?

A bulb blower is the better choice. The Library of Congress recommends an air bulb in preference to canned air. Cans can spit liquid propellant onto the film if tilted or shaken, and the blast is strong enough to drive grit across the surface. If canned air is all you have, keep the can upright, start the spray away from the film and stay well back.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

Help digitise the archive

52,684 analogue originals, mostly medium-format transparencies, are waiting to be scanned and catalogued. We are speaking to scanning, cataloguing and tagging partners.

See the digitisation briefWrite to the archive