A box of negatives that smells of vinegar is telling you something exact: the film base is breaking down, the process feeds on itself, and the time to act is before the smell gets strong.
Vinegar syndrome is what happens when the plastic base of acetate film breaks down and gives off acetic acid, the acid in vinegar. The smell is the first symptom and the least of the damage. Behind it, the base is shrinking and stiffening, and the reaction that causes it accelerates as it goes, because the acid it produces drives further breakdown. Left alone in a warm room, an affected negative ends up buckled, brittle and impossible to print or scan flat.
It is the best known way that photographic film decays, and it is one of four that an archive needs to recognise. The others are the decay of nitrate base, the fading of colour dyes, and the ordinary enemies of damp and dirt.
What causes vinegar syndrome?
Film is a sandwich: a light-sensitive emulsion, usually gelatin, coated on a transparent plastic support. From the mid-1920s manufacturers began replacing flammable nitrate supports with cellulose acetate "safety" film, and the Northeast Document Conservation Center's table of film bases lists cellulose triacetate for sheet and roll film from 1945 to the present. A large share of the twentieth century's negatives and transparencies therefore sits on acetate.
Acetate is not chemically stable for ever. In the presence of moisture and warmth its molecules slowly come apart, releasing acetic acid. The Image Permanence Institute's Storage Guide for Acetate Film sets out the course of events in terms of free acidity. Fresh film measures about 0.05. Acidity climbs slowly for many years, and then, at about 0.5, turns sharply upwards. That point is called autocatalytic: the acid already released speeds the reaction that releases more. Film in advanced decay often measures 5 to 10.
The practical meaning of the 0.5 threshold is easy to miss. At that stage the film smells of vinegar but is usually still usable. The Institute's predictions of film life measure the time to reach that point, and after it the decline is much faster.
What are the signs and stages of acetate decay?
The Northeast Document Conservation Center describes six stages for acetate negatives.
| Stage | What you see or smell |
|---|---|
| 1 | No deterioration |
| 2 | Curling; red or blue discolouration on some films |
| 3 | Vinegar odour; shrinkage; brittleness |
| 4 | Warping |
| 5 | Bubbles and crystals in the film |
| 6 | Channelling |
Three of these need a word of explanation. Shrinkage matters because the base contracts and the emulsion does not; the Institute records that it can reach about 10% in advanced cases. Bubbles and crystals are plasticisers, additives that kept the film flexible, migrating out of the base. Channelling is the end state: the emulsion, now too large for its support, lifts into ridges and grooves. It is common on sheet film, and by that stage copying the image has become a job for a specialist.
How do you test for it?
By smell, crudely. By measurement, properly. The Institute makes A-D Strips, paper indicators that change colour in response to acid vapour. A strip is enclosed with the film, left, and read against a scale. The Institute presents the strips as safer and more accurate than smelling the film, and lists three uses: documenting how far vinegar syndrome has gone in a collection, deciding when film should be duplicated, and screening new arrivals before they are shelved beside sound material.
The reading also triggers action. The Institute's Media Storage Quick Reference advises that acetate film with an A-D Strip reading of 2 or more should go into frozen storage and be duplicated as soon as possible.
A survey of this kind fits naturally into the first pass through an archive. When boxes are being counted and listed for a folder-level catalogue, a condition column and a note of any odour cost almost nothing to add.
Does it spread, and can it be stopped?
The honest answer to the first question is that the evidence points to yes, within limits. The Institute's guide notes that acetic acid vapour is readily absorbed by sound film and speeds its deterioration, that in some cases decay appears to have passed from film to film, and that degrading film shut in a closed box with good film is likely to harm it. In a large, well-ventilated room the risk is lower. The Library of Congress accordingly advises isolating deteriorating acetate from other collection items, moving it out of sealed containers into ventilated ones, and keeping the storage area ventilated.
To the second question the answer is no, but it can be slowed almost to a standstill. Temperature and humidity set the rate:
| Storage condition | Predicted years to onset, fresh acetate film |
|---|---|
| 21°C (70°F), 50% RH | About 40 |
| 21°C (70°F), 40% RH | About 50 |
| 16°C (60°F), 40% RH | About 100 |
| 13°C (55°F), 40% RH | About 150 |
| 4°C (40°F), 40% RH | About 450 |
These are the Institute's predictions for fresh film held at constant conditions. Film that has already spent decades in an office does not get those years back, but the proportions hold: the Institute states that film lasts about 17 times longer at minus 1°C than at 21°C. That is the whole case for the cold storage described in the guide to storage conditions for film and prints.
The response to a positive test is therefore a short sequence: isolate, ventilate, cool or freeze, and copy. Copying today usually means scanning, and affected film should go to the front of the queue while it is still flat. For valuable material, or film already in visible decay, consult a photograph conservator before freezing, cleaning or attempting any treatment.
How is nitrate decay different?
Nitrate was the first flexible film base. Eastman Kodak began selling nitrate roll film in August 1889, and according to the Northeast Document Conservation Center its last year of nitrate manufacture varied by product: 1933 for X-ray film, 1938 for 35mm roll film, 1939 for portrait and commercial sheet film, 1949 for film packs, 1950 for roll film in sizes 616 and 620, and 1951 for professional 35mm motion picture film. Those dates are Kodak's alone; other makers differed.
Nitrate decays through its own six stages, from yellowing and silver mirroring, through stickiness and a sharp nitric acid odour, to an amber colour with a fading image, softening that can weld the film to its neighbours, and finally a brownish acid powder. It also carries a hazard that acetate does not. The Library of Congress warns that nitrate is highly flammable, can ignite spontaneously at about 38°C (100°F) and cannot be extinguished once burning. Nitrate should be stored apart from everything else, kept cold, and copied; anyone who finds it in quantity should take specialist advice before moving it.
A studio archive that begins in the 1960s is, on those dates, unlikely to contain camera-original nitrate, but older material collected or copied along the way can turn up in any collection, which is why identification comes first.
What about colour fading and other decay?
Dye fading. The image in colour film is made of organic dyes, and many are unstable. The Image Permanence Institute explains that their molecules break down over time, lowering density and contrast, and that because the cyan, magenta and yellow dyes fade at different rates the colour balance shifts as well. This happens in the dark: no light is needed. Temperature is the controlling factor, with humidity playing a smaller part. The loss is irreversible in the film, though a scan can be corrected to approximate the original balance. Decaying acetate makes matters worse, because the acid it releases speeds fading in dye layers that are sensitive to it.
Polyester. Film on polyester base does not suffer vinegar syndrome, and the Institute rates black-and-white polyester film as suitable for cool storage. A polyester base does nothing to protect colour dyes, which is why colour film on any base is recommended for cold storage.
Damp and handling. High humidity invites mould, which feeds on gelatin, and softens emulsions so that they stick to sleeves. Fingerprints, abrasion and old adhesive tapes do the rest. None of these is exotic, and all are addressed by dry storage, good enclosures and clean handling.
Where this leaves a transparency archive
The Robert Harper Photograph Library's analogue holdings are the kind of material these processes act on: mainly 6 x 7 colour transparency film, with black-and-white negatives, larger-format film and 35mm slides, spanning the 1960s and 1970s to the digital era and browsable by format. The 503-folder inventory records what each folder contains. It is not a condition survey, and nothing here should be read as a statement about the state of any particular film.
What the inventory does establish is that the film is largely unscanned, so for most of those photographs no digital copy yet exists. For film of that age, base decay and dye fading are the reasons a scanning programme has a clock on it. The planning side is covered in the guide to digitising a film archive, and conservators and scanning specialists who work with ageing colour film can find the scope of the project on the digitisation partners page.
Frequently asked questions
What is vinegar syndrome?
It is the slow chemical breakdown of cellulose acetate, the plastic used as the base for most safety film. As the acetate degrades it releases acetic acid, which smells of vinegar. The film then shrinks, becomes brittle and distorts, and the image-bearing emulsion can lift away from the base. It affects only acetate film; nitrate and polyester decay in other ways.
Can vinegar syndrome be reversed?
No. The breakdown of the base cannot be undone, and no treatment restores it. What can be done is to slow it sharply with cold or frozen storage and to copy the image by scanning or duplication while the film is still flat enough to capture. The Image Permanence Institute advises frozen storage and prompt duplication once an A-D Strip reads 2 or more.
Does vinegar syndrome spread from one film to another?
It can harm neighbouring film. The Image Permanence Institute notes that acetic acid vapour is readily absorbed by sound film and speeds its deterioration, and that degrading film in a closed box with good film is likely to damage it. The Library of Congress advises isolating deteriorating acetate, using ventilated containers and keeping the store well ventilated.
How do I test film for vinegar syndrome?
Smell is the first sign but an unreliable measure. A-D Strips, made by the Image Permanence Institute, are paper indicators that change colour according to the acidity of the air around the film. A strip is sealed in the box or can with the film for a set period and then compared with a reference scale. The Institute presents them as safer and more accurate than sniffing.
How do I know whether film is nitrate, acetate or polyester?
Start with the edge printing: the words NITRATE or SAFETY often appear in the margin, though copies can reproduce the marking of an original. Date helps, since nitrate still film was phased out by the early 1950s. Polyester shows red and green interference colours when viewed between crossed polarising filters; nitrate and acetate do not.
Sources
- Image Permanence Institute: IPI Storage Guide for Acetate Film (James M. Reilly, 1993, revised 1996)
- Image Permanence Institute: IPI Media Storage Quick Reference, 2nd edition (2009)
- Northeast Document Conservation Center: Leaflet 5.1, A short guide to film base photographic materials
- Library of Congress: Care, handling and storage of motion picture film
- Image Permanence Institute, filmcare.org: Dye fading
Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

