Cameras, film and formats compared

Tri-X, HP5 and FP4: what three black-and-white films did to a face

A covered boat is moored beside a canal lined with pedestrians and buildings.
Canal-side walkways in Venice.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

Two fast films and one slow one account for a large share of the twentieth century's black-and-white faces. Grain was the price of speed, and then it became the point.

Grain began as the tax a photographer paid for working in bad light, and ended as the reason some of them chose the film.

Tri-X and HP5 are ISO 400 films with visible, traditional grain; FP4 is an ISO 125 film with fine grain and a longer, calmer tonal scale. That is the comparison in one sentence. The more interesting story, and the angle of this piece, is how grain changed sides. It started as the cost of working in poor light and became a look that photographers chose on purpose, to the point where software now adds it back. We set out what each film is, on the makers' own dates, what each does to skin, stone and sky, and what the 2026 changes to Kodak's range actually altered, which for Tri-X is the box and the distributor and nothing else.

What are Tri-X, HP5 and FP4?

Tri-X is Kodak's fast black-and-white negative film. It appeared as sheet film around 1940, rated ASA 200 in daylight, and in 35mm and 120 in 1954. Around 1960 the rating doubled to ASA 400, and the accepted explanation is that the speed standard was revised and the emulsion was not. Two versions are current: Tri-X 400 (400TX) in rolls, and Tri-X 320 (320TXP), which today is a sheet film. In 2007 Kodak re-engineered the film, with finer grain, and the roll version took the code 400TX.

HP5 is Ilford's fast film. The initials go back to the company's Hypersensitive Panchromatic plates of 1931, and the line passed through HP3, which was rated 200 in 1955 and 400 in 1960, and HP4. Ilford's own history dates HP5 to 1976 and the present HP5 Plus to 1989.

FP4 is Ilford's medium-speed film, launched in 1968 and revised as FP4 Plus in 1990. It is rated ISO 125.

All three are what the trade calls traditional or cubic-grain emulsions, as opposed to the tabular-grain films introduced in the 1980s, which are Kodak's T-Max and Ilford's Delta. The makers are a study in contrast themselves. Ilford was founded by Alfred Harman in 1879 to make dry plates; since a management buyout in 2005 its films have been made in Mobberley, Cheshire, by Harman Technology, which was bought by Pemberstone Ventures in 2015. Kodak's films are made in Rochester, New York.

Tri-X vs HP5 vs FP4: how do they compare?

Kodak Tri-X 400 Ilford HP5 Plus Ilford FP4 Plus
Box speed ISO 400 (ISO 320 for sheet-film TXP) ISO 400 ISO 125
First sold Sheet film about 1940; 35mm and 120 in 1954 HP5 in 1976; HP5 Plus in 1989 FP4 in 1968; FP4 Plus in 1990
Grain type Traditional Traditional Traditional, finer
Reputation, by common report Punchy contrast, assertive grain A little softer in the mid-tones, pushes well Smooth tone, high sharpness
Natural territory Reportage, street, portraits with attitude Available light, documentary, learning Studio portrait, still life, landscape
Made by Eastman Kodak, Rochester Harman Technology, Mobberley Harman Technology, Mobberley

The dates and speeds in that table are the makers' and are firm. The reputation row is consensus among users and reviewers, and it is softer evidence. Exposure, developer, dilution, agitation and the enlargement ratio all move the result, and a careful printer can make any of the three imitate its neighbour.

What did each film do to a face?

Grain is the clumping of developed silver, and it is most visible in the even mid-tones of a print. A cheek is an even mid-tone. So is a clear sky and a studio backdrop. This is why a film's character is argued over in portraits more than anywhere else.

On a fast film in 35mm, enlarged to a magazine page, skin acquires a fine tooth. Pores, stubble and lines are drawn with slightly raised contrast. The effect reads as candour, and it suited the hand-held, available-light portrait that the 1960s made fashionable. A slower film on the same face gives a smoother gradient from highlight to shadow and less texture that the sitter did not bring with them. It is kinder, and it needs either more light or a tripod.

Format changes everything, though. Richard Avedon exposed about 17,000 sheets of Tri-X for In the American West between 1979 and 1984, but they were 8 x 10 inch sheets. At that size the grain of a fast film all but disappears and what remains is its tonal behaviour: every freckle and crease resolved, against white. The same emulsion that gives 35mm its grit gives a large sheet an almost forensic clarity. Anyone comparing films should compare them at the same frame size, or they are comparing enlargement. Our note on why 6x7 was called the ideal format does the arithmetic on area.

Which is better for portrait, street and landscape?

Portrait. In a studio with flash there is light to spare, and FP4 Plus or another medium-speed film gives the finest result. By a window, or with a sitter who will not keep still, an ISO 400 film buys two shutter speeds or two stops of depth of field. Between Tri-X and HP5 Plus the choice is taste: a touch more bite or a touch more forgiveness.

Street. Speed wins. An ISO 400 film allows 1/250 second at a middling aperture on a dull British afternoon, and both fast films tolerate the exposure errors that come with working quickly. This is where their reputations were made.

Landscape. The camera is on a tripod and the sky is a large, even tone that shows grain mercilessly. A slower film is the conventional choice, and medium or large format makes more difference than the stock. The archive's own example is a group of black-and-white landscapes made in 1975: the inventory lists 560 frames of scenic views, rustic buildings and off-grid living as black-and-white negatives and contact sheets. Which film they are on has not yet been recorded, and we will not guess; the edge markings will settle it when the negatives are catalogued.

What happens when you push them?

Pushing means rating the film faster than its box speed and developing for longer to compensate. Push processing raises contrast, increases grain and lowers resolution; pulling does the reverse. A 400-speed film pushed two stops to 1600 loses shadow detail first, and the mid-tones take on the gritty look that people often attribute to the film itself.

This matters for anyone reading old negatives. Two rolls of the same stock from the same week can look quite different if one was pushed, and the instruction was usually written on the bag, as our guide to lab markings explains. It matters for scanning too, because a dense, contrasty, pushed negative needs different handling from a thin one. Our guide to scanning black-and-white negatives covers the practical side, including why infrared dust removal does not work on silver film.

Was Tri-X renamed in 2026?

No, and this is worth stating plainly because a year of headlines about Kodak has left some confusion.

What changed is who sells the film. Since 2013 Kodak's still films had been distributed by Kodak Alaris, a separate British company. From October 2025 Eastman Kodak, the manufacturer in Rochester, began taking distribution back in stages. Tri-X and Ektar followed in January 2026, in 135 and 120, in new retro-styled packaging; PetaPixel reported it on 21 January 2026, with availability at first through retailers in the United States and Canada.

What was renamed is Kodak's other black-and-white family. On 24 March 2026 T-Max 100, T-Max 400 and T-Max P3200 became Ektapan 100, Ektapan 400 and Ektapan P3200, and the Portra colour films became Ektacolor Pro. Analog.Cafe's summary was "same film, new boxes", and neither Kodak company has confirmed the reason for the change of names. In May 2026, according to PetaPixel's report of 14 August, Kodak added Tri-X 320 in 4 x 5, 5 x 7 and 8 x 10 inch sheets and Tri-X 400 in 100-foot bulk rolls.

HP5 Plus and FP4 Plus have not changed name or maker. For the wider picture, including colour, see which films you can still buy. We checked these points on 18 November 2026, and distribution in particular is still moving.

Can you add the look afterwards?

Up to a point. Film grain is random and lives in the emulsion, at a scale that depends on the film, the developer and the enlargement. Digital noise is a different pattern with a different relationship to tone. Software grain is a simulation of the first laid over an image that has neither. It can be convincing at screen size, and you can try it on your own picture with our film grain tool, which runs in the browser and uploads nothing.

What simulation cannot supply is the rest of the film's behaviour: the shoulder of the highlights, the way a pushed negative drops its shadows, the response to a red filter. Those are properties of the exposure, and they are fixed on the day.

Where the archive comes in

The Robert Harper Photograph Library is mostly colour: its principal analogue format is 6 x 7 transparency film. But the analogue holdings also include black-and-white negatives and contact sheets, among them the 1975 landscapes above and a folder of black-and-white portraits catalogued at 358 frames in the portraits collection. More than half of the archive is still on film and has yet to be scanned, and identifying each stock from its edge printing is part of that work. If you run a scanning or cataloguing service with experience of silver negatives, the page for digitisation partners says what we are looking for.

Frequently asked questions

Is Tri-X or HP5 better for portraits?

Both are ISO 400 films with traditional grain, and the difference is smaller than their reputations. By common report Tri-X gives a little more contrast and a more assertive grain, while HP5 Plus is slightly softer in the mid-tones and tolerant of pushing. Developer, exposure and format change the result more than the name on the box does.

What is the difference between HP5 and FP4?

Speed and grain. HP5 Plus is rated ISO 400 and FP4 Plus ISO 125, about one and two thirds stops slower. The slower film has finer grain and higher sharpness, which suits studio portraits, still life and landscape on a tripod. The faster one suits hand-held work in available light and can be pushed further.

Has Kodak Tri-X been discontinued or renamed?

No. Tri-X is still made and still called Tri-X. In January 2026 Eastman Kodak began distributing Tri-X in 135 and 120 directly, in new packaging, where Kodak Alaris had distributed it since 2013. The 2026 renaming affected other films: T-Max became Ektapan and Portra became Ektacolor Pro on 24 March 2026.

When did Tri-X come out?

Tri-X first appeared as sheet film around 1940, rated ASA 200 in daylight. The 35mm and 120 roll versions that made its name followed in 1954. Around 1960 the rating became ASA 400 after a change in the speed standard. Kodak re-engineered the film in 2007, when it became 400TX.

Does pushing film increase grain?

Yes. Push processing means underexposing the film and extending development to compensate. It increases contrast and visible grain and reduces resolution. Pull processing does the opposite. A roll of ISO 400 film pushed to 1600 will show noticeably coarser grain and fewer shadow tones than the same film exposed and developed normally.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

Help digitise the archive

52,684 analogue originals, mostly medium-format transparencies, are waiting to be scanned and catalogued. We are speaking to scanning, cataloguing and tagging partners.

See the digitisation briefWrite to the archive