Getty, Andersen, Midjourney, LAION, Ross, Anthropic: a dated status table of the cases that will decide how photographs may be used to train AI, separating what courts have ruled from what they have yet to.
Nearly four years after the first lawsuits over image generators were filed, no court in Britain or America has ruled on the question at their centre: whether copying photographs to train an image model infringes copyright. The cases that could answer it are all still running. This page records where each one stands, and is written to be updated as they move.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Checked on 18 November 2026. Each entry separates what a court has decided from what remains pending. Where we could not confirm a point from a court record or a reputable report, we say so.
Image and photography cases: status table
| Case | Court | Decided | Pending |
|---|---|---|---|
| Getty Images v Stability AI (UK) | High Court; Court of Appeal of England and Wales | 4 Nov 2025: model is not an "infringing copy"; limited trade mark infringement. Training claim abandoned, so not ruled on | Appeal on secondary infringement heard 11 and 12 Nov 2026. Judgment awaited |
| Getty Images v Stability AI (US) | N.D. California, 3:25-cv-06891 | 23 Apr 2026: trade mark, dilution and unfair competition claims survive; one claim dismissed with leave to amend | Copyright claim over training. Pre-trial; a November 2025 scheduling order set trial for January 2028, according to a docket-based report we have not re-confirmed |
| Andersen v Stability AI, Midjourney, DeviantArt, Runway | N.D. California | Aug 2024: copyright and some Lanham Act claims survive dismissal | Everything else. Schedule extended Feb and Sep 2026. No trial has taken place |
| Disney and Universal v Midjourney; Warner Bros. Discovery v Midjourney | C.D. California | 14 Nov 2025: cases consolidated | In discovery. Midjourney agreed on 6 Oct 2026 to share video training datasets. Mediation outcome unverified |
| Evox Productions v Stability AI and others | C.D. California, 2:26-cv-07201 | Nothing yet | Filed 2 Jul 2026. One defendant moved to dismiss on 12 Oct 2026 |
| Evox Productions v Google | N.D. California, 5:26-cv-07013 | Nothing yet | Filed 9 Jul 2026 |
| Evox Productions v Midjourney | C.D. California, 2:26-cv-08408 | Nothing yet | Filed 30 Jul 2026 |
| Kneschke v LAION | Hamburg courts; Federal Court of Justice, I ZR 281/25 | 27 Sep 2024 and 10 Dec 2025: dataset creation covered by German text and data mining exceptions; natural-language opt-out not machine-readable | Heard 3 Sep 2026. No decision reported; a reference to the EU Court of Justice was raised as a possibility |
| Düsseldorf Higher Regional Court, I-20 W 2/26 | Germany | 2 Apr 2026, in interim injunction proceedings: an AI image resembling a photograph did not infringe, because protected creative elements were not reproduced | Further steps not known |
Text and music cases that shape the image disputes
Photographers and agencies watch these because the reasoning will be borrowed.
| Case | Court | Decided | Pending |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thomson Reuters v Ross Intelligence | D. Delaware; Third Circuit | 29 Sep 2026: not fair use to copy Westlaw headnotes to train a non-generative legal search tool. Generative AI distinguished | Ross has asked the court to revisit the ruling, according to MLex |
| Bartz v Anthropic | N.D. California | 23 Jun 2025: training on lawfully bought books was fair use; keeping pirated books was not. $1.5bn settlement approved 20 Jul 2026 | Whether any appeal from approval is pending: unverified |
| Kadrey v Meta | N.D. California | 25 Jun 2025: summary judgment for Meta on training, on a limited record about market harm | Claims about distribution through BitTorrent continue |
| New York Times v OpenAI and Microsoft, with consolidated cases | S.D. New York | No fair-use ruling | Summary judgment being briefed; the latest briefing dates reported run to 18 Dec 2026 |
| Concord v Anthropic | N.D. California | No ruling | Fair-use summary judgment argued 21 Oct 2026 and taken under submission |
| GEMA v OpenAI | Munich Regional Court I, 42 O 14139/24 | 11 Nov 2025: memorised song lyrics are reproductions outside the text and data mining exception | On appeal to the Munich Higher Regional Court |
| GEMA v Suno | Munich Regional Court I, 42 O 763/25 | 31 Jul 2026: training on stream-ripped music infringed; exception failed partly for lack of lawful access | Not final. Appeal status unverified |
| Like Company v Google Ireland | EU Court of Justice, C-250/25 | Nothing binding. Advocate General's opinion delivered 3 Nov 2026 | Judgment, date not set |
Timeline of key dates
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| January 2023 | Getty issues its High Court claim against Stability AI; Andersen class action filed in California |
| 27 December 2023 | New York Times sues OpenAI and Microsoft |
| August 2024 | Andersen: core claims survive motion to dismiss |
| 27 September 2024 | Kneschke v LAION: Hamburg Regional Court rules for LAION |
| 11 February 2025 | Thomson Reuters v Ross: district court rejects fair use |
| 11 June 2025 | Disney and Universal sue Midjourney |
| 9 to 30 June 2025 | Getty v Stability AI trial in London; training claim abandoned |
| 23 and 25 June 2025 | Bartz v Anthropic and Kadrey v Meta fair-use rulings |
| 14 August 2025 | Getty refiles its US claim in the Northern District of California |
| 4 November 2025 | Getty v Stability AI: High Court judgment |
| 11 November 2025 | GEMA v OpenAI: Munich judgment |
| 10 December 2025 | Kneschke v LAION: Hamburg appeal dismissed |
| 2 April 2026 | Düsseldorf appeal ruling on an AI image resembling a photograph |
| 23 April 2026 | Getty v Stability AI (US): motion to dismiss decided |
| July 2026 | Evox Productions files three image suits |
| 20 July 2026 | Bartz settlement receives final approval |
| 31 July 2026 | GEMA v Suno: Munich judgment |
| 3 September 2026 | Kneschke v LAION: Federal Court of Justice hearing |
| 29 September 2026 | Thomson Reuters v Ross: Third Circuit affirms |
| 21 October 2026 | Concord v Anthropic: summary judgment hearing |
| 3 November 2026 | Like Company v Google: Advocate General's opinion |
| 11 and 12 November 2026 | Getty v Stability AI: Court of Appeal hearing |
What has actually been decided?
Less than the volume of litigation suggests. Drawing only on the rulings above:
- In England, a trained model that does not store the training images is not an "infringing copy" for the purposes of secondary infringement. That finding is the one under appeal. The detail is in our Getty v Stability AI timeline.
- In Germany, building a research dataset of image links and descriptions was held to fall within the text and data mining exceptions, and a reservation written in ordinary language did not count as machine-readable. That too is under appeal; see Kneschke v LAION and machine-readable opt-outs.
- Also in Germany, a model that has memorised a work and can reproduce it is outside the exception, and so is training on unlawfully obtained copies. Both rulings concern music and neither is final.
- In the United States, three courts have ruled on fair use for training on text. Two found for the developer on particular facts and one, on appeal, against. Our article on fair use after Thomson Reuters v Ross compares them.
What is still pending?
The decisions most likely to change practice for photographs, in no predicted order:
- The Court of Appeal's judgment in Getty v Stability AI.
- The Federal Court of Justice's decision in Kneschke, or a reference from it to the EU Court of Justice.
- The EU Court of Justice's judgment in Like Company v Google Ireland.
- A first US fair-use ruling on an image model, in Getty, Andersen, the Midjourney cases or the Evox suits.
- Summary judgment in the New York Times and Concord cases.
This page covers the cases with the most bearing on images and training data. Many more copyright suits against AI companies are on foot, particularly in the United States.
Claims to treat with caution
Some statements circulate widely and are not supported by the record as we found it.
- "Getty decided that AI training is lawful in the UK." The training claim was abandoned. The court did not rule on it.
- "The Andersen case went to a jury in September 2026." Docket-based reports show the schedule was extended that month. No trial has been held.
- "AI training is fair use in the US", and its opposite. Neither is established. The decided cases concern text, turn on their facts, and no court has ruled on image models.
- "The Bartz settlement sets a price per work." It resolved claims over pirated books under statutory-damages exposure. It is not a licence rate and does not concern photographs.
- "A notice in website terms is a valid EU opt-out." The Hamburg appeal court held otherwise, and the point is before the Federal Court of Justice.
How to follow these cases yourself
Primary records are the safest source. English judgments are published by the National Archives' Find Case Law service. EU opinions and judgments appear on the Court of Justice's Curia site. US dockets can be read through CourtListener. Law-firm trackers such as Mishcon de Reya's are useful for cross-checking, and the better ones date every entry.
If your interest is practical, the working documents matter as much as the judgments. Knowing exactly which files were supplied to whom is the foundation of any later claim or defence, and a fingerprint of each file is the simplest record. Our free image hash and fingerprint tool generates one in the browser.
The alternative to waiting
Every case in these tables arose from a dispute over use said to have taken place without a licence. For buyers of image data, the more certain route is the contractual one: a licence from the owner, on stated terms, for a described set of images.
Archive.London is the home of the Robert Harper Photograph Library, 95,487 unique photographs on the inventory's count by a single photographer, owned by 825 Ventures Ltd, the owner and rights holder. More than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned, and only a small selection has been published online by Archive.London, from studio still life to the music collections. Licences are negotiated directly and are subject to rights review. Counsel, journalists and data teams who want to understand what is available can start at AI training data licensing.
Frequently asked questions
Has any court ruled that training AI on images is copyright infringement?
Not directly, as of 18 November 2026. The English High Court did not rule on training in Getty v Stability AI because that claim was abandoned. German courts held that building the LAION dataset was covered by text and data mining exceptions. No US court has decided fair use for an image model. Decisions on text and music exist and point in different directions.
What is the status of Andersen v Stability AI?
It is still in the pre-trial phase in the Northern District of California. Copyright claims and some Lanham Act claims survived a motion to dismiss in August 2024. The schedule was extended in February 2026 and again in September 2026. No trial has taken place, despite at least one widely indexed post claiming otherwise.
What is happening in the Disney and Universal lawsuit against Midjourney?
The case, filed on 11 June 2025 and consolidated with Warner Bros. Discovery's suit on 14 November 2025, is in discovery in the Central District of California. Midjourney agreed on 6 October 2026 to hand over video training datasets. A court-ordered mediation deadline passed on 19 August 2026; we could not verify the outcome.
Which AI copyright cases involve photographs specifically?
Getty Images v Stability AI in London and California; Kneschke v LAION in Germany, brought by a stock photographer; the three Evox Productions suits filed in July 2026 by an automotive photo library; and Andersen v Stability AI, which concerns visual artists more broadly. A German appeal ruling of 2 April 2026 also considered an AI image resembling a photograph.
How often is this tracker updated?
The page carries a 'checked on' date and each row says whether the point is decided or pending. This version was checked on 18 November 2026. Litigation moves quickly and court schedules change, so confirm the current position against the court record or a recent report before relying on any entry.
Sources
- Getty Images v Stability AI 2025 EWHC 2863 (Ch), The National Archives
- Burges Salmon: Getty Images v Stability AI, Court of Appeal hearing (12 November 2026)
- CourtListener: Getty Images (US) Inc v Stability AI Ltd, N.D. Cal. docket
- ChatGPT Is Eating the World: Getty Images v Stability AI docket reports (US scheduling order and motion to dismiss ruling)
- Mishcon de Reya: Generative AI intellectual property cases and policy tracker
- ChatGPT Is Eating the World: Andersen v Stability AI docket reports
- ChatGPT Is Eating the World: Disney v Midjourney docket reports
- Morgan Lewis: AI and copyright, judicial landscape in Germany (25 June 2026)
- beck-aktuell: Federal Court of Justice hearing in Kneschke v LAION (3 September 2026)
- Simmons & Simmons: GEMA v Suno AI, key EU decision on AI training, outputs and copyright
- Court of Justice of the EU: Advocate General's opinion in C-250/25 Like Company v Google Ireland
- Haynes Boone: Third Circuit rejects fair use for Ross's copying of Westlaw headnotes
- MLex: Ross Intelligence asked US appeals court to revisit AI case over Westlaw
- Authors Guild: Court grants final approval of Anthropic copyright settlement
- Polsinelli: AI vs authors update, Anthropic settlement approved while Meta litigation continues
- AI Musicpreneur: Concord v Anthropic fair use summary judgment hearing, October 2026
This article is general information, not legal advice. It reflects the position as we understood it on the date shown and may be out of date. Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

