Copyright and AI law

Who owns the copyright in a commissioned photograph?

An illuminated cinema entrance and traffic light trails on a dark wet street.
Cinema frontage after dark.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

Paying for a photograph does not make you its copyright owner. Unless the picture was commissioned before 1 August 1989, in which case it may well have done.

In the UK today, as a general rule, the photographer owns the copyright in a commissioned photograph. The client who paid for the shoot does not, unless the photographer was an employee or has signed the copyright over in writing. That has been the rule for photographs made since 1 August 1989. For photographs commissioned before that date, the rule was close to the reverse, and the old rule still governs those pictures.

This article is general information, not legal advice. Checked on 18 November 2026.

Section 11 of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 starts with one sentence: the author of a work is the first owner of any copyright in it. For a photograph, the author is the person who creates it, which in ordinary cases means the photographer.

The Act has no special rule for commissions. A magazine that commissions a fashion story, a jeweller that orders product shots and a couple who book a wedding photographer are all in the same position: they get the photographs they paid for and a right to use them, but not the copyright. The Intellectual Property Office puts it bluntly in its guidance: "the first legal owner of copyright is the person or organisation that created the work and not you the commissioner".

What is different about employees?

Section 11(2) makes one exception. Where a photograph is made by an employee in the course of employment, the employer is the first owner of the copyright, subject to any agreement to the contrary.

The line between an employee and a freelancer is drawn by employment law, not by who supplied the brief. A staff photographer on a newspaper's payroll is an employee. A freelance photographer hired for a day, working under what lawyers call a contract for services, is not, and keeps the copyright unless the contract says otherwise. The Intellectual Property Office's guidance makes the same distinction.

What was the rule before 1 August 1989?

The 1988 Act came into force on 1 August 1989. Before that, the Copyright Act 1956 applied, and before that the Copyright Act 1911. Both treated commissioned photographs as a special case.

Under section 4(3) of the 1956 Act, where a person commissioned the taking of a photograph and paid or agreed to pay for it in money or money's worth, that person was entitled to the copyright, unless the parties had agreed otherwise. The 1911 Act had a similar proviso covering photographs, portraits and engravings made to order for valuable consideration. The Intellectual Property Office summarises the position in one line: before 1 August 1989, the commissioner owned copyright in commissioned photographs, portraits and engravings.

The older Acts also defined authorship differently. Under the 1956 Act the author of a photograph was the person who owned the material on which it was taken at the time, which is to say the owner of the film, not necessarily the person who pressed the shutter.

Photograph made Governing rule Default first owner of a commissioned photograph
1 July 1912 to 31 May 1957 Copyright Act 1911 The person who ordered and paid for it, absent contrary agreement
1 June 1957 to 31 July 1989 Copyright Act 1956, s.4(3) The person who commissioned and paid for it, absent contrary agreement
On or after 1 August 1989 CDPA 1988, s.11 The photographer, unless an employee in the course of employment

Do the old rules still apply to old photographs?

Yes. The 1988 Act did not rewrite history. Paragraph 11 of Schedule 1 says that first ownership of copyright in an existing work is determined in accordance with the law in force at the time the work was made. It goes further: where a commission was placed before 1 August 1989 and the old commissioning rule applied to it, that rule also decides ownership of photographs made under the commission after that date.

So a studio photograph commissioned by a company in 1978 may, depending on the facts, belong to the company or its successors and not to the photographer or the photographer's archive. The qualifications matter:

  • The rule applied only where the commissioner paid or agreed to pay.
  • It gave way to any agreement to the contrary, and photographers' terms of business often contained one.
  • Work shot speculatively, for a portfolio or on the photographer's own account, was never commissioned at all.
  • Ownership may since have moved by assignment, by will or through corporate succession.

The upshot is that for pre-1989 commissioned work, the name on the negative sleeve does not settle who owns the copyright. The paperwork does, where it survives. The age of a picture matters in a second way too, which we cover in our guide to how long copyright lasts in a UK photograph.

Only in writing. Under section 90(3) of the 1988 Act an assignment of copyright is not effective unless it is in writing and signed by or on behalf of the assignor. An exclusive licence must also be in writing and signed by the owner to have its statutory effect. Paying an invoice, holding the prints, or keeping the transparencies in a filing cabinet for forty years does not by itself transfer legal title.

There is one qualification. In some commissioning disputes the courts have held that the client is entitled in equity to have the copyright assigned to it, as the Court of Appeal did over a commissioned logo in Griggs Group v Evans ([2005] EWCA Civ 11). That depends on what the parties must have intended and is decided on the facts of each case.

An assignment can be partial. It can cover some rights and not others, or run for a limited period. A photographer might assign the right to reproduce a picture in advertising while keeping everything else.

What can a commissioner do without an assignment?

Where a client has paid for photographs and nothing is written down, the law will usually imply a licence so that the commission is not pointless. The Intellectual Property Office's guidance warns that this may be modest: "the commissioner of the work may only get a limited non-exclusive licence".

The scope of an implied licence is measured by what the parties must have intended when the work was ordered. Pictures commissioned for a catalogue can go in the catalogue. Whether they can also go on packaging, into a television campaign or to a third party is a separate question, and the answer is often no.

That reasoning is being tested on a use nobody had in mind until recently: AI training. A brand that holds prints from a 1995 shoot is unlikely to find a right to license them as training data in an implied licence. Written contracts are being read closely too. PetaPixel reported on 11 March 2026 on a private arbitration between a stock contributor and Adobe over whether a 2018 contributor agreement allowed his library to be used to train Adobe's AI. According to that report, the arbitrator granted Adobe summary judgment on all but one of the contributor's claims, Adobe has asked a court to confirm the award, and the contributor has said he is asking the court to set it aside. We have not seen the award itself. In disputes of this kind the wording of the grant is usually what decides the outcome.

What about moral rights and privacy?

Copyright is not the only right in a commissioned photograph.

  • Right to be identified. Authors have the right to be credited under section 77, provided it has been asserted.
  • Right to object to derogatory treatment. Section 80 protects against treatment that distorts the work or harms the author's reputation.
  • Privacy in private commissions. Under section 85, a person who commissions a photograph for private and domestic purposes has the right not to have copies issued to the public, even though the photographer owns the copyright. Wedding and family portraits are the usual examples.

Moral rights can be waived but not assigned, so a transfer of copyright does not carry them with it. They are subject to exceptions, and the transitional provisions in Schedule 1 limit how they apply to photographs made before 1 August 1989; section 85, for example, does not apply to photographs made before that date. Separately, a photograph of an identifiable living person is personal data, and brands, artworks and designs shown in a picture may carry rights of their own. A copyright licence covers the copyright and nothing else.

A checklist before you rely on a commissioned photograph

  1. Date it. Was the picture made, or the commission placed, before 1 August 1989?
  2. Establish the relationship. Employee, freelancer, or the photographer's own project?
  3. Find the paper. A commissioning letter, terms of business, purchase order or assignment.
  4. Read the grant. What uses, what territory, what period, exclusive or not?
  5. Check what is in the frame. People, trade marks, artworks, private property.
  6. Record the answer. Embedding the conclusion in the file helps the next person; our free add copyright metadata tool writes creator, copyright notice and usage terms into a JPEG.

The checklist is a way of organising the questions, not a substitute for advice. Where the answer matters commercially, a solicitor who practises in copyright is the person to ask.

Why this matters for a working photographer's archive

The Robert Harper Photograph Library spans both regimes. It holds material from the 1960s and 1970s through to the digital era, and Robert Harper's commercial clients included De Beers, Harrods, Selfridges, Boots and Heinz, alongside more than fifteen years as a regular contributor to Elle and The Telegraph Magazine. An archive like that contains commissioned work, editorial work and personal work made under different rules at different dates, including the studio photography in the advertising collections.

The archive is owned by 825 Ventures Ltd, the owner and rights holder. That is the reason every licence is subject to rights review: the review is where questions of date, commission and third-party rights are worked through for the images concerned. How we approach it is set out on the rights and stewardship page. Brands, agencies and researchers with a specific picture or collection in mind can get in touch to discuss it.

Frequently asked questions

Not automatically. For photographs made in the UK since 1 August 1989 the photographer is the first owner of copyright unless they were your employee acting in the course of employment. To own the copyright you need a written assignment signed by the photographer. Otherwise you usually have a licence, express or implied, to use the pictures for the commissioned purpose.

Generally the commissioner. Under the Copyright Act 1956, a person who commissioned a photograph and paid or agreed to pay for it in money or money's worth was entitled to the copyright, unless there was an agreement to the contrary. The Intellectual Property Office's guidance confirms that before 1 August 1989 the commissioner owned copyright in commissioned photographs.

Yes. Section 90(3) of the 1988 Act says an assignment of copyright is not effective unless it is in writing and signed by or on behalf of the assignor. A conversation, an invoice marked paid, or possession of the negatives is not an assignment, although it may be evidence of a licence.

Can a client use commissioned photographs for anything they like?

Only if the licence or assignment says so. Where nothing is written down, courts may imply a licence, but usually only as wide as is needed to give effect to what both sides intended at the time. Uses nobody contemplated, such as licensing the images to train AI models, are unlikely to be covered without fresh permission.

No. Moral rights, including the right to be identified as author and the right to object to derogatory treatment, belong to the author and cannot be assigned, though they can be waived. A person who commissions photographs for private and domestic purposes also has a separate right under section 85 not to have them issued to the public.

Sources

This article is general information, not legal advice. It reflects the position as we understood it on the date shown and may be out of date. Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

Licensing the archive for AI and data projects

95,487 photographs from one photographer and one rights holder. Read the dataset card, search the 503-folder inventory, discuss a sample set under NDA, or arrange a first look as scanning proceeds.

See AI and data licensingWrite to the archive