Free-typed keywords decay within a few thousand images. A controlled vocabulary is slower on day one and faster on every day after, provided it is small enough for people to actually use.
Give three cataloguers the same photograph of a pair of shoes and no rules, and you will get "trainers", "sneakers" and "sports footwear". Each is correct. Together they guarantee that no single search finds all three pictures. Multiply by tens of thousands of images and several years, and free-typed keywords stop being an index and become a record of individual habit.
A controlled vocabulary is the remedy: an agreed list in which every concept has one preferred term, and every synonym points to it. This guide sets out how to build one that suits a photographic archive, which published vocabularies are worth borrowing from, and where the keyword field should stop and other fields take over.
What makes a controlled vocabulary different from a list of tags?
Three properties.
One preferred term per concept. The cataloguer chooses from the list and cannot invent. If the term needed is missing, it is proposed, approved and added, not typed ad hoc.
Synonym control. Variants are recorded as non-preferred terms: "sneakers USE trainers", "jewelry USE jewellery". A good search system expands the query, so the user who types the American spelling still finds the British-indexed image. An archive selling internationally may choose to export both spellings into the file for systems that do no expansion.
Relationships. Terms sit in a hierarchy (broader and narrower) and can be linked sideways (related). "Solitaire ring" is narrower than "ring", which is narrower than "jewellery".
The payoff is measured in two familiar terms. Recall is the share of relevant pictures a search finds. Precision is the share of what it finds that is relevant. Uncontrolled tagging damages both at once.
Of and about: the two questions every image answers
Image indexers have long distinguished what a photograph is of from what it is about, a distinction set out in Sara Shatford's work on picture indexing in the 1980s. A studio photograph may be of a perfume bottle, a sheet of glass and a shadow. It may be about luxury, anticipation or minimalism.
Both kinds of term are useful and they behave differently. "Of" terms are checkable against the picture and should be applied consistently. "About" terms are interpretive, are what many commercial buyers search with, and need a short approved list so that they do not multiply. A sensible rule is to require the first kind and ration the second.
A second axis is generic against specific. "Diamond" is generic. A named stone is specific. Both belong, with the specific term applied only where the evidence supports it.
Which published vocabularies are worth using?
| Vocabulary | Maintained by | Strongest for |
|---|---|---|
| Art & Architecture Thesaurus (AAT) | Getty Research Institute | Object types, materials, techniques, styles and periods |
| Thesaurus of Geographic Names (TGN) | Getty Research Institute | Places, including historical names |
| Union List of Artist Names (ULAN) | Getty Research Institute | Artists, photographers, designers, studios |
| Thesaurus for Graphic Materials (TGM) | Library of Congress | Subjects and genre or format terms, designed for indexing pictures |
| IPTC Media Topics | IPTC | News and editorial subject classification |
| Wikidata | Wikimedia community | Stable identifiers for specific people, bands, brands, buildings and events |
None of these will be adopted whole. The practical pattern is a compact house vocabulary, written in the language the archive's users search in, with each term mapped where possible to an identifier in one of the published lists. The mapping is what lets a museum, an aggregator or a dataset buyer reconcile your terms with theirs later.
The IPTC standard has a place for this. Alongside the plain Keywords property (dc:subject), whose definition IPTC revised in version 2024.1 of December 2024, it offers CV-Term About Image, a structure that holds a term together with the identifier of the vocabulary it came from.
How to build a keyword hierarchy for a photographic archive
Start from the questions users ask, and build facets, each a small hierarchy of its own.
- Subject: objects, people as types (model, musician, chef), activities.
- Setting: studio, location, interior, street, landscape.
- Place: country, region, city, district.
- Period: decade at least; year where known.
- Genre and use: still life, portrait, reportage, advertising, editorial.
- Physical format: transparency, negative, contact sheet, Polaroid, print, with film size.
- Technique and look: black-and-white, colour, close-up, backlit, high-key.
- Concept: the rationed "about" list.
For an archive already arranged into subject categories, the top level may exist. The Robert Harper Photograph Library's online catalogue arranges 330 described collections under 24 principal categories, from Fashion and Jewellery to Marine and superyachts, and those headings are a natural first tier. The work is then in the second and third tiers. Under a category such as fragrance, for instance, a cataloguer might need narrower terms for bottle, atomiser, packaging and ingredient, plus brand names held as specific terms. That example is illustrative, not a description of an existing scheme.
Keep it shallow. Three or four levels is as deep as most people will navigate. Write a one-line scope note for any term that could be misread. And appoint one person to approve additions, because a vocabulary with no gatekeeper reverts to free tagging.
What should not go in the keyword field
The keyword list is the wrong home for facts that have fields of their own, covered in the guide to IPTC fields every archive should fill:
- Named people go in Person Shown in the Image. Add a name as a keyword too if your users expect it, but the dedicated field is what makes a name search exact.
- Places go in Location Shown and Location Created.
- Dates go in Date Created.
- Narrative goes in the Description, the subject of writing captions from contact sheets and sleeve notes.
- Rights and restrictions go in the rights fields. A keyword reading "restricted" is not a rights statement.
Avoid three habits in particular: keywords for things not visible or not evidenced, long runs of near-synonyms added to catch searches, and terms that describe the cataloguer's opinion of the picture.
How many keywords, and how to keep them consistent
No standard sets a number. For archive material, eight to twenty-five considered terms is a workable range: enough to cover each facet, few enough that each one was a decision. Stock agencies often ask for more, and a distributor's own requirements should override any house rule on delivery.
Consistency comes from process more than from talent.
- Catalogue at collection level first. A shoot of two hundred frames shares most of its terms. Apply those once to the whole set, then add frame-level terms only where frames differ.
- Sample and audit. Have a second person re-keyword a small sample each month and compare. Disagreements show where the vocabulary or its scope notes are unclear.
- Log changes. When a preferred term changes, update existing records in bulk. Do not let old and new forms coexist.
- Label machine suggestions. Automated tagging can speed up the generic terms, with limits discussed in can AI tag an archive?. Record which terms a person has confirmed.
- Check what reaches the file. Export a few images and open them in the EXIF and metadata viewer to confirm that keywords, including parent terms, are embedded as intended.
An archive at the start of its keywording
Keywording is the stage that turns scans into a searchable library, and for the Robert Harper archive most of it lies ahead: 52,684 analogue images, by the archive's inventory count, largely await digitisation and metadata cataloguing. The collection descriptions and category structure online are the base to build on. Cataloguing specialists, vocabulary consultants and tagging vendors who would like to propose an approach or a pilot will find the brief on the digitisation partners page.
Frequently asked questions
What is a controlled vocabulary in photo keywording?
It is an agreed list of terms that cataloguers must choose from, with one preferred term for each concept and its synonyms and variant spellings recorded against it. It stops the same subject being tagged five different ways, which is what makes search return everything relevant and little that is not.
How many keywords should an archive photograph have?
There is no standard figure. A workable range for archive material is roughly eight to twenty-five well-chosen terms covering subject, setting, period, format and concept. Past that point added terms tend to be guesses or near-duplicates, which lower search precision. Consistency across the collection matters more than the count on any one image.
Which controlled vocabulary is best for photographs?
No single list covers everything. The Getty Art & Architecture Thesaurus is strong on objects, materials and techniques; the Library of Congress Thesaurus for Graphic Materials was built for indexing pictures; IPTC Media Topics suits news subjects; Wikidata provides identifiers for specific people, places and brands. Most archives combine a small house vocabulary with links to one or two of these.
Should keywords be hierarchical or flat?
Build and maintain them as a hierarchy, and export them flat. A hierarchy lets a cataloguer pick 'brooch' and have 'jewellery' applied automatically. The IPTC Keywords field is a flat list, so parent terms should be written out on export so that systems which ignore hierarchy can still find the image.
Where are keywords stored in an image file?
In the IPTC Keywords property, which is dc:subject in XMP, with a legacy copy in the older IIM block that some software still reads. Hierarchical paths are often stored in a separate software-specific XMP field. A metadata viewer will show which of these a file contains.
Sources
- IPTC Photo Metadata Standard (version history, including 2024.1 Keywords revision)
- IPTC Photo Metadata Standard 2025.1 specification
- Getty Research Institute: Art & Architecture Thesaurus
- Library of Congress: Thesaurus for Graphic Materials
Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

