Open the job bag for a 1985 magazine shoot and you will usually find film, a Polaroid and a delivery note. What you will not usually find is a signed release. Here is what the trade does about that.
A missing release does not make a photograph unusable; it makes it a photograph you have to think about before you use it.
Most twentieth-century studio archives contain very few signed releases, and the reason is not carelessness. For the work those studios mostly did, nobody asked for one. A magazine commissioned a fashion story, the model agency confirmed a booking for that use, the pictures ran, and the paperwork that governed the day was a booking form in somebody else's filing cabinet.
Decades later the film is still here and the booking form is not. This article is about that gap: what a release actually does, why it is so often absent, and the three working tools, editorial licensing, risk review and exclusion lists, that picture libraries use instead of pretending the gap is not there. Our angle is that the absence of a release is a fact to be managed, not a defect to be hidden, and that the archives worth dealing with are the ones that say so first.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Checked on 18 November 2026. The law described is that of England and Wales unless stated, and it differs elsewhere, notably in the United States, where rights of publicity vary state by state.
What is a release, and how is it different from copyright?
Two different people have interests in a photograph of a person.
The copyright belongs, broadly, to the photographer or whoever acquired it from them. It controls copying and publishing the image. A picture library licenses copyright.
A release is a permission from the person in the picture (a model release) or the owner of a recognisable thing in it (a property release). The American Society of Media Photographers describes what a good one records: that both sides understand what the picture is for and how it will be used, any restrictions the subject wants, the consideration given, and contact details for later. Its value, in the Society's words, is that it lets images be licensed commercially without fear of violating anyone's property or privacy rights.
A licence of the first does not supply the second. That is the whole point of the phrase "editorial use only", which we unpack in editorial versus commercial image use.
Why do older studio archives hold so few releases?
Four reasons, all structural.
- Editorial commissions did not need them. A picture made for and published in a magazine feature was an editorial use from the start.
- Advertising consents sat elsewhere. Where a model appeared in an advertisement, usage was typically agreed between the client, the advertising agency and the model agency, for a stated medium, territory and period. The photographer's copy, if there was one, was not the master.
- Time-limited consent expires. Even where usage was agreed, it was agreed for that campaign. It was never a general permission for uses forty years later.
- Paper is separated from film. Job bags are thinned out, studios move, agencies close.
There is a fifth point particular to still-life studios. Much of their output shows no people at all. A bottle of scent, a watch or a pair of shoes raises no model release question. It raises a different one: the trade marks and designs in the frame belong to someone, and that someone did not commission the picture so that a competitor could use it.
Is a model release legally required in the UK?
No statute says so, and there is no free-standing right to one's own image. The Court of Appeal put it in a sentence in Fenty v Arcadia Group Brands, decided on 22 January 2015: "There is in English law no 'image right' or 'character right'". Rihanna nevertheless won, because Topshop's sale of a T-shirt bearing her photograph was held, on the facts, to misrepresent that she had endorsed it. Kitchin LJ located the vice "not in the use of Rihanna's image but in using it in such a way as to cause a misrepresentation". One of the three judges called the case close to the borderline.
That decision is a good map of the terrain. The absence of a general image right does not mean anything goes. Depending on the use, a person pictured may have a claim in:
- Passing off, where the use falsely suggests endorsement.
- Misuse of private information, where the picture shows something private.
- Data protection. A photograph of an identifiable living person is generally personal data. The Information Commissioner's Office has pursued the point as far as the Upper Tribunal in its Clearview AI litigation over scraped facial images, where the tribunal ruled for the regulator on jurisdiction in October 2025; the ICO has since reported that Clearview was given permission to appeal, so the litigation continues.
- Defamation, where a picture is paired with words that damage a reputation.
Advertising has its own rulebook on top. Section 6 of the CAP Code urges marketers to obtain written permission before referring to or portraying a member of the public, and before implying that anyone personally approves of a product, and warns that people who do not wish to be associated with a product could have a legal claim. A release is simply the document that shows the permission exists.
How does editorial use deal with the gap?
By staying on the side of the line where the picture is being used to inform about its subject.
| Use | Typical example | Release normally expected? |
|---|---|---|
| Editorial | A book on 1980s fashion, a documentary, a newspaper feature | No |
| Exhibition and scholarship | A museum display, an academic paper | No |
| Fine art print sale | A gallery edition of a portrait | Often not, but fact-sensitive |
| Advertising and promotion | A brand campaign using a recognisable person | Yes |
| Endorsement and merchandise | A product bearing a person's image | Yes |
| Use of another brand's product in an advert | A watch brand's product shot used by a retailer | Property or trade mark permission |
The table is a description of trade practice, not a guarantee. An editorial label does not immunise a use that is misleading, intrusive or defamatory, and a caption can turn a harmless picture into a harmful one. But for a book publisher or documentary maker, the combination of a copyright licence and a clearly editorial context is how the great bulk of archive photography of people is, and has always been, published. Our guides to licensing a photograph for a book and music photographs for documentaries follow that process through.
What does a risk review look for?
For anything beyond plain editorial use, a careful licensor sorts images before quoting. A workable scheme has four tiers.
| Tier | What is in the frame | Usual treatment |
|---|---|---|
| A | No people, no identifiable private property, no prominent third-party marks | Widest range of uses considered |
| B | Products, packaging or logos of identifiable brands | Editorial freely; commercial use by others needs thought about trade marks and designs |
| C | Identifiable professional models or members of the public | Editorial; commercial use only with permission obtained for that use |
| D | Well-known people, children, or sensitive contexts such as medical or private settings | Editorial with care; anything else referred for individual review |
The review also asks who commissioned the picture, because that can bear on who owns the copyright. The National Portrait Gallery reminds people offering it portraits that for works commissioned before 1 August 1989 copyright usually belongs to the commissioner; our article on commissioned photographs and UK copyright explains the change.
The practical trick is to record the tier as metadata when the image is catalogued, not to rediscover it at each enquiry. The IPTC fields for archives include places for model and property release status, and our free copyright metadata tool writes rights fields into a file in the browser. "No release on file" is a perfectly good value. It is true, and it stops anyone assuming otherwise.
What is an exclusion list, and who keeps one?
An exclusion list is the register of images, subjects or whole categories that a licensor has decided not to offer for particular uses, or at all. It typically grows from four sources: requests from people pictured, takedown and correction notices, the licensor's own judgement about sensitive material, and conditions in the original commission.
It matters most for bulk licensing. A picture editor chooses one image and thinks about it. A dataset licence may cover tens of thousands that no human looks at individually, which is why buyers of data ask to see how exclusions are made and maintained. We describe that process in rights review for AI training images, and a survey of the kind set out in how to survey a photographer's archive is the first chance to record what paperwork, if any, travels with the film.
A list of this kind is also what an insurer's media liability questions are getting at, a point we return to in insuring a photographic archive.
What should a licensee ask an archive?
- Is a release held for this specific image? If so, may I see it, and what uses does it cover?
- If not, on what basis are you licensing it, and for which uses?
- Who is responsible for any further permissions my use needs?
- Do you know of any restriction, complaint or sensitivity attached to it?
- Who commissioned the picture, and who owns the copyright?
- Will the licence state all of this in writing?
An archive that answers the first question with "everything is fine" has not understood it.
Where Archive.London stands
Our position is published and unambiguous. Section 10 of the image licensing terms states that unless a Licence Confirmation expressly confirms a particular release or clearance, no model, property, trade mark, artwork, design, privacy, publicity or other third-party release is provided. Editorial licences do not authorise commercial endorsement, and the licensee is responsible for obtaining the permissions its particular use requires.
The Robert Harper Photograph Library is the work of one photographer with a single rights holder, 825 Ventures Ltd, and that simplifies the copyright side of any conversation, although who commissioned an older picture can still bear on ownership and is checked as part of rights review. It does not answer the release question. People and brands named in the catalogue are recorded as subjects: De Beers, Chanel and other houses as products photographed; musicians and portrait sitters as people photographed. Those descriptions imply no endorsement and no release, and we make no claim that releases exist for any image. Because more than half of the archive is still on film, what paperwork accompanies individual jobs has not been established.
So licensing is available by negotiation, subject to rights review, image by image or set by set. The rights and stewardship page explains how the archive is held; picture researchers, publishers and data buyers with a specific use in mind can start with professional access.
Frequently asked questions
Do old photographs need a model release?
It depends on the use, not the age. Editorial uses, such as illustrating a book, article or documentary about the subject, are commonly licensed without a release. Advertising, endorsement and merchandise uses normally need the consent of an identifiable person. In trade practice an old photograph with no release is commonly licensed for editorial use and seldom for commercial use without further permission; whether a particular use is lawful depends on its facts.
Is there a legal requirement for a model release in the UK?
There is no statute that requires one, and the Court of Appeal confirmed in 2015 that English law has no general image right. But a person can have claims in passing off, privacy, data protection or defamation depending on how a picture is used, and the advertising codes urge written permission. A release is how users manage those risks.
Can you get a release years after a photograph was taken?
Yes, if the person can be found and agrees. A retrospective release is a new agreement and should describe the specific image and the intended use. For well-known people, permission for commercial use is usually negotiated with their representatives and may involve a fee. Estates may need to be consulted in some jurisdictions.
What is a property release?
A permission from the owner of something recognisable in the picture, such as a private house, an artwork or a distinctive branded product, to use its image commercially. Many product and location photographs in older archives have none. For editorial use that is normally accepted; for advertising a different company's goods, it is a real constraint.
Does a missing release affect licensing images for AI training?
It is one of the points a rights review covers. Training use differs from publishing a person's image, but under UK data protection law a photograph of an identifiable living person is generally personal data, and buyers increasingly ask what a licensor knows about releases, sensitive contexts and children. A careful licensor says what it knows and what it does not.
Sources
- Fenty & Ors v Arcadia Group Brands Ltd & Anor 2015 EWCA Civ 3 (The National Archives)
- CAP Code (non-broadcast), section 6: Privacy
- American Society of Media Photographers: Releases
- Information Commissioner's Office: Upper Tribunal judgment on Clearview AI Inc (October 2025)
- National Portrait Gallery: Offering a portrait to the National Portrait Gallery (copyright in commissioned works)
- Archive.London: Image Licensing Terms, section 10 (releases and third-party rights)
Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

