Cameras, film and formats compared

Rolleiflex or Hasselblad: the twin-lens and the SLR

Orange light breaks through dark clouds above a silhouetted horizon.
Sunset beneath layered clouds.Photograph by Robert Harper. Robert Harper Photograph Library, Archive.London. From the archive, shown for illustration.

Both make twelve square pictures on a roll and both are looked down into. The difference is what happens at the instant of exposure: one camera goes dark and makes a noise, the other does neither.

The Rolleiflex never stops looking at the sitter; the Hasselblad blinks, and in exchange for the blink gives you every lens in the catalogue.

The Rolleiflex is a twin-lens reflex introduced in 1929. The Hasselblad 500C is a single-lens reflex introduced in 1957. Both make 6x6 pictures on 120 film, twelve to a roll, and both are normally used at waist level with the photographer looking down into a hood. The plan for this article proposed that sitters behaved differently because one was a waist-level camera and the other was not. That is not quite right, since both are, so we have sharpened the angle. The real difference lies in the fraction of a second when the picture is taken. The Rolleiflex keeps showing its user the subject throughout and makes almost no sound. The Hasselblad goes dark and announces itself. What each photographer could see and each sitter could hear at that moment shaped two schools of portraiture, and two very different pieces of equipment for anyone buying one today.

This article is general information, not financial or legal advice.

What is the difference between a Rolleiflex and a Hasselblad?

Rolleiflex (2.8F and 3.5F) Hasselblad 500C and 500C/M
Type Twin-lens reflex Single-lens reflex, modular
Maker and origin Franke & Heidecke, Germany Victor Hasselblad AB, Sweden
First of line 1929 1948 (1600F); 500C in 1957
Model dates 2.8F from June 1960; 3.5F from 1958 500C 1957 to 1970; 500C/M 1970 to 1994
Lens Fixed: 75 mm f/3.5 or 80 mm f/2.8, Zeiss Planar or Schneider Xenotar Interchangeable, each with its own leaf shutter
Shutter Leaf, 1 s to 1/500 Leaf, in the lens
Flash sync All speeds All speeds
View during exposure Continuous Blacked out
Film 120, 12 frames of 6x6 120, 12 frames of 6x6 per magazine
Change film mid-roll No Yes, by swapping magazines
Parallax at close range Yes None
Image on screen Reversed left to right Reversed left to right

The table already tells most of the story. The cameras agree about the picture, its size, shape and shutter type, and disagree about everything around it.

How does a twin-lens reflex work, and what does it do well?

A twin-lens reflex is two cameras stacked. The lower lens exposes the film. The upper lens, of the same focal length, throws its image onto a fixed mirror set at 45 degrees and up to a ground-glass screen. The two lenses are geared to move together, so what is sharp on the screen is sharp on the film.

Because the mirror never moves, a set of advantages follows that no reflex camera with a single lens can match:

  • The viewfinder image stays visible during the exposure. The photographer sees the blink, the flinch or the smile as it is recorded.
  • There is almost no delay between pressing the button and the shutter firing, since nothing has to get out of the way first.
  • The only moving part at the moment of exposure is a small leaf shutter between the lens elements, which is quiet and synchronises with flash at every speed.
  • The mechanism is simpler than an SLR's and has less to go wrong.

The Rolleiflex set the pattern. Its Automat of 1937 advanced the film and counted frames with a single crank, and by the time of the F models of the late 1950s and 1960s it was a refined, dense, self-contained instrument, with a Compur shutter running from 1 second to 1/500. The design was popular with portrait studios and press photographers, particularly from the 1940s to the 1960s. Robert Capa used an early Rolleiflex during the Second World War. Don McCullin's first serious camera was its cheaper sibling, a Rolleicord, bought for 30 pounds during his National Service in Nairobi.

The limitations are equally intrinsic. The viewing lens sits above the taking lens, so at close range the two see different pictures: parallax. The lens cannot be changed. Depth of field cannot be previewed. And the image on the screen is reversed left to right, which makes following a moving subject an acquired skill.

What did Hasselblad change with the 500C?

Victor Hasselblad's first civilian camera, the 1600F of 1948, was already a modular single-lens reflex with a focal-plane shutter. The company's own history describes the step that made its name: the 500C of 1957 replaced that shutter with a leaf shutter inside each lens, which gave electronic flash synchronisation at all speeds and automatic stop-down so the photographer could focus at full aperture.

Putting the shutter in the lens also freed the rest of the camera to come apart. Lenses, film magazines and viewfinders became interchangeable. A photographer could go from a wide-angle to a portrait lens, from black and white to colour in the middle of a roll, from a waist-level hood to a prism, and could fit an instant-film back to check lighting before committing film. Hasselblad made roughly 76,700 of the 500C between 1957 and 1970, when the 500C/M added a user-changeable focusing screen.

What the photographer sees through a Hasselblad is exactly what the film will record, at any distance and through any lens. That solved parallax and made close-up, product and fashion work precise. The cost is the moment of exposure itself. The mirror swings up, auxiliary shutters behind it open, the lens shutter closes, stops down and fires: a sequence you can hear across a room, after which the screen stays dark until the film is wound on.

The design's reputation for reliability was sealed above the atmosphere. Modified 500C cameras flew on the last two Project Mercury missions in 1962 and 1963, and Apollo 11 carried three motorised 500ELs.

Did sitters really behave differently in front of each?

Camera design constrains behaviour; it does not dictate it. With that caution, three physical facts are worth setting out, because they are true of the machines and need no anecdote.

First, both cameras leave the photographer's face uncovered. Someone using an eye-level camera hides behind it. Someone using a waist-level camera looks down to focus and then, very often, looks up and talks. The sitter is dealing with a person.

Second, only the twin-lens camera lets the photographer watch the exposure happen. With a Rolleiflex, attention can stay on the sitter without interruption. With a Hasselblad there is a blind interval at exactly the decisive point, and experienced users learn to look over the camera at the subject as they press the release.

Third, the sound. A leaf shutter alone is a faint click. A medium format mirror is not. A sitter always knows when a Hasselblad has taken the picture, which can be useful with professional models, who work to the rhythm of the shutter, and less so with someone unused to being photographed.

The documented record fits these facts without proving a rule. Diane Arbus moved from a 35mm Nikon to a twin-lens Rolleiflex around 1962, saying she had become "terribly hyped on clarity", and from 1964 also used a twin-lens Mamiyaflex with flash. Her portraits are frontal, square and centred, and the critic Peter Schjeldahl wrote of her in 2005: "She didn't gaze at her subjects; she induced them to gaze at her." Vivian Maier, by the account of the collection that holds her work, bought a Rolleiflex in 1952 and made her street portraits with it for years, a camera held low and quiet enough to pass unremarked.

The Hasselblad, for its part, became the instrument of the commissioned sitting: studio flash, changes of lens and film, and a proof to show the client. That is a different kind of portrait, and the camera suits it.

Which is better for portraits, still life and travel?

  • Portraits of people who are not used to cameras: the Rolleiflex. It is small, quiet and continuous, and its one lens removes a decision.
  • Head-and-shoulders portraits and anything closer: the Hasselblad, with a 150 mm lens and no parallax.
  • Still life, product and close-up: the Hasselblad, without contest. Exact framing and interchangeable lenses and backs are what the work requires.
  • Travel and walking about: the Rolleiflex. One object, no bag of accessories, twelve frames and a crank.

Either way you will be composing squares, and may want to see how they crop to a page with the aspect ratio calculator. For the rectangular alternatives, see our comparison of the Hasselblad 500C/M, Mamiya RZ67 and Pentax 67.

What should collectors and buyers know?

Both cameras are old. The youngest Rolleiflex 2.8F and the youngest 500C/M are decades past their manufacture, and their value as tools depends on condition, not legend.

With a Rolleiflex, the taking lens is the camera. It cannot be replaced by buying another lens, so haze, scratches or separation in that one piece of glass matter more than on any system camera. The shutter and the focusing mechanism are the other points a technician will check.

With a Hasselblad, you are assessing several objects. Each lens has its own shutter. Each magazine has light seals that perish. Body and lens must be in the same cocked state when separated. A complete outfit that has been serviced is worth more attention than a bargain body with an unknown lens.

In both cases provenance adds interest: who owned a camera and what was made with it. The questions to ask about a camera's history are much the same as those for a print, set out in our piece on photograph provenance. We quote no prices, because condition varies too widely for any figure to be useful.

Where does the Robert Harper archive come in?

The Robert Harper Photograph Library holds portraits whose catalogued subjects include Robert De Niro, Sir Bobby Charlton, Sir Hardy Amies, Ken Russell, Paul Whitehouse, Anthony Powell, Candida Crewe, Zerbanoo Gifford and Anton Lesser, and one inventory folder alone records 358 black-and-white frames of portraits and people. They are introduced on the portraits collection page.

Harper trained in the world this article describes. He spent two years at the Condé Nast studios assisting David Bailey, Helmut Newton and Lester Bookbinder, before working as a freelance assistant and then opening his own London studio. The inventory records formats, not camera bodies, and we do not claim to know which instrument made which portrait; the 2025 inventory gives 6 x 7 transparency film as the principal analogue format, with black-and-white negatives and contact sheets alongside. The archive's small cameras and film collection shows the apparatus as subject matter.

For the public record on the photographers named here and many others, see our index of photographers, and for places to see portrait photography on the wall, the photography directory. Curators and researchers interested in the portrait holdings can enquire about professional access.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a Rolleiflex and a Hasselblad?

A Rolleiflex is a twin-lens reflex: one lens for viewing, one fixed lens for taking, in a single compact body. A Hasselblad 500-series camera is a single-lens reflex built from separate modules: body, interchangeable lens, film magazine and finder. Both make 6x6 pictures on 120 film. The Rolleiflex is quieter and simpler; the Hasselblad is a system.

Is a Rolleiflex good for portraits?

Yes, within its limits. Its leaf shutter is quiet, the viewfinder never blacks out, and the photographer's face stays visible to the sitter because the camera is held at the waist or chest. The fixed 75 or 80 mm lens gives a natural half-length view. For tight head shots, parallax between the two lenses and the lack of a longer lens become obstacles.

Why does a Hasselblad viewfinder go black when you take a picture?

Because the same lens serves for viewing and for taking. A mirror reflects the image up to the focusing screen; to expose the film the mirror must swing out of the way, and on the 500-series cameras it stays up until the film is wound on. A twin-lens reflex has a separate viewing lens and a fixed mirror, so its screen never goes dark.

What is parallax on a twin-lens reflex?

The viewing lens sits a few centimetres above the taking lens, so the two see slightly different pictures. At a distance the difference is negligible. Close to the subject, the film records a view a little lower than the one on the screen, and a carefully framed head can lose its top. Later Rolleiflexes compensate partially within the finder.

Which is the better buy for a collector, Rolleiflex or Hasselblad?

Neither can be called better in general. Condition, service history, lens condition and completeness matter far more than the name, and both are decades old. A Rolleiflex is one self-contained object; a Hasselblad is a body plus lenses, backs and finders that each need assessing. This article is general information, not financial or legal advice.

Sources

Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

Help digitise the archive

52,684 analogue originals, mostly medium-format transparencies, are waiting to be scanned and catalogued. We are speaking to scanning, cataloguing and tagging partners.

See the digitisation briefWrite to the archive