Vendors can only price what they are told. A brief that states quantities, formats, a measurable specification and an acceptance test will bring back quotes that can be compared line by line.
A scanning vendor asked to quote for "about 50,000 negatives, high resolution" will do one of two things: decline, or guess high. Neither helps. The brief that gets useful quotes is the one that removes guessing. It states how many items exist in each format, what condition they are in, what a finished file must measure, how files will be named and how the work will be judged. Everything else in the document supports those five facts.
This guide sets out the sections of such a brief, the standards worth citing and the ones that do not yet cover film, and how a pilot batch turns a specification into a price. It is written for owners of film collections, and it reflects the questions the Robert Harper Photograph Library is putting to digitisation partners.
What does a vendor need to know before quoting?
TownsWeb Archiving, a UK digitisation company, lists the factors that move its prices: format, condition, how mixed the collection is, whether work is on or off site, capture resolution, metadata and output formats. It puts format first, as the factor with the most impact on cost per scan. A brief is, in effect, your answers to that list.
| Section | What to state |
|---|---|
| 1. The collection | Who made it, date range, what it is used for, why it is being digitised |
| 2. Quantities by format | Counts or sampled estimates for each film size, mounted or unmounted, plus prints and paper |
| 3. Housing and condition | Sleeves, mounts, boxes; curl, dirt, damage; anything needing a conservator |
| 4. Technical specification | Resolution, bit depth, colour space, master and derivative formats, per format |
| 5. File naming | The identifier scheme and how it maps to boxes, sheets and frames |
| 6. Metadata | What the vendor must record or embed, and in what form it is delivered |
| 7. Logistics | Where the work happens, transport, security, insurance, environmental conditions |
| 8. Quality and acceptance | Targets, tolerances, sampling rate, rescan terms |
| 9. Deliverables | Media, folder structure, checksums, reports, return of originals |
| 10. Commercial terms | Price basis, phasing, timetable, rights, confidentiality, case-study permission |
Sections 2 and 3 come from a survey, the first stage of the box-to-file workflow. If the survey is incomplete, say so and give ranges. An honest range, say "between 8,000 and 10,000 frames, about half of them 35mm", is quotable. A confident wrong number is not.
Attach photographs: typical boxes, a full sleeve on a lightbox, the worst example you can find. A lower-resolution visual index helps even more. If you have survey images, the contact sheet maker will lay out a representative page.
How do you specify image quality so it can be measured?
State each parameter as a value, per format, and name the standard it comes from.
The most specific public reference for film is the Technical Guidelines for Digitizing Cultural Heritage Materials from the US Federal Agencies Digital Guidelines Initiative, third edition, approved on 10 May 2023. It grades capture from one star to four, four being the highest, and gives tables for transparencies and negatives.
| Parameter | FADGI 3 star | FADGI 4 star |
|---|---|---|
| Resolution, 35mm up to 4x5 in | about 3,000 ppi | about 4,000 ppi |
| Resolution, 4x5 in and larger | about 1,500 ppi | about 2,000 ppi |
| Bit depth per channel | 16 | 16 |
| Colour spaces listed | Adobe RGB (1998), ProPhoto, eciRGB v2 (Gray Gamma 2.2 for monochrome) | Same |
| Master formats listed | TIFF, JPEG 2000 | TIFF, JPEG 2000 |
Do not simply write "FADGI compliant". Name the level, restate the numbers you intend and say how conformance will be shown. FADGI's model is that the vendor captures a reference target on the production equipment and supplies an analysis report. Ask for that report at set-up and at agreed intervals.
Three other references are often cited, and each needs care.
- ISO 19264-1:2021 is the international standard for analysing the quality of cultural heritage imaging systems. Its title and scope are limited to reflective originals. ISO's own summary says a future second part will address transparent originals. A brief for film should not claim conformance to it for transmitted-light capture; it is relevant to prints, contact sheets and magazine pages.
- Metamorfoze is the Dutch national preservation programme run from the Koninklijke Bibliotheek. Its Preservation Imaging Guidelines, version 1.0, were published in January 2012 and define three levels: Metamorfoze, Metamorfoze Light and Metamorfoze Extra Light. They address two-dimensional originals such as manuscripts, books, newspapers and photographs. Check the document's scope against your material before citing it for film.
- The National Archives in the UK publishes digitisation guidance for public bodies. It gives minimum resolutions of 300 ppi for documents, 600 ppi for photographs and 4,000 ppi for photographic transparencies, in 24-bit colour with an sRGB profile, as lossless JPEG 2000 or baseline TIFF. Note that its 8-bit sRGB requirement differs from FADGI's higher levels, so a brief cannot adopt both without choosing.
Before fixing resolutions, work out what they produce. The scan resolution calculator gives pixel dimensions and uncompressed TIFF sizes by film format, and the digitisation storage calculator totals them across the collection, which tells you what delivery media and storage to ask the vendor to price. The reasoning behind the format row is in TIFF, DNG or JPEG 2000.
What should the brief say about file naming and metadata?
Give the naming scheme in full, with examples, and state that file names must match identifiers on the physical enclosures. Say who applies those identifiers. If the vendor is to number sleeves, that is preparation work and should be a separate price line.
For metadata, distinguish three levels and say which you want.
- Technical metadata written by the capture system: device, date, resolution, profile.
- Fixed descriptive fields embedded in every file: creator, copyright notice, credit line, source.
- Item-level description: transcribing sleeve notes or job numbers, or captioning. This is skilled labour and the largest variable in many quotes.
Ask for a delivery manifest listing every file with its checksum.
How should logistics, security and insurance be covered?
The National Lottery Heritage Fund's project planner makes the basic point: if an outside partner is doing the work, decide where the materials will be and how the partner will get access to them. A brief should state whether originals may leave the premises, how they travel, the storage conditions expected at the vendor's site, who may handle them and who insures them at each stage and for what value. Ask vendors to describe their handling procedure for film and their training.
Say what happens to files afterwards: how long the vendor may retain copies, and how deletion is confirmed.
What acceptance tests should be written in?
Acceptance criteria protect both sides. A workable set:
- System conformance. A target-based report meeting the named level at the start and at agreed intervals.
- Sampled visual inspection. A stated percentage of each batch checked at 100 per cent for focus, dust, orientation, cropping and completeness.
- Tonal check. No clipping of image highlights or shadows beyond a stated tolerance. The image histogram tool shows clipping percentages for a derivative, a quick first screen before a formal check.
- Completeness. Every identifier in the manifest present once, with no gaps or duplicates.
- Remedy. Rescans at the vendor's cost where a batch fails, within a stated time.
Why ask for a pilot batch, and on what price basis?
A pilot of a few hundred items, chosen to include every format and the awkward cases, does what no document can. It measures throughput on your material, shows whether the specification is achievable and gives you files to examine before committing. Pay for it. A paid pilot gets proper attention and leaves you free to choose a different vendor for the main work.
Ask for prices per item by format, with separate lines for preparation, metadata, media, transport and insurance, and a stated VAT basis. Published list prices, summarised in what it costs to scan 50,000 negatives, span two orders of magnitude, so unit prices without scope tell you little. If you are open to arrangements other than a fee, such as phased contracts or a case-study collaboration, say so in the brief.
The brief behind the Robert Harper archive
The Robert Harper Photograph Library's inventory lists 52,684 analogue photographs: mostly medium-format colour transparencies, with black-and-white negatives, contact sheets, larger-format film, 35mm slides, more than 4,000 Polaroid prints and magazine pages. The counts are not yet checked frame by frame against the physical material, and the analogue material largely awaits both scanning and cataloguing. The archive is seeking partners for that work and would rather receive a clear pilot proposal than a headline price. Vendors who can state the formats they handle, their capture method, output specification, metadata capability, price basis and insurance are invited to respond through the digitisation partners page.
Frequently asked questions
What should a digitisation brief include?
State what the collection is, how many items there are in each format, their condition and housing, the capture specification (resolution, bit depth, colour space, file format), the file naming scheme, the metadata required, where the work will happen, how quality will be tested, what will be delivered and on what commercial basis. Attach photographs of typical boxes and sleeves.
Which standard should I cite in a film scanning specification?
For film, the FADGI Technical Guidelines are the most specific public reference, with star levels and resolution tables for transparencies and negatives. ISO 19264-1:2021 currently covers reflective originals only. Cite a named level, such as FADGI three star, and list the parameters you mean by it, so that nobody has to interpret the reference.
How big should a digitisation pilot be?
Large enough to include every format and every kind of difficulty in the collection, and small enough to assess by eye: commonly a few hundred items. The pilot should use the full specification and naming scheme, and its purpose is to measure throughput, expose handling problems and confirm that files pass the acceptance test before the main contract is priced.
How do I compare digitisation quotes fairly?
Give every vendor the same brief and ask for prices in the same units: per item by format, with separate lines for preparation, metadata, storage media, transport and insurance. Ask each to state capture equipment, expected throughput and what happens to failed scans. Compare totals only after checking that each quote covers the same scope and the same VAT basis.
Who owns the scans a vendor makes?
That is for the contract to state, and you should take your own advice on the wording. A brief should say plainly that the vendor acquires no rights in the images, may keep no copies beyond an agreed period, and needs written permission to show any image in a case study or portfolio.
Sources
- FADGI: Technical Guidelines for Digitizing Cultural Heritage Materials, third edition (May 2023)
- Library of Congress, The Signal: FADGI third edition announcement (11 May 2023)
- ISO 19264-1:2021 Photography, Archiving systems, Imaging systems quality analysis, Part 1: Reflective originals
- Zeutschel: Metamorfoze, background, goals and content
- The National Archives: Digitisation (guidance on digitising records)
- TownsWeb Archiving: How much does digitisation cost? (February 2015)
- National Lottery Heritage Fund: Digitisation project planner, handbook and examples
Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

