Cameras, film and formats compared

When studios went digital: the first pro DSLRs and their raw files

A man in white stands beside a picnic blanket while a small group sit behind him.
A picnic on the grass.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

There was no single day. Newspapers went first, studios last, and the changeover left every working archive with a seam: boxes of film on one side, folders of raw files on the other.

Film is evidence that says nothing, and a raw file is a witness that will not stop talking; an archive needs to know how to question both.

Professional photographers switched to digital over roughly the decade that began in 1999, in an order set by deadlines and page sizes: news and sport first, studios and fashion last. The dates below come from the manufacturers' launches and contemporary reviews. Our angle is the view from the other end of the process. Histories of the changeover are usually written from the camera shop. This one is written from the archive, where the same years appear as a seam in the holdings. On one side there are boxes of transparencies that record nothing about how they were made. On the other there are folders of raw files that record almost everything except what the picture is of.

What was the first professional digital SLR?

Kodak built it. The Kodak DCS of 1991, later known as the DCS 100, was the first commercially available digital single-lens reflex: a Nikon F3 film camera fitted with a 1.3 megapixel Kodak sensor, connected to a separate processing and storage unit that the photographer carried on a shoulder strap. The DCS 200 followed in 1992 on a Nikon F-801s body, with an 80 MB hard drive attached to the camera.

For most of the 1990s that was the pattern. A film camera maker supplied the body, Kodak supplied the electronics, and the result was priced for news organisations. The DCS 460 of 1994 offered 6 megapixels at a launch price of $28,000. The DCS 520 of 1998 was built on a Canon EOS-1n and the DCS 620 of 1999 on a Nikon F5, each with about 2 megapixels. These cameras earned their keep where speed beat quality: a picture transmitted from a stadium before the film could have reached a darkroom.

When did digital become good enough for a magazine page?

The arithmetic is simple and it explains the whole timetable. Print reproduction is conventionally specified at 300 pixels per inch. An A4 page is 8.27 x 11.69 inches, so it needs about 2,480 x 3,508 pixels, or 8.7 megapixels.

Camera Announced Resolution Prints at 300 ppi Notes
Kodak DCS (DCS 100) 1991 1.3 MP A few inches wide Nikon F3 body, separate shoulder unit
Kodak DCS 460 1994 6 MP (3,060 x 2,036) About 10 x 7 inches $28,000 at launch
Nikon D1 15 June 1999 2.7 MP (2,000 x 1,312) About 6.7 x 4.4 inches US$5,500 body only
Nikon D1X 5 February 2001 About 5.3 MP effective (3,008 x 1,960 output) About 10 x 6.5 inches Replaced the D1 alongside the faster D1H
Canon EOS-1Ds September 2002 About 11.1 MP About 13.5 x 9 inches Full-frame 35.8 x 23.8 mm CMOS sensor
Kodak DCS Pro 14n 2002 14 MP (4,500 x 3,000) 15 x 10 inches Full frame, Nikon F80 body

Our megapixel sums are easy to check with the megapixel calculator. The point of the table is the fourth column. A newspaper picture three columns wide was within reach by 1999. A full-bleed magazine page was not comfortably within reach of a 35mm-style camera until 2002.

Why was the Nikon D1 the turning point?

Price, and the fact that it was one object. Nikon announced the D1 on 15 June 1999 with a 2.7 megapixel sensor and a body price of US$5,500. DPReview's review at the time called it the first "home grown" digital SLR from a major manufacturer, and noted that it cost about half, possibly a third, as much as the closest Nikon-based rival, the Kodak DCS 620, while out-resolving it. Wikipedia's account credits the D1 with displacing Kodak from its dominance of the professional market.

The D1 recorded JPEGs, TIFFs and 12-bit raw files, the last of which needed Nikon's own software to open. On 5 February 2001 it was replaced by a pair, the D1X for resolution and the D1H for speed. For press photographers the argument was over. A news organisation could now equip a photographer with a digital camera for a fraction of what the Kodak hybrids had cost.

Kodak, which had invented the category, withdrew from it. It discontinued its last professional SLRs in May 2005 to concentrate on compact cameras and digital backs for medium-format cameras.

Why did studios hold out longer than newspapers?

Because their benchmark was not 35mm negative film printed on newsprint. It was medium-format and large-format transparency film, reproduced at full page or across a spread and examined by art directors with a magnifier.

A 6x7 transparency scanned at 4,000 ppi yields about 97 megapixels. Even allowing that film does not resolve to the limit of such a scan, a 2.7 megapixel file was no substitute, and neither was 6. Studio photographers also needed things press photographers did not: flash synchronisation with powerful packs, lenses with movements for product work, and colour that a client would approve against a physical sample. Their first route into digital was often a digital back fitted to an existing medium-format or view camera, tethered to a computer, the line of business that Kodak retreated to in 2005.

The full-frame cameras of 2002 changed the calculation for location, fashion and portrait work. Canon's EOS-1Ds put about 11.1 million pixels on a sensor the size of a 35mm frame, with no change in how lenses behaved. That is enough for an A4 page at 300 ppi with a little to spare. From that point the question for a working photographer was less whether to change than when the clients, the repro houses and the picture desks would all accept files in place of film.

There was also the matter of proofing. A screen on the back of the camera replaced the instant print that studios had relied on for decades to check lighting, which is the routine described in Polaroid proofing before digital.

What is a raw file, and why did professionals shoot it?

A raw file holds the sensor's data before the camera has turned it into a finished picture. Where a standard JPEG stores 8 bits per channel, 256 levels, a raw file typically stores 12 or 14 bits, which is 4,096 to 16,384 levels. White balance, contrast and sharpening are applied afterwards and can be changed repeatedly without damaging the original, which is why raw files are called digital negatives.

Each maker has its own format. Nikon's is NEF, which is built on the TIFF/EP standard with proprietary additions; parts of some Nikon raw files are encrypted. Formats also change from one camera model to the next and are often undocumented. That is the long-term risk: a file is only as readable as the software that understands it. Adobe introduced DNG in 2004 as an openly documented alternative, and the Library of Congress lists proprietary raw formats as less desirable for preservation, recommending DNG. What to do about that in practice is the subject of preserving NEF and other raw files.

What does the changeover look like from inside an archive?

It looks like two different kinds of evidence.

Film original Raw file
Date of exposure Not recorded on the film; taken from bags, job sheets or publication Recorded in metadata, to the second, if the camera clock was right
Camera and lens Not recorded Usually recorded
Exposure settings Not recorded Recorded
Subject, place, client From written notes From written notes or filenames, if any
Copies Each duplicate is a generation removed Every copy is identical
To use it Must be scanned Must be decoded by software
Main risk Physical decay and colour fading Format obsolescence and storage failure

The middle rows are the reason archives treat the two differently. A raw file will tell you the shutter speed of a picture taken twenty years ago, and you can read it in a browser with our EXIF viewer. It will not tell you who is in the picture. A transparency tells you neither, but the bag it came in may tell you both. Cataloguing has to join the two kinds of record into one consistent description, which is slower than either scanning or copying.

For anyone assembling image data, the seam matters in another way. Born-digital files and film scans differ in resolution, noise, colour response and metadata, and a collection that spans both should say so. We discuss that in raw files and film originals as high-resolution training images.

Where the seam falls in the Robert Harper archive

The inventory of the Robert Harper Photograph Library counts 95,487 unique photographs: 52,684 analogue and 42,803 digital. The analogue side is mostly 6 x 7 colour transparency film. The digital side is recorded in the inventory as a single folder of Nikon NEF raw files, TIFFs and JPEGs on a wide variety of subjects, including sailing, superyachts, flying, landscapes and portraits, which fits a later career in marine photography. These counts come from the inventory and have not yet been independently reconciled.

We have not yet established the year in which the archive's film stops and its files begin, and we will not put a date on it until the files' own metadata has been read and checked. That is one of the more satisfying tasks ahead, because it is a question the digital files can answer for themselves. The folder-by-folder figures are in the archive inventory, and the formats, counts and known limitations are set out for data teams in the dataset card. Licensing for AI and data use is available by negotiation with the single rights holder, subject to rights review; the AI training data licensing page explains how to start that conversation.

Frequently asked questions

When did professional photographers switch to digital?

In stages, over roughly the decade that began in 1999. Press and sports photographers moved first, once the Nikon D1 of 1999 made a digital SLR affordable. Studio, fashion and advertising photographers followed after 2002, when full-frame sensors of 11 megapixels and more could fill a magazine page. Many worked with both film and digital for several years.

What was the first professional digital SLR?

The Kodak DCS, later called the DCS 100, of 1991. It used a Nikon F3 camera body fitted with a 1.3 megapixel Kodak sensor, with processing and storage in a separate unit carried on the shoulder. The Nikon D1 of 1999 is often called the first digital SLR designed as a whole by a major camera maker.

How many megapixels did early professional DSLRs have?

Very few by later standards. The 1991 Kodak DCS had 1.3 megapixels. Kodak's DCS 460 of 1994 reached 6 megapixels at a launch price of $28,000. The Nikon D1 of 1999 had 2.7 megapixels, its 2001 successor the D1X about 5.3, and the Canon EOS-1Ds of 2002 about 11.1.

What is a NEF file?

NEF is Nikon's raw file format. A raw file stores the sensor's data before the camera turns it into a finished picture, typically at 12 or 14 bits per channel, together with metadata such as the date, camera model and exposure settings. NEF is built on the TIFF/EP standard, with proprietary elements that need suitable software to read.

Are raw files better than film scans for an archive?

They are different kinds of original. A raw file is already digital, carries its own capture data and can be copied without loss, but depends on software that understands a proprietary format. Film has to be scanned and described by hand, yet a 6x7 transparency scanned at 4,000 ppi yields about 97 megapixels, far more than early digital cameras produced.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

Help digitise the archive

52,684 analogue originals, mostly medium-format transparencies, are waiting to be scanned and catalogued. We are speaking to scanning, cataloguing and tagging partners.

See the digitisation briefWrite to the archive