Robert Harper and the archive

The Who at fourteen: a first photograph sold

Three musicians pose with a bass guitar, drumsticks and an electric guitar in front of dark blinds.
Three musicians with their instruments.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

Robert Harper's career began with one sale: a photograph of The Who in concert, made when he was fourteen. The record is short. What grew from it fills 1,434 catalogue entries.

At fourteen, Robert Harper sold a photograph of The Who in concert. It was the first picture he was ever paid for, seven years after his first camera. That single sentence is the whole of the documented fact, and it is the earliest professional marker in a career that went on for approximately thirty-five years.

The archive's record gives no year for the photograph, no venue and no buyer. This article does not supply them. It sets out what is known, describes the band's early history as the public record has it, and explains what the wider music collection holds and what it does not yet show.

What the archive records about the photograph

Three things. The subject was The Who. The setting was a concert. The photographer was fourteen and the picture was sold.

Everything else is open. The record does not say whether the buyer was a newspaper, a magazine, a fan or a promoter. It does not say whether the picture was printed anywhere. It does not say what camera was used or whether a negative was kept. Harper was born in Scotland and grew up in Glasgow and on the island of Islay, but the record does not tie the concert to either place, or to anywhere else.

It is tempting to fill gaps like these with a likely story. We would rather leave them visible, because they are exactly the kind of gap that cataloguing an archive tends to close.

Who were The Who when a teenager could photograph them?

The public history of the band is well documented, and it explains why the subject was a good one for a young photographer to have sold.

The group began as the Detours, started by Roger Daltrey in 1959, with Pete Townshend and John Entwistle joining in the early 1960s. They changed their name to The Who in February 1964, and Keith Moon took over the drums that spring. In June 1964, at the Railway Hotel in Wealdstone, Townshend broke the head of his guitar on a low ceiling and then smashed the instrument on stage. Moon kicked over his drum kit the following week, and destruction became part of the act.

The records followed. "I Can't Explain", their first single as The Who, was recorded in November 1964 and reached the UK top ten. "My Generation" came out in October 1965 and peaked at number two.

Date Event in the band's public history
February 1964 The Detours become The Who
June 1964 First instrument smashing, Railway Hotel, Wealdstone
October 1965 "My Generation" released; reaches UK number two
1967 Monterey Pop Festival, first major US appearance
May 1969 Tommy released
14 February 1970 The Leeds concert recorded for Live at Leeds
August 1971 Who's Next reaches UK number one
31 May 1976 Charlton concert listed by Guinness as the world's loudest, at over 120 dB
September 1978 Death of Keith Moon

This table is context only. It does not date Harper's photograph, and nothing in it should be read as a hint about which concert he attended.

Why a live band is a hard first subject

Concert photography on film was unforgiving. The light was designed for an audience, not a camera. It was dim, coloured and constantly changing. Film was slow by modern standards, so shutter speeds were long and performers were rarely still. A roll held a few dozen frames at most, and there was no way to check any of them until the film had been developed.

The Who made all of that harder. A band famous for windmilling arms, leaping and wrecked equipment offers a photographer the picture of the night in a fraction of a second, and no second attempt.

None of this describes how Harper's own picture was taken, which the record does not tell us. It describes the general problem that any concert photograph of the period had to solve. A sellable frame from such conditions is a fair early test of timing.

From one concert to 1,434 catalogued shots

The first sale was not an isolated episode. The music and musicians inventory at Archive.London records 1,434 unique shots across nineteen principal folders, spanning rock, pop, jazz, opera and instrumental performance.

Some of the folders carry dates and places in the catalogue's own descriptions:

  • Jethro Tull, November 1974: 37 unique shots.
  • Stan Webb Band, March 1975: 78 unique shots.
  • Art Blakey Big Band, Edinburgh, 1987: 30 unique shots.
  • Eric Clapton at the Royal Albert Hall, 1993: 98 unique shots, recorded as five sheets of slides.

Others are catalogued by name alone, including David Bowie at 151 unique shots, David Gray at 162, and The Zombies and Colin Blunstone at 159. The music subjects also include Paul McCartney and Wings, Van Morrison, Santana, Everything But The Girl and Laurie Anderson.

These are inventory counts, not checked frame by frame against the physical material, and collections may overlap. The names are catalogued subjects. They do not imply that any artist commissioned the photographs, approved them or has any link with the archive.

Harper's commercial clients included CBS Records, which places the music business inside his professional life as well as in front of the stage. The catalogue also holds the objects of listening, with separate collections for records and CDs, instruments, and speakers, radios and Walkmans.

Where is the photograph of The Who now?

This is the question the archive cannot yet answer, and it is the most interesting one.

The Who are listed among the music subjects of the archive. The online catalogue, however, does not at present describe a dedicated The Who collection with a count and a format, as it does for Clapton or Bowie. Whether the first photograph sold survives as a negative, a print or a contact sheet, and what other frames of the band sit beside it, has not been established in anything published so far.

The reason is simple. The archive records 52,684 unique analogue photographs, and that material largely awaits scanning and cataloguing. Black-and-white negatives and contact sheets are among the formats listed. A contact sheet is where an early concert would most plausibly show itself, frame by frame, if it is there to be found. Until the boxes are worked through, the honest position is that we do not know.

The career that followed the first sale is traced in our profile of Robert Harper, from Islay to the Condé Nast studios. The music work continued alongside it, and the studio discipline behind the later pictures is described in two years in the Condé Nast studios.

For music researchers and picture editors

The music holdings on film largely await digitisation: more than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned, and only a small selection has been published online by Archive.London. Picture researchers, documentary producers and publishers working on a particular artist or period can set out what they need on the page for picture agencies and researchers; licensing is by negotiation with the single rights holder, subject to rights review.

Frequently asked questions

What was the first photograph Robert Harper sold?

The first photograph Robert Harper sold was an image of The Who in concert, when he was fourteen. That is the whole of the documented fact. The archive's record does not give the year, the venue, the price or the buyer, and Archive.London does not speculate about any of them.

Does the Robert Harper archive contain photographs of The Who?

The Who are listed among the music subjects of the archive. The online catalogue does not yet describe a dedicated The Who collection with a count, as it does for subjects such as David Bowie or Eric Clapton. What the boxes hold will only be clear once the analogue material has been scanned and catalogued.

Which musicians are in the Robert Harper Photograph Library?

Music subjects include The Who, David Bowie, David Gray, Eric Clapton, Paul McCartney and Wings, Van Morrison, Santana, Jethro Tull, Everything But The Girl, Laurie Anderson, Art Blakey Big Band, The Zombies and Colin Blunstone. The music inventory records 1,434 unique shots. These are catalogued subjects and imply no endorsement by the artists.

Can I license music photographs from Archive.London?

Licensing is available by negotiation with 825 Ventures Ltd, the owner and rights holder, and is subject to rights review. Researchers should give the artist, approximate period, intended use and deadline. Availability cannot be inferred from the images currently shown online, because most of the analogue material has not yet been digitised.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

For picture agencies, publishers and researchers

Fashion, beauty, jewellery, music, portraits and British life from the 1960s onwards, with 52,684 analogue originals still to be scanned. Tell us what you are researching.

See representation and researchWrite to the archive