Digitising film archives

Scanning medium-format transparencies: resolution, colour, files

A man in a flat cap works behind taut threads on a wooden loom.
A weaver at a loom.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

A 6x7 transparency scanned to the highest published film standard becomes a 97-megapixel, 583 MB file. Whether you need that depends on three decisions, taken in order.

Scan a 6x7 centimetre transparency at 4,000 pixels per inch and 16 bits per channel, the top level in the most detailed published standard for film, and you get a file of about 8,819 by 11,024 pixels: 97 megapixels and roughly 583 MB as an uncompressed TIFF. That is a lot of data for one photograph. Whether it is the right amount depends on three decisions, best taken in this order: resolution, colour, file format.

Medium-format transparencies deserve the care. A transparency is a camera original and a finished positive at once, the thing the photographer and the art director looked at on the lightbox. It is also the predominant material in the analogue holdings of the Robert Harper Photograph Library, which the archive's inventory describes as mostly medium-format colour transparencies.

What counts as a medium-format transparency?

Medium format in this context means roll film, most commonly the 120 size, which is about six centimetres wide. Different cameras expose different lengths of it, giving a family of frame shapes on the same stock.

Nominal format Approximate image area Shape
6x4.5 56 x 42 mm 4:3
6x6 56 x 56 mm Square
6x7 56 x 70 mm Close to 5:4
6x9 56 x 84 mm 3:2

Actual image areas vary a little from camera to camera, so measure a sample before fixing crop sizes. A transparency, also called reversal or slide film, is a positive: light areas of the subject are light on the film. That makes it easier to assess than a negative and harder to scan, because its darkest areas are very dense.

What resolution should medium-format transparencies be scanned at?

Two public reference points agree at the top end.

The US Federal Agencies Digital Guidelines Initiative publishes the Technical Guidelines for Digitizing Cultural Heritage Materials, third edition, approved on 10 May 2023. Its tables for transparencies from 35mm up to 4x5 inches set a target resolution for each of four quality levels, with a small measurement tolerance: about 1,000 ppi at one star, 2,000 at two, 3,000 at three and 4,000 at four. Film of 4x5 inches and above has lower targets, 500 to 2,000 ppi, because the film itself is larger.

In the UK, The National Archives' digitisation guidance, written for public bodies digitising records, gives a minimum of 4,000 ppi for photographic transparencies, against 600 ppi for photographic prints and 300 ppi for ordinary documents.

Here is what those levels produce from two common frame sizes. The figures assume nominal image areas and uncompressed RGB TIFF.

Resolution 6x6 pixels 6x6, 16-bit TIFF 6x7 pixels 6x7, 16-bit TIFF
2,000 ppi 4,409 x 4,409 (19 MP) about 117 MB 4,409 x 5,512 (24 MP) about 146 MB
3,000 ppi 6,614 x 6,614 (44 MP) about 262 MB 6,614 x 8,268 (55 MP) about 328 MB
4,000 ppi 8,819 x 8,819 (78 MP) about 467 MB 8,819 x 11,024 (97 MP) about 583 MB

For other formats and for working backwards from a print size, use the film scan resolution calculator. A 6x7 frame at 3,000 ppi already prints at about 22 by 28 inches at 300 ppi, which covers most editorial and exhibition uses.

Two cautions. First, sampling resolution is not resolving power. The Canadian Heritage Information Network's scanning guide (25 May 2023) advises testing a scanner's effective resolution with a target, because delivered detail often falls short of the stated figure. Second, the international standard for measuring imaging systems, ISO 19264-1:2021, covers reflective originals only; ISO says a later part will address transparent originals. For film, FADGI's tables are the benchmark to cite.

How many bits, and why do transparencies need more?

FADGI's film tables call for 16 bits per channel at three and four stars and allow 8 bits at one and two. The Canadian guide treats 8 bits as the minimum and 16 as ideal. The National Archives' guidance, which is aimed at records more than at photographic collections, specifies 24-bit colour, which is 8 bits per channel.

For a photographic archive the case for 16 bits rests on density. Transparency film holds very deep shadows, and the Canadian guide accordingly suggests a scanner density range of at least 3.5, with 4.0 as the ideal and rarely found in affordable equipment. Recording those shadows with more tonal steps leaves room to open them later without banding. Whether a scan has actually captured both ends of the range is quick to check: the image histogram tool reports the percentage of clipped shadow and highlight pixels in a derivative.

How should colour be managed when scanning transparencies?

A transparency has one great advantage over a negative: it can be compared directly with the scan. FADGI's guidance on transparencies has long been that the tonal scale and colour balance of the digital image should match the original, and the third edition describes a workflow of capturing raw, adjusting in a calibrated environment and tagging the corrected file with its profile.

In practice that means four things, all of which appear in the Canadian guide.

  • Calibrate and profile the scanner using an IT8 target on transparency film. A profile made for the specific film type is better still but not essential.
  • Calibrate the monitor with a colorimeter. Adjusting by eye is not reliable.
  • Embed the profile in every master file.
  • Keep adjustments out of the master. Make corrections on a separate production copy.

On the choice of colour space the standards disagree, and it is worth knowing that before a vendor asks. FADGI lists Adobe RGB (1998), ProPhoto and eciRGB v2 for three- and four-star film capture, admitting sRGB only at the two lower levels. The National Archives' guidance specifies an sRGB profile. A project should choose one, give its reason and apply it without exception.

Fading raises a separate question. Colour dyes change with age, and the Library of Congress notes that temperature is the main factor in the stability of colour materials, recommending cold storage. A scan should record the film as it now is. Reconstruction of what the dyes once looked like is interpretation, and belongs in a derivative.

What handling details matter for roll-film transparencies?

Medium-format film is large enough to sag in a holder and glossy enough to produce Newton's rings against plain glass, so film flatness and the choice of carrier affect sharpness across the frame. Beyond that, the routine is the same as for any film: hold by the edges with clean gloves, remove dust with a squeeze-bulb blower, and check which way round each batch sits. The Canadian guide notes that the emulsion (dull) side generally goes up on a flatbed but that each batch should be checked.

Infrared dust and scratch detection, where the scanner has it, works with colour transparencies and must be applied at the time of scanning. And leave a margin: the same guide recommends keeping some film border in the archival master, cropping only in derivatives.

Which file format should the master be?

FADGI's film tables name two master formats at every level, TIFF and JPEG 2000. The National Archives' guidance likewise accepts lossless JPEG 2000 or baseline TIFF 6.0. TIFF is the common choice for photographic masters; the trade-offs, including where DNG fits for camera-based capture, are set out in TIFF, DNG or JPEG 2000: choosing a preservation format.

Whatever the master, working copies will be JPEGs. The TIFF to JPG converter handles 8-bit and 16-bit scans in the browser, though very large TIFFs need a desktop computer. How transparencies compare with other capture routes is covered in scanner, drum or camera.

The transparencies in the Robert Harper archive

The archive's inventory records 52,684 analogue photographs, mostly medium-format colour transparencies, from a career that included more than fifteen years as a regular contributor to Elle and The Telegraph Magazine. Film stocks, exact frame sizes and condition have not yet been published, and more than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned. Those are the facts a scanning specification will have to be built on. Technicians, labs and imaging vendors with experience of colour transparencies at volume are invited to make contact through the digitisation partners page.

Frequently asked questions

What resolution should I scan medium format transparencies at?

Published standards point to between 3,000 and 4,000 ppi for preservation masters. FADGI rates about 3,000 ppi as three stars and about 4,000 ppi as four stars for film up to 4x5 inches, and the UK National Archives' guidance gives 4,000 ppi as its minimum for transparencies. For access copies and editing, 2,000 ppi is often ample.

How big is a 6x7 scan at 4,000 ppi?

A nominal 56 x 70 mm frame scanned at 4,000 ppi measures about 8,819 x 11,024 pixels, or 97 megapixels. As an uncompressed RGB TIFF that is roughly 292 MB at 8 bits per channel and 583 MB at 16 bits. At 3,000 ppi the same frame is about 55 megapixels and 328 MB at 16 bits.

Should transparency scans be 8-bit or 16-bit?

Use 16 bits per channel for masters. FADGI requires 16-bit files at its three- and four-star levels for film, and the Canadian Heritage Information Network calls 16 bits ideal. Transparencies have deep shadows, and the extra tonal steps allow later adjustment without visible banding. Derivatives for web and layout can be 8-bit.

Which colour space is best for scanning slide film?

There is no single answer in the standards. FADGI lists Adobe RGB (1998), ProPhoto and eciRGB v2 for its higher levels, while the UK National Archives' guidance specifies sRGB. What matters most is that the scanner is profiled, the chosen profile is embedded in every file, and the choice is written into the project specification.

Should faded colour be corrected in the scan?

Not in the master. FADGI's guidance for transparencies is that tone and colour in the file should match the original as it is. Record the film faithfully, keep that file untouched, and make any restoration of faded dyes on a separately saved production copy, so that the correction can be revisited as tools and judgement improve.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

Help digitise the archive

52,684 analogue originals, mostly medium-format transparencies, are waiting to be scanned and catalogued. We are speaking to scanning, cataloguing and tagging partners.

See the digitisation briefWrite to the archive