Cameras, film and formats compared

From tungsten to strobe: a short history of studio flash

People sit and recline on a broad sandy beach beside calm water.
A day on the beach.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

Before the power pack, a studio was a warm room where everything had to keep still. Afterwards a drink could be thrown in the air and photographed on the way down.

Studio flash did not make photographs brighter so much as shorter, and in a still life the short ones are the ones that sell the drink.

Studio flash replaced tungsten lamps over roughly two decades, from the first commercial units around 1950 to general adoption in the 1960s, and the usual explanation is that it was brighter and cooler. Both are true. Neither is the interesting part. The change that mattered to still-life photographers was duration. A tungsten lamp burns for as long as the switch is on; a flash tube burns for a few thousandths or ten-thousandths of a second. Our angle here is what that brevity did to the pictures themselves: it allowed a studio, for the first time, to photograph things that will not hold still, such as a pour, a splash, a bubble or a curl of smoke.

What did studios use before electronic flash?

Daylight first, then fire. In 1859 Robert Bunsen and Henry Roscoe showed that burning magnesium gave a light resembling daylight, and magnesium ribbon was soon sold for photography. In 1887 Adolf Miethe and Johannes Gaedicke introduced flash powder, magnesium mixed with potassium chlorate and set off by hand. It worked, and it was dangerous. Commercial flashbulbs, which sealed the metal in an oxygen-filled glass envelope, appeared in Germany in 1929. They were safer, bright and used once.

None of this suited a studio producing pictures all day. The working answer was incandescent light. The Swiss Camera Museum in Vevey dates the first use of electric lighting in photography to the end of the nineteenth century and notes that incandescent lamps then became common in studios. Tungsten lighting had one large virtue: the photographer could see exactly what the film would see, and adjust a reflector by an inch while looking.

Its faults were all consequences of running continuously. The lamps were hot, which was hard on sitters and worse on food. The light was much yellower than daylight, so colour work needed film balanced for it or filters that cost exposure. And because large-format still life is shot at small apertures, exposures ran to whole seconds. Anything that moved, wilted, melted or evaporated in that time was a problem. Ice was a prop to be faked. Liquid was photographed at rest.

Who invented electronic flash, and when?

The principle is to store electrical energy in a capacitor and release it at once through a gas-filled tube. The Swiss Camera Museum gives a careful sequence: Laurent and Augustin Seguin presented the Stroborama in 1925, which the museum calls the true invention of the electronic flash; Paul Laporte proposed xenon as the gas in 1936, because its light is close to daylight; and Harold Edgerton designed the first studio electronic flash in 1939.

Edgerton is the name that stuck, with reason. He began working with the stroboscope at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 1931, synchronising flashes with moving machinery to study it, and then turned the instrument on the world: a drop of milk forming a coronet, athletes in mid-stride, bullets bursting balloons. His milk-drop coronet was shown in the Museum of Modern Art's first photography exhibition in 1937. In 1947 he co-founded EG&G with Kenneth Germeshausen and Herbert Grier. The flash tube he introduced reaches full brightness almost instantly and is over in less than a thousandth of a second.

Edgerton's pictures were science that happened to be beautiful. It took the lighting industry another twenty years to put the same effect within reach of a commercial studio photographing a gin and tonic.

When did studio flash replace tungsten?

Date Development Source
1887 Flash powder introduced by Miethe and Gaedicke Wikipedia: Flash (photography)
1929 Commercial flashbulbs appear in Germany Wikipedia: Flash (photography)
1931 Edgerton begins stroboscope work at MIT Lemelson-MIT Program
1939 Edgerton designs the first studio electronic flash Swiss Camera Museum
1950 Bowens, a London camera repair firm founded in 1923, begins making electronic studio flash with separate generators Wikipedia: Bowens International
1953 Pierre Bron's company produces the first Broncolor flash Swiss Camera Museum
1963 Bowens credited with the first monobloc, a flash with its power source built in Wikipedia: Bowens, Monolight
1960s Studio electronic flash replaces incandescent lamps in studios Swiss Camera Museum
1968 Profoto founded in Stockholm by Conny Dufgran and Eckhard Heine Wikipedia: Profoto

Two notes on that table. The Bowens claim to the first monobloc rests on a Wikipedia article that itself asks for better citations, so we give it as credited, not proven. And the Broncolor date is the museum's; Wikipedia's entry for the company gives 1958 as its founding year with a first listed product of the same date. We have preferred the museum.

The early studio units were pack-and-head systems. A floor-standing generator held the capacitors and the controls, and cables ran to one or more flash heads. Each head carried a modelling lamp, a small continuous bulb beside the flash tube, which restored something of tungsten's great virtue by letting the photographer see roughly where the shadows would fall.

What changed when the light became short?

Three things, and the third is the one that altered the look of advertising.

Heat and comfort. Flash delivers its energy in an instant and is otherwise dark, apart from the modelling lamps. Sets stayed cool. Food stayed fresh for longer, and people could keep their eyes open.

Colour. Xenon flash is close to daylight in colour, so daylight-balanced film could be used in the studio without heavy filtration. This mattered a great deal once colour transparency film became the standard material for magazines and advertising, as described in why studios used medium-format transparency film.

Time. In a darkened studio the camera's shutter can simply be opened and the flash fired. The exposure then lasts as long as the flash and no longer. A photographer with a power pack had, in effect, a shutter speed far beyond anything a mechanical shutter on a view camera could offer.

Consider a splash moving at two metres a second, which is slow for thrown liquid. During a one-second tungsten exposure it travels two metres and records as nothing at all. At 1/1,000 second it moves two millimetres, a visible smear at close range. At 1/10,000 second it moves a fifth of a millimetre and looks like glass. The entire genre of the frozen pour, the crown of liquid rising from a glass and the ice cube caught at the instant of entry depends on that last figure. It was Edgerton's milk drop, industrialised.

What do watt-seconds, t0.5 and t0.1 actually mean?

Studio flash is rated in watt-seconds, which are joules: the electrical energy stored in the capacitors. It is a measure of what goes in, not of the light that comes out, which also depends on the efficiency of the tube and the reflector. Small flashguns reduce their output by cutting the discharge short; larger studio units generally vary the charge.

Duration is quoted in two ways. t0.5 is the time the light stays above half its peak. t0.1 is the time it stays above a tenth of its peak. A flash rises almost instantly and decays in a long tail, and the tail still exposes film, so t0.1 is the longer and more honest figure for judging motion. A unit advertised on its t0.5 can look fast on paper and still leave a soft edge on a falling drop. Duration also changes with the power setting, in a direction that depends on the design, so makers publish a table for each unit.

For the shortest events there are specialised sources. Air-gap flashes produce pulses of less than a millionth of a second and are used in scientific imaging, which is how a bullet is caught in flight.

What did flash make harder?

It made the light invisible. With tungsten, what you saw was what you got. With flash, the exposure happened in an instant that no eye could assess, and the modelling lamps gave only an approximation, especially with glass and liquid, where reflections are everything. Flash meters helped with exposure. They could not show where a highlight would land on a bottle.

The practical answer for some three decades was instant film. A Polaroid back on the camera gave a proof of the actual flash exposure in a minute or two, and the photographer adjusted and tried again before committing to transparency film. We describe that routine in Polaroid proofing before digital. Flash also demanded power in proportion to format: the larger the film, the smaller the aperture needed for depth of field, and the more watt-seconds required, as our note on medium-format lenses and their 35mm equivalents explains.

How can you tell tungsten from flash in an old photograph?

With caution. Signs of flash include frozen motion that a long exposure could not hold, crisp neutral colour, and the shapes of the light sources mirrored in glass or metal: a rectangular softbox or a strip light shows up as a clean-edged highlight. Signs of tungsten include warmth, a slight softness in anything that could move, and smaller, harder reflections. None of these is proof, and an old transparency that has shifted colour with age can mislead.

Digital files are easier. Most cameras record whether a flash fired in the file's EXIF data, which our EXIF viewer will display, though a studio pack triggered by a cable is not always recorded there. For film, the best evidence is whatever came with it: proofing Polaroids, and the lab's notes on the bag, which are the subject of clip tests, pushes and pulls.

Where this shows in the Robert Harper archive

The inventory lists twelve folders of drinks photography, including two folders of cocktails catalogued at 423 and 630 frames, 710 frames of glasses and a folder of ice cubes, shakers and other accessories. One entry records the working method of the period in a single line: a Cinzano shoot held as 10 x 8 inch transparencies with 19 Polaroids, together with 5 x 4 inch and 6 x 7 film. We have not yet catalogued the lighting of individual shoots, and we will not guess at it. But the combination of sheet film and proofing Polaroids is exactly the routine described above, and the library holds 4,005 Polaroid prints in all.

The same applies to the advertising collection and to the glass and liquid work discussed in photographing fragrance bottles. More than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned. Museums, curators and writers working on the history of studio practice are welcome to ask what the catalogue can show; the professional access page explains how, and our directory of galleries and museums is a starting point for anyone who wants to see the history of the medium in person.

Frequently asked questions

Who invented electronic flash?

Harold Edgerton of MIT is usually credited: he began work on the stroboscope in 1931 and developed the electronic flash tube. The Swiss Camera Museum notes an earlier step, the Stroborama shown by Laurent and Augustin Seguin in 1925, and credits Edgerton with designing the first studio electronic flash in 1939.

When did studios switch from tungsten to flash?

Gradually, between about 1950 and 1970. Bowens began making electronic studio flash in 1950 and the first Broncolor flash dates from 1953. The Swiss Camera Museum says studio electronic flash replaced incandescent lamps in the 1960s. Tungsten never vanished: it stayed in use for film sets and for some still-life work.

What is the difference between a power pack and a monolight?

A pack-and-head system keeps the capacitors and controls in one generator box and feeds separate flash heads through cables. A monolight, or monobloc, builds the power supply and controls into each head. Packs suit high power and several heads in a fixed studio. Monolights are simpler to carry and need a mains socket each.

What do t0.5 and t0.1 mean for flash duration?

They measure how long a flash lasts. t0.5 is the time the light stays above half its peak intensity. t0.1 is the time above one tenth of peak, and it is always longer. Because the dim tail of the flash still exposes the film or sensor, t0.1 is the better guide to whether movement will be sharp.

How does flash freeze a liquid splash?

In a darkened studio the shutter can stay open while the flash alone makes the exposure, so the effective exposure time is the flash duration. A flash lasting a few ten-thousandths of a second records a falling drop or a thrown drink as a sharp shape, where a mechanical shutter at ordinary speeds would show a blur.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

Help digitise the archive

52,684 analogue originals, mostly medium-format transparencies, are waiting to be scanned and catalogued. We are speaking to scanning, cataloguing and tagging partners.

See the digitisation briefWrite to the archive