Gifts, bequests, Acceptance in Lieu and the Cultural Gifts Scheme all end with photographs in a public collection. They begin in very different places, and the museum's answer is not always yes.
Giving a collection to a museum is less like handing over a present and more like applying for a job on the object's behalf.
In September 2024, National Museums Scotland announced that it had been allocated more than 17,000 photographic objects, among them some 11,000 stereographs and 200 stereoscopes, collected over four decades by Bernard and Alma Howarth-Loomes. (The Arts Council's 2023 report, which records the case, puts the stereographs at 13,000.) The museum did not buy it in the ordinary sense. The collection had been accepted by the government in lieu of inheritance tax, settling £375,970 of it.
That is one of four ways photographs reach a public collection in the UK: a plain gift, a bequest, Acceptance in Lieu, and the Cultural Gifts Scheme. Guides to them tend to be written by tax advisers and start from the relief. Our angle starts from the other end: what each route asks of the owner, and what the museum on the receiving side says it wants, taken from the published guidance and policies with their dates.
This article is general information, not financial or legal advice. It is not tax advice either. Checked on 18 November 2026. Anyone considering one of these routes needs a professional adviser and an early conversation with the institution.
What are the four routes?
| Route | When | What the owner receives | Who decides | Main test |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gift | In life | Nothing from the state under this route; the satisfaction of a home for the work | The museum | Fit with its collecting policy |
| Bequest | By will | Gifts to charities are generally exempt from inheritance tax | The museum, which may decline | Fit with its collecting policy |
| Acceptance in Lieu | After a death | Inheritance tax settled with the object | Ministers, on the Panel's advice | Pre-eminence, condition, fair value |
| Cultural Gifts Scheme | In life | Reduction in income tax, capital gains tax or corporation tax | Ministers, on the Panel's advice | Pre-eminence, condition, fair value |
The first two are private arrangements between an owner and an institution. The second two are national schemes administered by Arts Council England, in which the object passes to the nation and is then allocated to a museum, library or archive.
How does Acceptance in Lieu work, and has it been used for photographs?
Acceptance in Lieu lets those liable for inheritance tax pay some or all of it with an object instead of cash. The Arts Council's annual report sets out what the Acceptance in Lieu Panel considers: whether the object or collection is pre-eminent under one of four heads (association with national history, artistic or art-historical interest, importance for study, or association with a particular historic setting), whether it is in acceptable condition, and whether it is fairly valued.
There is an incentive for the estate. As a tax guide by Rawlinson & Hunter published in October 2018 explains it, the credit is the object's open market value, less the inheritance tax that would have been due on it, plus a sweetener, known as the douceur, of 25 per cent of that tax. On their worked example an object worth £100,000 settles £70,000 of tax. By our own simple arithmetic, not theirs, a sale at that price with inheritance tax at 40 per cent would leave £60,000 before selling costs. Rates and rules change, so treat that as an illustration of the mechanism only.
The scheme is not confined to Old Masters. In the year to 31 March 2023 the Arts Council reported 48 completed cases across both schemes, bringing objects valued at over £52 million into public ownership and settling £34.2 million of tax. Photographic cases recorded in the Arts Council's reporting include:
- The Bernard Howarth-Loomes collection of early photography and equipment, allocated to National Museums Scotland, where it had been on long-term loan since 2002.
- The Janette Rosing collection of more than 3,800 photographs of Cornwall from the early 1850s to the early 1900s, including work by or attributed to Linnaeus Tripe, allocated to Kresen Kernow, the county's archive centre.
- The archive of the sculptor Edward Allington, including extensive photographic documentation of his work, temporarily allocated to Tate.
Two things stand out. Collections and archives qualify as wholes, not only single masterpieces. And each of these went somewhere with a reason to want it: Cornish photographs to Cornwall, a collection long on loan to the museum that already knew it.
Where an object is worth more in tax terms than the estate owes, the same report notes that the receiving institution, sometimes with grants, may make up the difference, or the offeror may waive it.
How does the Cultural Gifts Scheme work for living donors?
The Cultural Gifts Scheme, launched in March 2013 under Schedule 14 to the Finance Act 2012, is the lifetime equivalent. The government's guidance of 27 January 2015 gives the terms:
- Individuals receive a tax reduction of up to 30 per cent of the agreed value, against income tax or capital gains tax, which may be spread across up to five tax years starting with the year the offer is registered.
- Companies receive up to 20 per cent against corporation tax, in the accounting period in which the offer is registered, with no spreading.
- No capital gains tax or inheritance tax arises on the gift itself, subject to the rules in the Schedule.
- The value is fair market value at the date the offer is registered. The applicant has to justify it with evidence and the Panel may propose a different figure.
- The two schemes share one limit: £40 million of tax per tax year.
The steps run in a fixed order: a written application to the Arts Council; registration, normally within 30 days of complete information; assessment by the Panel; a recommendation to the minister; a letter of acceptance, which the donor has 30 days to accept; transfer of title; and only then the tax reduction.
The rules are about to loosen slightly. An HMRC policy paper first published on 13 July 2026 and updated on 28 October 2026 sets out changes taking effect from 6 April 2027. Joint owners will each be able to claim relief on their share of an object, where joint ownership has until now been a bar. And donors will have one opportunity, within the five-year period, to amend how their remaining tax reduction is allocated, where the present guidance says a schedule cannot be revised and unused amounts fall away.
What do museums say they want from a gift?
A national scheme can only place an object with an institution prepared to take it, and a plain gift depends entirely on that. So the museum's published policy is the document to read first.
The V&A's collecting policy, signed off by its trustees in January 2025 and running to 2029, is a good guide to the questions any large museum asks:
- Fit. The item has to serve the museum's mission and stated priorities. For photography the V&A names international work by emerging and mid-career artists, with attention to contemporary digital practice.
- Title. The museum has to be satisfied that it can acquire valid title.
- Condition. If necessary preservation measures are not feasible, an item will not normally be acquired.
- Storage and access. If suitable storage is not available, or public access cannot be provided, the same applies.
- Rights. Where copyright applies, the owner should be identified wherever possible and a licence obtained.
- Cost. The total cost, including conservation, documentation, imaging, curation, display and storage, should be considered.
- Conditions. A gift or bequest made subject to any condition is referred upwards for decision.
The National Portrait Gallery's guidance for people offering portraits is franker still. It describes itself as selective, not comprehensive. It asks whether the sitter is already well represented, whether there is a better home elsewhere and whether storage costs are manageable. It wants evidence of ownership, any information on copyright, and an image first. Photographs are usually decided by its curatorial acquisitions group, which meets quarterly.
None of this is unfriendly. A museum that accepts a collection is taking on its care indefinitely, and the kindest answer to an unsuitable offer is a quick no with a suggestion of where to try next. Our photography directory lists museums, galleries and collecting institutions by place and specialism, which helps in finding the one with a reason to say yes.
What should an owner prepare before approaching anyone?
The same file serves all four routes.
- An inventory: what there is, in what formats, in what quantities. A method is in how to survey a photographer's archive.
- Evidence of ownership of the physical objects.
- A clear statement on copyright: who holds it, and whether it is being given, licensed or kept. Print and copyright are separate properties.
- Provenance and significance: publication, exhibition and biographical records that support a case for pre-eminence or for fit.
- A condition summary, honest about problems. Poor condition makes rejection likely under the national schemes.
- A view on value with evidence, if a scheme is in prospect. The general method is in how photographic archives are valued.
- A preferred home and a second choice, each chosen by reading the institution's collecting policy.
- Pictures of the pictures. The National Portrait Gallery asks for an image first, and so will everyone else. For a group of works, our free contact sheet maker lays reference scans out as one indexed sheet in the browser, which is easier for a curator to assess than forty attachments.
Keep the material insured and properly stored while an offer is pending. The National Portrait Gallery, for one, expects the offerer's insurance to cover a work while it is under consideration; our piece on insuring a photographic archive sets out what an underwriter will ask.
Where does a commercially owned archive fit?
Not every archive is headed for a museum store, and not every relationship with a museum is a transfer of ownership. Loans, exhibitions, research access and licensing for publication all put photographs before the public while the owner continues to care for and develop the collection.
That is the position of the Robert Harper Photograph Library. It is owned by 825 Ventures Ltd, the owner and rights holder, and Archive.London is seeking exhibition, publishing, digitisation and cataloguing partners for it; our rights and stewardship page sets out how the archive is held and described. More than half of it is still on film and has yet to be scanned, which is the stage at which institutional advice is most useful. We make no statement here about any future gift or scheme.
Curators, museum photography departments and exhibition organisers who would like to discuss the material are welcome to contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Can a photograph archive be accepted in lieu of inheritance tax?
Yes, if it meets the test of pre-eminence and is in acceptable condition. Recent examples include the Bernard Howarth-Loomes collection of more than 17,000 photographic objects, allocated to National Museums Scotland, and Janette Rosing's collection of more than 3,800 Cornish photographs, allocated to Kresen Kernow. The Acceptance in Lieu Panel advises ministers on each offer.
What is the difference between Acceptance in Lieu and the Cultural Gifts Scheme?
Acceptance in Lieu settles an inheritance tax bill with an object after a death. The Cultural Gifts Scheme is for the living: a donor gives a pre-eminent object to the nation and receives a reduction in income tax, capital gains tax or, for companies, corporation tax. Both are administered by Arts Council England and share one annual limit.
Do museums accept every gift of photographs?
No. Museums acquire against a written policy and decline material that does not fit, duplicates what they hold, lacks clear title or would cost more to store and conserve than they can justify. The V&A's policy states that an item will not normally be acquired if suitable storage or necessary preservation is not feasible.
Does giving photographs to a museum transfer the copyright?
Not unless the copyright is expressly assigned. Ownership of a print or negative and ownership of the copyright are separate. Museums ask who holds the copyright and usually seek a licence to reproduce the work. The National Portrait Gallery asks offerers to say whether copyright is included.
Can a donor choose which museum receives the gift?
Under the Cultural Gifts Scheme a donor may name a preferred eligible institution, but it is not guaranteed. The Panel considers the institution's collecting policy, existing holdings, public access, standards of care and regional spread. If the preferred home is unsuitable the donor may name another, and failing agreement the object is advertised.
Sources
- Department for Culture, Media and Sport: Cultural Gifts Scheme guidance (27 January 2015)
- Arts Council England: Cultural Gifts Scheme
- Arts Council England: Cultural Gifts Scheme and Acceptance in Lieu Report 2023
- HM Revenue and Customs: Reforming the Cultural Gift Scheme (published 13 July 2026, updated 28 October 2026)
- National Museums Scotland: Major collection of photography spanning a century is saved for the nation (9 September 2024)
- Lyon & Turnbull: Art and philanthropy, a UK tax guide (Rawlinson & Hunter, 16 October 2018)
- [V&A Collecting Policy 2025 (signed off by the Board of Trustees, January 2025)](https://vanda-production-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/2025/08/26/13/42/22/c50582b5-a8fa-4591-9d49-ee29a828ac9d/V&A Collecting Policy 2025.pdf)
- National Portrait Gallery: Offering a portrait to the National Portrait Gallery
Published by Archive.London. Corrections are welcome under our editorial policy.

