A licence from the copyright owner covers the photograph. It does not cover the person in it. Data protection and likeness are separate questions, and for image datasets they are often the harder ones.
A photograph of an identifiable living person is personal data. That is true whoever took it, whoever owns the copyright and however long ago it was made, provided the person is alive and can be recognised. So an image dataset can be properly licensed in copyright terms and still raise a second set of questions that the licence does not answer.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Checked on 18 November 2026.
When is a photograph personal data?
Under the UK GDPR and the EU GDPR, personal data is information relating to an identified or identifiable living individual. For photographs, three things decide it.
- Identifiability. A clear portrait identifies its sitter. A figure in a crowd may not. A caption, a file name or a location tag can turn an anonymous figure into an identified one.
- Life. These laws protect the living. Photographs showing only people who have died fall outside them, though an archive will not always know.
- Context. A picture of a person at a clinic, a place of worship or a political event may reveal sensitive information without a word of caption.
Faces raise a specific point. Recital 51 of the GDPR says the processing of photographs "should not systematically be considered" processing of special categories of data. Photographs count as biometric data "only when processed through a specific technical means allowing the unique identification or authentication of a natural person". Holding a portrait in an archive is not, by that fact alone, biometric processing. Extracting a face template from it to recognise the sitter elsewhere is biometric processing, under much stricter conditions.
What have regulators said about training on images of people?
Two documents from December 2024 set the current frame.
The European Data Protection Board adopted Opinion 28/2024 on 17 December 2024. It describes a three-step test for a developer relying on legitimate interests: identify an interest that is lawful and "real and present", show the processing is necessary for it, and balance it against the rights and reasonable expectations of the people concerned. It adds that models trained on personal data "cannot, in all cases, be considered anonymous", and that a company deploying a model built by someone else should, as part of its accountability, consider whether the model was developed lawfully.
The Information Commissioner's Office published its response to a consultation series on generative AI the same month. It described web scraping as large-scale processing that "often occurs without people being aware of it", which makes it hard for people to exercise their rights, and said it expects developers to "significantly improve their approach to transparency".
Both documents are guidance on how regulators read the law. Neither approves or prohibits training on images of people as a class.
What do the Clearview and LAION episodes show?
Clearview AI built a facial recognition service from images collected across the web. The ICO fined it £7.5 million and issued an enforcement notice in May 2022. A tribunal first held that the ICO lacked jurisdiction. In a judgment the ICO announced on 8 October 2025, the Upper Tribunal reversed that, upholding three of the Commissioner's four grounds and sending the case back for the substantive appeal to be heard. An ICO update of 19 December 2025 records that Clearview was granted permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal, and PPC Land reported that the appeal was listed for hearing from 19 to 21 October 2026. No judgment could be confirmed on the date above.
LAION-5B, an index of several billion image links and captions used in training image models, shows the same risk from another angle. On 10 June 2024 Human Rights Watch reported finding 170 photographs of identifiable Brazilian children among the links, some with names in the caption or address, after reviewing a tiny fraction of the whole. LAION confirmed the finding and undertook to remove them. The dataset had already been withdrawn following a Stanford Internet Observatory report published in December 2023 about links to suspected child sexual abuse material, and a revised version, Re-LAION-5B, was released on 30 August 2024 with 2,236 links removed.
In the United States, a class action against Photobucket, Pierce v Photobucket, alleges that the company planned to license users' photographs for biometric analysis and AI training without valid consent. A law firm alert of April 2026 reports that claims were allowed to proceed. These are allegations, and no decision on the merits has been reached.
The common thread is that pictures of people gathered for one purpose were reused for another, at scale, without the people knowing.
What is decided, and what is still pending?
Decided. Photographs of identifiable living people are personal data. Facial recognition applied to them is biometric processing. UK data protection law can reach an overseas company that monitors UK residents, on the Upper Tribunal's ruling announced on 8 October 2025, which is itself under appeal.
Pending. Clearview's appeal to the Court of Appeal, reported as heard in October 2026; its outcome could not be confirmed on the date above. How regulators will apply the legitimate interests test to particular image models. Whether the UK will create a digital replica or personality right, which the government said in its report of 18 March 2026 it would explore. In the United States, the NO FAKES Act, which would create a federal right over digital replicas of voice and likeness, was reported out of the Senate Judiciary Committee on 18 June 2026 and had not, as far as we could confirm on the date above, been enacted.
How is likeness different from data protection?
Data protection asks whether information about a person is being handled fairly and lawfully. Likeness rights ask whether a person's image is being exploited commercially without consent. The two overlap but are not the same, and they differ sharply by country.
| Question | UK | EU | United States |
|---|---|---|---|
| Is a photo of an identifiable person regulated as personal data? | Yes, UK GDPR | Yes, GDPR | No general federal equivalent; state privacy and biometric laws vary |
| Is there a general right to control commercial use of one's image? | No single right; passing off, privacy and data protection are used | Varies by member state | State rights of publicity, varying widely |
| Is there a specific law on digital replicas? | Not enacted | Not covered here | Federal bill pending; some state laws |
English courts have said more than once that there is no free-standing image right. In Fenty v Arcadia Group [2015] EWCA Civ 3, the singer Rihanna succeeded against a retailer through passing off, because buyers were likely to think she had endorsed a T-shirt bearing her photograph. The Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 adds one narrow protection in section 85: a person who commissions a photograph for private and domestic purposes can prevent copies being issued or shown to the public. Wedding and family commissions are the obvious cases.
What can a licensor of photographs do?
A rights holder cannot grant permissions it does not have, but it can be orderly and candid.
- Classify. Sort images into those with no people, people who cannot be identified, identifiable adults, well-known individuals, children, and sensitive contexts.
- Exclude by default where the risk is plain: children, private occasions, sensitive settings.
- Separate names from pictures. Deliver descriptive captions without identifications unless there is a reason and a basis to include them, as discussed in captioning images for machine learning.
- Review location data. Coordinates can identify a home. The location remover strips GPS from JPEGs and leaves other metadata intact.
- Say what is known about releases, and no more. If no model release is on file, the documentation should say so.
- Restrict uses by contract. Typical terms rule out facial recognition, identification of individuals and the generation of a real person's likeness.
- Keep a removal route. A person who objects should have someone to write to, and the licence should oblige the licensee to act on removals.
The buyer has its own obligations as the party doing the training. The supplier's part is to make those obligations possible to meet. The wider process is set out in what a rights review covers and in the checklist for preparing an archive.
People in the Robert Harper archive
The Robert Harper Photograph Library includes photographs of people: the portraits and music subjects catalogued in the collection, fashion work, and street scenes. It also includes large bodies of work with nobody in the frame at all, among them still life, jewellery, fragrance, food and landscape. Archive.London makes no claim that releases exist for any image. Photographs of identifiable people are reviewed case by case and can be left out of a licence, and subsets without people can be defined from the start. The position is set out under rights and stewardship.
The archive is owned by 825 Ventures Ltd, the owner and rights holder. Licences are negotiated directly with the single rights holder, subject to rights review, and data teams can raise questions about people and likeness at the outset through the AI training data licensing page.
Frequently asked questions
Is a photograph personal data under GDPR?
Yes, if a living person can be identified from it, directly or in combination with other information such as a caption, a name or a location. That is true under both the UK GDPR and the EU GDPR. A photograph in which nobody can be identified, or which shows only people who have died, is not personal data under those laws.
Are photographs of faces biometric data?
Not automatically. Recital 51 of the GDPR says photographs fall within the definition of biometric data only when processed through specific technical means that allow a person to be uniquely identified or authenticated. Storing a portrait is not biometric processing. Running it through facial recognition to identify the sitter is, and that falls under the stricter rules for special category data.
Can images of people be used to train AI under GDPR?
There is no blanket yes or no. A developer needs a lawful basis, and regulators have focused on legitimate interests, which requires a real interest, necessity and a balance against the rights of the people shown. The EDPB and the ICO have both said this needs case-by-case assessment. This is general information, not legal advice.
Does a copyright licence cover the people shown in a photograph?
No. Copyright belongs to the author or their successor and concerns copying the photograph. The person depicted has separate interests: data protection, privacy, and in some places a right of publicity over commercial use of their likeness. A licence from the rights holder grants the first and cannot grant the others.
Is there a right to your own image in UK law?
Not as a single, general right. People have relied on data protection, misuse of private information, passing off where a false endorsement is suggested, and a narrow statutory privacy right in photographs commissioned for private and domestic purposes. The UK government said in March 2026 that it would explore a digital replica or personality right; no such law has been enacted.
Sources
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Recital 51
- EDPB Opinion 28/2024 on data protection aspects of AI models (17 December 2024)
- SCL: ICO responds to consultation series on generative AI
- ICO: UK Upper Tribunal hands down judgment on Clearview AI Inc (8 October 2025, updated 19 December 2025)
- PPC Land: Clearview AI faces Court of Appeal test of £7.5m UK fine (October 2026)
- Human Rights Watch: Brazil, children's personal photos misused to power AI tools (10 June 2024)
- LAION: Releasing Re-LAION-5B (30 August 2024)
- Olshan: Colorado federal court allows privacy and AI training claims to proceed against Photobucket (April 2026)
- Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, section 85
- Reed Smith: UK copyright and AI report, the opt-out is dead
- IPWatchdog: Senate Judiciary moves NO FAKES Act one step closer to passage (18 June 2026)
This article is general information, not legal advice. It reflects the position as we understood it on the date shown and may be out of date. Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

